A couple more options:
The Delaware ODNR range (10 minutes north of Delaware off of rte. 23). Kind of run down (IMHO), but only costs $3.
Tri-County (Amanda). Nice private range, membership required. About 20 miles or so south of Lancaster on rte. 22.
Pickaway County Sportsman's Club. Just north of Circleville on Rte. 22, a nice range with pistol & rifle comps, CMP clinics and so forth.
Don't have numbers in front of me, but you can go to
www.wheretoshoot.org and find them I believe.
I looked long, far and wide for good ranges, and there are precious few in the Columbus area, unfortunately. So, I got disgusted and bought 44 acres!
There's only 1 range idiot where I shoot, and that's me!
BTW, New Albany is a nice indoor range, but it's expensive, crowded and the staff can be jerks at times. Powder room is more easy going, but the ventilation system leaves much to be desired..cough...cough. Haven't been to Buckeye in Lancaster so I don't know about it.
Nice to see so many fellow central Ohioans here. We should have a get-together some time.