Tests at 1000 yards from half a dozen Palma rifles with all powder types was interesting. Some powders did very well, a few were so-so and one was a waste of time to load. After the accuracy tests were done, samples were sent to a ballistics lab for pressure testing. As predicted, loads with AA2520 had the most uniform charge weights, muzzle velocity and peak pressure. Extremely repeatable ballistics indeed. AA2520 loads also had the worst accuracy of all; by a large margin. Some of us nicknamed it "wash tub ammo."
IMR3031 was the dirtiest and had only so-so accuracy.
IMR4895 was selected as it shot the most accurate inspite of greater spreads of charge weights, muzzle velocity and peak pressure. It shot into about 8 inches at 1000 and about 3 at 600 yards; 1/4th the size of groups with AA2520.
Bart B: Very interesting read. I have friends who made Distinguished and High Master with AA2520 in M1a's. Palma rifles are much more accurate, and you shoot at 1000 yards with the things, so maybe the things you observed would be in the noise level with an M1a.
I recall trying to find the 1000 yard target over the post of my M1a!.
Shooting a post at 1000 yards is a matter of faith, because you ain’t aiming. As you know, a service rifle shooter is satisfied to shoot in the 180's at that distance, whereas some Palma shooters I know will throw hissy fits if they drop below 190.
I think my first 1000 yard outing with a service rifle, I shot a 164 or something equally bad. Horrible experience. I apologized to my target pullers. They were fast crew and I made them work hard as I was all over the target.
The gentleman asking for data, I can assure all that the accuracy of a PTR 91 is not within the realm of a Palma Rifle. If AA2520 is very consistent in pressure and velocity variations, it might be a good candidate for that rifle.
One of the problems with AA2520 and all Accurate Arms powders is the last keg can be totally different from the current keg. Accurate Arms changed vendors so often that I have often had to develop loads with a different lot. Their loading data is next to useless, and I don’t approach maximum loads with their stuff, cause I might be blowing primers with the new can. I have one 90’s vintage keg of AA2520 that is so sooty, that it clogs my .223 powder funnel.
I did find the Chinese made Accurate Arms powders to be pretty good. I shot over 27 lbs of Chinese AA2495 and got my Distinguished and a Regional Gold in a M1a using the stuff. Incidentally, AA2495 is AA copy of IMR 4895. Foolishly they call it AA2495 instead of AA4895, so hardly anyone knows it is a copy.
I am glad to read that IMR 4895 is still good stuff, with 155’s and at 1000 yards.
You have any suggestions in a 1:10 barrel out to 600 yards with these components?