Man kills 500 lb wounded bear with knife as it attacks him.

Status
Not open for further replies.

d2wing

Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
6,419
Last weekend in Minnesota, an archer shot a 500+ black bear. Normally you would wait overnight to track it. Because of the hot weather a few guys started to track it. a pair of guys got close and the bear attacked one of them. As it pounded on him breaking his arm and gashing him he stabbed it repeatedly with his hunting knife. After about 20 stab wounds the bear backed off, went a few feet away and died. I don't know why the other guy didn't help up to that point. The other guy made pressure bandages and helped the guy walk 3 miles or so to call for help. he was hurt pretty bad but walked out.
It is pretty amazing that he was able to kill the bear with his knife and won. But there were two mistakes, tracking too soon and not being armed. I am not sure if the DNR allows bow hunters to carry but I sure would.
 
He sounds like a tuff man . I wouldn't want to me him in a dark alley ?
 
He has several broken bones including an arm but expects to deer hunt in a month.
 
Without any more info than that, I don't imagine the guy killed it with his knife.

No, it probably died from the archery wound. Doubtful that the knife wounds did much more than fend the bear off of a more prolonged attack.

It was likely mortally wounded through some vitals by the arrow, but still made its way through a knife fight before biting the dust.

As for the hunter, definitely not smart to track that wounded bear prematurely and lightly armed, but kudos on scrapping it out hand-to-hand with an attacking bear!
 
I am not sure if the DNR allows bow hunters to carry but I sure would.

MN DNR handbook says that "a person may take bear, elk, and moose by archery while in possession of a firearm."
 
Maybe more information will come out. Magazine article or book? The news report was sketchy.
 
Desidog that is the same story but it happened in Minnesota. The link in that story is to a local station.
The guy is out of the hospital today. He hasn't talked on camera. But his friends say he is going deer hunting. He has both arms broken according to one report.
Go to the Kare11 Link. That has the correct story.
 
I had a black bear on my trail camera recently. I keep s XDs on my hip while bow hunting for that reason.

Thankfully my state allows carrying on private land while bow hunting.
 
IMHO if I were hunting a 525 pound bear I would have done it a little differently but it's a free country. Got to hand it to the guy. Killing a big bear up close and personal with a knife is something not every gets to tell his grand kids.
 
bear

Lucky he didn't read all the good advice on the Hunting Knife thread extolling
the virtues of short bladed knives.
 
Just watched the news clip.amazing storey ! Ill second OYE .
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but those guys were idiots.

Shot the bear poorly before dark and the bear ran off. Well after dark, four hours later, they opted to go look for it unarmed (have to wonder if beer was involved in the decision-making process). They ASSUMED the bear would be dead by then. They were reportedly following a blood trail in heavy brush and swamp. The bear attempted to stop the first attacker that came upon it (it is the hunters who are the aggressors, not the bear, LOL). The hunter, Brandon Johnson described the bear as "coming out of the dark." Yep, that is the way it works in the dark when you just have a flashlight. So the bear gets on Brandon and wounds him just about on all areas of his body and in the process, Johnson stabs the bear a LOT of times. The bear wanders off and dies about 50 yards distant.

The nearest hunter in the search that was "following the blood trail" hears Brandon being attacked and screaming for 2 or more minutes. By the time he finally reaches Brandon, the bear was gone. Here I have to wonder that if they were following a blood trail, why the hunters were separated by such a great distance that it literally took minutes for the first hunter to get to Brandon. This guy, Craig Lindstrom, is a trained first responder fireman and applies tourniquets to both arms. Brandon has 2 broken arms, dislocated wrist, lacerations and bites to arms, legs, body, face, and neck. The tracking party then walk Brandon back to camp where they call 911. This was 3 HOURS after the attack occurred, badly busting the proverbial golden hour.

Why Lindstrom didn't send somebody ahead to call 911 is bothersome, unless maybe it was just him and Brandon looking for this bear. Don't know, but if there was more in the party, somebody should have been sent to make that call. Read numerous accounts of the incident and Lindstrom never says how many were actually looking for the bear, but there were at least 11 in the total hunting party based on the trophy pic that shows 10 with the bear (Brandon was in the hospital when they finally got the bear out).

The whole event was a series of screw-ups and bad decisions. Fortunately, Brandon Johnson managed to survive.

http://kstp.com/article/stories/s3574876.shtml
http://www.kare11.com/story/news/lo...ights-off-525-pound-bear-with-knife/16411473/

This account, however, provides more information that still makes things sound screwed up. http://bringmethenews.com/2014/09/30/hunter-fights-off-525-pound-black-bear-using-only-a-knife/

Apparently, there were 3 hunters looking for this bear. Brandon Johnson and Trevor Novak were on one side of the swamp, armed with headlamps and knives. Craig Lindstrom had a headlamp and a pistol, but he was on the other side of the swamp.

Supposedly, Brandon and Trevor see the bear and think it is moving away, but it came after them. Trevor does not aid Brandon during the attack. After the attack is over, Trevor and Craig walk Brandon the 3 hours back to camp. Again, Craig doesn't send Trevor for help or to call 911.

Sheesh.

No matter how the story gets told, it is still full of mistakes.
 
I'm glad Mr. Johnson came out of it alive. I am certain it was a harrowing experience for him.

I am equally certain he learned a few things that might benefit him in the future.

1. Bears are bigger than you.
2. Bears are stronger than you.
3. Bears are faster than you.
4. Bears are hard to see at night.
5. Bears can bite REALLY hard.
6. The words "it's big and it's coming your way" will make you wish for a better weapon than a knife and whatever 'grit' you can muster.
7. Don't count on your 'friends' to wade into a mauling to help get the bear off of you. (we need to talk about this later.... buddy)
8. DAYLIGHT tracking of large wounded animals is starting to sound better and better.
 
Are we allowed to carry a loaded muzzleloader in the woods after dark when we go after a wounded animal in NY state during muzzleloader season? Our hunting party is all Canadian and we do not have handguns. A link to the appropriate legislation would be appreciated. All I could understand in what I read on that subject is that it is strictly forbidden. We do shoot bears during our deer hunt, it is legal and we buy licenses. The neibouring farmer who owns some of the lands we hunt thanks us everytime, and bear makes a great smoked meat!

OYE: +1 !

Double Naught Spy: +1 too.
 
Seems like there are some tough ethical questions and maybe tougher answers.
Do you leave your animal overnight to spoil for fear of it attacking you?
Do you go armed with weapons not allowed during the ongoing season while you track?
Do you use bright artificial lights that are almost universally forbidden while hunting?
Should you shun the evening hunt to avoid any of the above?
If the animal is found alive do you use your lights and illegal weapons to kill it and end any possible suffering?
 
Seems like there are some tough ethical questions and maybe tougher answers.
Do you leave your animal overnight to spoil for fear of it attacking you?
Do you go armed with weapons not allowed during the ongoing season while you track?
Do you use bright artificial lights that are almost universally forbidden while hunting?
Should you shun the evening hunt to avoid any of the above?
If the animal is found alive do you use your lights and illegal weapons to kill it and end any possible suffering?
Exactly.
 
Thanks for the link double naught.that helps understand it better. I totally agree that there were a series of errors and some difficult choices. I glad the hunter won the fight but like I said before I would have done it differently.
 
This incident happened just a few miles from me. Every bear hunter I know carries a sidearm when they are bowhunting. MN just has one bear season, it is the same license whether you are using a firearm or archery.
Going after a bear without a firearm in the dark is horrendously stupid. Bears around here are hunted over bait, and are most active in the hours right after dark. Stumbling around after dark in an area baited to attract bears, not the best idea. Deliberately following a known wounded bear after dark, armed with only a knife? Count me out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top