Lever Action Options

Status
Not open for further replies.

Anotherguy

Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2007
Messages
152
I want to pick up a lever action in .357 magnum. It will be used primarily as a fun gun for plinking at the range. I have zero experience when it comes to lever action rifles and have never even shot one. So far I am leaning towards the Marlin. I like the Winchester but I think the cost would be more than I am prepared to spend. There are a few other options; Henry, Puma, Uberti and probably some others that I'm not aware of. Of these mentioned are there any I should stay away from? Any opinions on quality, sights, etc.?
 
The Marlin would be an excellent choice, and the .357 magnum really comes alive in a rifle. They are fun and relatively cheap to shoot. Low maintainance, rugged, dependable...what else could you ask for?

Winchesters are generally not recommended due to being designed for a rifle cartridge, but many enjoy their's as well.
 
The Marlin is a very good rifle, accuracy is good functions nice and you can remove the bolt assembley just one thing i dont like is the big thick forend.

The 94 win is a very tough and reliable rifle strong as anything else out there light weight probley doesn't function as smooth as the marlin but it will depend on what you do with it.

Either way they are both great rugged and tough guns and you will enjoy them both
once you choose which brand then you'll have to pick a model ha ha lol.
 
I bought an older Marlin 1894C and I'm glad I did. It's a extremely reliable rifle with a smooth lever. There are others out there but you won't go wrong with a Marlin IMO.
 
I also have the Marlin and highly recommend it. Not only is it accurate, but, by removing the lever screw, the lever and bolt can be removed to clean the barrel from the breech end.
 
Well, I went down to my local gun shop today just to see how they feel in my hands and I am blown away at how lightweight they are yet at the same time how solid they feel. They 're so handy and comfortable. My gun shop had all of the brands I mentioned in my original post and I must say they all felt a little different but they all felt good even the lowest priced one which was a Puma. It was a 16" and I swear it felt like I was holding a BB or pellet rifle. I think I prefer an 18" to 20" barrel length. The Uberti had by far the smoothest action of all and I like the case hardened finish but the price was out of my reach at the moment. The Henrys they had were all in the shiny gold finish which doesn't appeal to my taste but the one I handled had an excellent trigger. I guess I was uninformed about the price of the Winchester versus the Marlin because they're comparable. I have to say I like the Marlin better though. It just felt more solid, hard to put into words exactly why. They had an 1894 Cowboy which I preferred over the 1894C, I don't care for the checkered wood and like the octagonal barrel of the Cowboy model. Maybe that has something to do with why I preferred the Cowboy, the barrel is probably slightly heavier, I don't know. Thanks to everyone who offered an opinion on this subject. I do have one more question if you'll indulge me; are there any jamming problems when shooting .38 special out of these rifles or is this a non issue? Now I'm asking myself why it took me so long to notice how cool a lever action can be.
 
Handling of .38 seems to be rather gun-specific. Most seem to do OK, but I don't think anybody can guarantee you anything on that.


If I were buying one used, I'd think about asking the seller to cycle some through the action for me if at all possible.
 
I would go with the Puma. The action is a copy of the Winchester 92 action. They handle like a dream too. I just bought one in .454 and am looking for a used .357 for the wife.
 
What upsets me about the Puma is that all the 16" .357s I've seen have the large loop lever which I do not want. If it wasn't for that I would have bought one already.
 
Lever Actions Options

I have just purchased a Puma Lever action .357 with a 16 inch small standard lever and to it to the farm to sight it in and at 100 yards does okbut, a little below the bulls eye and also nice groups. Rich642z,Omaha,Ne.:):):):):)
 
I shoot .38 Sp ammo through my Marlin all the time and it's a non-issue. I've shot all different brands too and at least 1,000 rounds so I'm guessing that a good enough test. (for my rifle at least)

I was looking at both the 1894C and the Cowboy Marlins but wasn't sure which to buy. An older used 1894C made up my mind. This one has the straight stock, older style front and holds only 6 rounds in the tube. It's older but it's in great shape and came with a scope and really nice leather strap so I bought it for the $300 the dealer wanted. (I took the scope off as soon as I got home LOL)
 
I have just purchased a Puma Lever action .357 with a 16 inch small standard lever and to it to the farm to sight it in and at 100 yards does okbut, a little below the bulls eye and also nice groups. Rich642z,Omaha,Ne.

Really???

Hmm... Guess I'll do a bit of searching for one myself.

EDIT: Yup, looks like they have a NEW model in 16" with the small standard lever. Bout dang time, looks like I have to start saving up for one...

Thanks for the heads up rich.
 
Samuraigg, I see your in the SW suburbs of Chicago.
The Puma I handled today had the small standard lever with a 16" barrel. It's at GAT Guns in West Dundee.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top