Back when I was into bowhunting, during practice, I shot an arrow into another arrow. They were aluminum, the second arrow stuck perfectly into the first. I still have it hanging like that in the garage. To this day I'm not sure dad believes I did it the way I said I did (he had walked into the house when it happened).
Me and a friend, during our teenage years, used to shoot our .22's at pennies taped to a paper target at 30-40 yds. Using my trusty Model 60, I built quite a collection of pennies with holes in them.
More recently, went to a sporting clays "fun" type tournament with a bunch of clients and friends. I've never shot sporting clays, but have shot skeet/dove years ago. There were about 150 guys there divided into teams. Most had Browning or Ruger over/unders, and most of them looked like they had shot a lot of clays. I roll up with my 870 pump, and kept up with them okay, until we got to the last station where I shot 9 out of 10, the high score on that station for the day. Won a $100 gift certificate to a local gun shop. Luck, heck yes!
Of course, those are the rare highlights. I could fill pages with stories of missed deer, hogs, dove, skeet........