New trimmer from FA (Midway)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ya saw that just now... and Came here ta see what everyone thinks of It

Case trimmer Looks Nice.... and since all the Trimmers are on one Platform seems Like it would work Well

Kinda Tight on funds Right now or I would order It...

So come On.... someone Pull the Trigger:D
 
Heck it is not that much more than a LC WFT and will do a lot more. I picture it in a shallow Rubbermaid tray or something to catch the shavings. If I didn't just buy the WFT for 223 I would order one.
 
I've got one in the hands of The Folks In Brown and it may be here by week's end. I'll try to post a quick impression of it when it comes. I have a bunch of 300 AAC to prep (it's trimmed but not chamfered) and got tired of doing that chore by hand...

It looks very similar to a Giraud (which I also have) in terms of how it manages trim length, but adds inside/outside neck prep in exchange for losing the chip guard/cup of the Giraud.
 
How about making it so it will work with straight wall cases? Useless to me if it wont do both

By it's design basing the length off the shoulder it would have to be a whole different design for straight cases. Some folks do trim straight wall (I don't) but it would be nice if it could do both. I do not see a way it could the way it is set up but I am no engineer.:)

rbernie, please do let us know how it works for you.
 
rbernie,

Do us a favor and trim a few. That's what I'm really interested in... I'd imagine it doesn't have the horsepower of a Giraud but is it "good enough" for so much less? I already have a RCBS Trim Mate and this would mostly be for trimming mass quantities.

Mark
 
Can it trim straight wall? head space off the rim (44mag/45L/38-357)? I'm not sure how you would grip the case though... Maybe if the collet also gripped the case utilizing your hand pressure pushing in to pinch and grip and headspace at the same time?
 
Seems like it would work nice. Maybe even alittle faster then my trim process and it would take up less space for me. Right now I use the lyman trimmer with a dewalt power drill to trim then a RCBS trim mate to do the rest
 
WFT for me...nice and simple, just like I need!

Rbernie Have you been able to try it yet?
 
Interesting piece of equipment.

What would make it more interesting would be if it had a chuck or collet to allow it for mounting the myriad of other trimmer system out there that do not come with a drive.

Between the WFT, Trim-it, and a third similar trimmer that I cannot remember the name, they all use either a 3/8" or 1/2" end mill for the cutter. I think the Lee cutter might be 1/2" diameter. If not, it would not be a big deal for Lee to make a 1/2" diameter version.

Then, the reloader could continue to use the trimmer he has but has a nice drive system with chamfer, debur, and primer pocket brush.

I'd buy one as I dislike using a drill motor for trimming.
 
Sadly, I don't have much time to write a detailed experience post, but my early first impressions are that it's solid, does what it says that it does, and it is worth the coin.

The unit unpacks easily; the top cover of the unit contains the collets and trimmer attachments. It takes less than ten minutes to get unit unpacked, set up, and the cutter and chamfer attachments screwed into their respective shafts. Instructions on how to get started and working are adequate to the task.

The system uses plastic collars and a collet to set the case in the case holder for the trimming operation; it's not nearly as elegant as the Giraud setup but it's readily adjustable without having to buy new cutter heads for each chambering to be trimmed. For someone like me that values case prep volume across a broad range of chamberings, this may prove to be an acceptable compromise between precision and cost. The case holder itself and cutter are steel with aluminum knobs. It took me less than three minutes to get the cutter set up for operation, and the cutter held cutting tolerances within a +-.003 range for my cutting sample of 100 cases.

The only downside to the unit that is immediately obvious is the lack of chip control; unlike the Giraud, the FA unit makes zero effort to manage the flow of chips off the cutter or chamfering bits. I need to riddle out a good way to contain the chips; I didn't have time on Sunday to really think the problem through.

I can try to answer questions as I pop between other commitments if anyone wants more info.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1159.JPG
    IMG_1159.JPG
    83.7 KB · Views: 23
  • IMG_1160.JPG
    IMG_1160.JPG
    99.7 KB · Views: 26
  • IMG_1161.JPG
    IMG_1161.JPG
    103.8 KB · Views: 23
  • IMG_1162.JPG
    IMG_1162.JPG
    108.2 KB · Views: 31
Last edited:
Thanks for the pics.

I was thinking of setting it in a large flat Rubbermaid, Sterilite plastic box. The large flat kind that can slide under a bed. Should collect all the trimmings.

I use a large 1 2 cal bucket with a shop vac hose connected for my LC WFT and it sucks up the shavings.
 
One point that bears making for anyone not familiar with this type of gadget - all of the cutters and tools rotate simultaneously. Don't wear a tie when using this gizmo. :)
 
Can it trim straight wall?
No - it spaces off the shoulder. It also needs some case body sticking out beyond the end of the collet for your mitts to hang on to.

Which brings up a point - short cases are gonna be less comfortable to trim than long cases, due to the fact that you just have less case body to hang on to when you stuff the mouth of the case into the trimmer collet. No surprise for folk used to a Giraud or similar, but bears mentioning for folk that are newer to trimming automation.

I trimmed a bunch of 300AAC and it was fine, but I can imagine that anything shorter would start to get hard to hang on to...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top