Oh boy, another GLOCK vs XD thread... with a twist!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Miami_JBT

Member
Joined
May 19, 2009
Messages
1,242
Location
Big Bend of FL, originally from Miami.
For those like me that were gun owners back during the Clinton AWB, I remember how times were around the 2000 Presidential Election time frame wise and that people were seriously looking at handguns thinking that they'd be banned under Al Gore.

So I'm comparing a Gen 2 GLOCK 17 versus the original HS2000, the gun that would eventually become the Springfield Armory XD9. Since they were around back then.

Ozmxna2.jpg

The elections are right around the corner and the polling is neck and neck between Al Gore and George W. Bush and I remember honestly, things don't look good. The question was would the Republicans hold their slim majority in Congress or would Al Gore win the presidency? If he did, would that mean the Democrats sweep the Republicans out of Congress and regain control to push even more gun control?

I do recall that people were panic buying during the lead up the election. Heck, choices were slim since folks started panic buying back in December of '99 with the Y2K scare.

vP4pajn.jpg

So, what two choices would we possibly be looking at? Well, if it were me; I'd look at two pieces of European Combat Tupperware. Yup, the police loved GLOCK 17 from Austria and a new-comer from Croatia, the IM Metal HS2000; both in 9x19mm.

First, let’s look at the established plastic fantastic.

GLOCK has been selling their gun since the mid 1980s and they’ve taken law enforcement by storm.

Agencies like my home town’s PD, City of Miami was one of their big early adopters and they’ve had nothing but success with it. I can tell you this, GLOCK works not matter where because even in Alaska, the GLOCK keeps on trucking.

LrDeUv5.jpg

This gun seriously is that tough. Back then, we all heard the talk at the gun shops and gun shows. About how you can bury a GLOCK, freeze ‘em, throw them from helicopters, etc... they just keep on working. Well, I might not be burying my GLOCK, but I sure did carry it in Florida and it went into the water with me and it didn't rust even when I carried it all day due to me sweating in our oppressive summers.

I’d have no problem recommending a GLOCK, especially a good conditioned used GLOCK 17.

j6Lotfo.jpg

I recall that 9mm was cheaper then .40 S&W and pre-ban 17rd magazines were a tiny bit easier to find since all those PDs are exchanging their older guns for those new .40 S&W chambered ones. The PDs were swapping their used pre-ban mags to GLOCK for new mags, who'd then flip the old mags on the used market to vendors.

Yeah, you could get a newer Gen 3 GLOCK 17 with the light rail. But really, why get that? It cost more money and money was tight then. Better to spend your hard-earned dollars on pre-ban magazines!

I remember when American Handgunner magazine reviewed the HS2000.

hlnBJcr.jpg

It was a "dark warrior" and the gun was a real sleeper hit. When Intrac out of Knox, TN was importing them. They’ve were selling them for under $300 new.

The coolest feature, if I could call it that is the magazines. You could use modified pre-ban Beretta M9 magazines in the gun and lucky for me. I was able to find those cheap by the Army/Navy stores near Homestead Air Force Base.

The HS2000 sights were the same size as what comes on a P226. So that means you'd be able to change the sights like you can with a GLOCK. But the factory sights are metal and good as is. Unless you want night sights, there was no need to change them.

xzRAMDc.jpg

The barrel was just a tad shorter than what you’d find on the GLOCK 17 but the grip length was pretty much the same. The texturing was even similar between the two guns.

Safety wise, the HS2000 had two of the three same safeties as a GLOCK plus a 1911 style grip safety and a little loaded chamber flag on top of the barrel hood to show you the gun is loaded. It even has a little pin that sticks out the back to let you know it is cocked. I recall that really was a big selling point to folks that were weary of carrying a loaded GLOCK.

The magazine release button was also ambidextrous and that was a big deal too.

Field Stripping for cleaning was similar between the two.

Qo618jV.jpg

RY2UGEo.jpg

Both field stripped into four basic components. Slide, barrel, recoil spring/guide rod, and frame. The guide rod on the HS2000 was metal while the GLOCK 17 was plastic. But that’s not really an issue, but if it was. You were able to find an aftermarket metal guide rod for your GLOCK.

I do remember when Intrac said that they're releasing a new version of the HS2000 soon. One with a light rail like the new GLOCKs.

BU5fi7C.jpg

n9HZZap.jpg

A lot of the features shown there were similar to what you see on the new GLOCKs like their “Practical Tactical” models.

While that’s all good, money was a big issue back then. I remember that Intrac didn’t tell folks if there was going to be a price increase on the new batch of guns coming in with the upgraded features.

Additionally, no word on parts and accessories. If Al Gore won, folks believed that he very well could order ATF or the State Department to make importation of guns or gun parts harder or impossible. Many thought that since GLOCK already had an established presence in the US with the law enforcement market being a big part of their business. ATF won’t bar them from bringing in guns and parts since they supplied agencies across the country.

Back then, I was all about GLOCK. But I can say that I really like the HS2000 and it is a great pistol for the original price they sold at, especially since you can used modified pre-ban Beretta M9 magazines in it. But since no one had a crystal ball that said the elections would go with George W. Bush and the Republicans keep control of Congress. I’d ultimately with the used GLOCK 17 due to parts and magazines.

KijVGzy.jpg

Luckily, George W. Bush won and the renewal for the AWB never reached his desk so I get to own both guns today. But back then, if I were in that position of trying to get my first gun, it'd be a GLOCK.
 
Awesome nostalgic post that goes to show each season has its own cares and worries.

We've survived a lot with our rights largely intact!

Thanks for sharing the old magazine articles.

I was close to finishing high school around that time, and couldn't own pistols yet.
If I could, I likely would have chosen the glock between the two for similar reasons (parts, mags, known quantity value - customer service and repair etc).

Might have even gone sig 226 or Beretta for cheaper "high caps".

I bought my first pistols as the awb was sunsetting. Mags were still rare above 10 rounds and usually fetched 70+!

Who knows what future generations will face.

Stay strong, never give up, and avoid the doom and gloom sky is falling.

"there are more than the forces of evil at work in this world "! -some wizard. Harry Potter maybe?
 
Takes me back. My first duty weapon was a XD40 Tactical. Loved that pistol. Hard as coconuts to find a level 3 holster that fit it! Got an early G35 afterwards since I was getting into shooting with the dept’s team. Actually had a major malfunction with that G35 when the rails gave way, they were completely separated from the frame. A ruptured 40 case sealed the deal, and the slide came flying off frame. Think I wetted myself a bit! Factory ammo! Lucky, the dept’s armorer was at the match with me and I did get another Glock G35 for its replacement. But after many phone calls and forms, back when it was never Glock’s fault. But that was quickly sold an I never shot Glock again until the generation 4 came out, and then only 9mm. Shot XD or 92s from then on out!

I think it’s unbelievable on how limited we were in regards to semiauto pistols back then. SW Gen 3’s were the go to, but only after a 500 round break in and recoil spring change.Still remember the article that had a bunch of gun writers shooting a 5900 series, 5000 rounds in one day I believe. Three stoppages. Frame and rails were worn and gouged but it still ran, and was very loose. Times have changed. And for the better me thinks.

If I was starting over today, and I needed a good basic pistol I would be fine with a Beretta 92 for duty, or a M&P if forced to use polymer. I just don’t shoot like I use to and I like to keep my stuff basic and don’t fiddle with them except for sights and maybe grips. For personal use, edc and plinking, I wouldn’t feel under gunned with either a Ruger or Taurus. Like I said, just don’t shoot like a did when I was younger and had all of my original parts. Both brands are inexpensive and more than good enough for the average to above average user. Laser training, practice draw strokes, and just enough live ammo for recoil management is life now. And I rather enjoy that, gives me time to enjoy life.

When I heard of the AWB, the first thing that came to my mind was, “great they are going to start making these wonder nines thinner!” LOL. No, they just blocked a third to two fifths of the magazine and kept the thick brick like grip. And people would pay about $10-$15 per round for the ability to own those five or more rounds over a ten round magazine. Crazy times. Saw KCI mags go for $50/$60 a Mag back then, and OEM Glock mags go for over $100 if pre banned. One good thing about the XD mags, you could buy the 357/40 mags and have the lips re configured to except 9mm bullets and feed reliably and have a level +10 round magazine if you wanted.

Peace,
Lefty
 
Last edited:
Nice write up! I was too young to buy handguns back then but my first was a Glock and I definitely prefer it to the "XD", although to be fair I've had several over the years and they were solid guns, just always preferred Glocks.
 
It was a "dark warrior" and the gun was a real sleeper hit. When Intrac out of Knox, TN was importing them. They’ve were selling them for under $300 new.

Critics of the XD like to bring up it's price with the original importer. Just pondering, possibly that importer under priced them. And I doubt they provided a lifetime warranty.
 
I was one of those who initially resisted Glocks. I was convinced I wouldn't like one. I got a good deal on a 1st gen S&W Sigma just about the time they were bringing out the 2nd gen guns and decided to try it as my first striker fired plastic gun. I didn't make it through the 1st magazine before the gun broke.

At that time the only option I had to return it to Smith was to go directly to the UPS counter. There as a cute 20 something gal working the counter and when I declared it as a pistol going back for repair she commented, "Should have bought a Glock". The gun was returned and did the same thing during the 1st magazine. Back to UPS, got the same advice from this gal, "Should have bought a Glock". And few weeks later when I shipped it back to Smith for the 3rd time I once again got the same advice. "Should have bought a Glock".

After the 3rd time I insisted Glock replace the gun with a new one, a 2nd gen. Which they did. When it came in I traded it unfired for a Glock. The rest is history.

I did eventually try an XD in 40 S&W. It was accurate and reliable enough, but the grip safety is a deal killer for me. I'll tolerate a grip safety on a 1911 but think it would be a better gun without it. Back in the day many guys who actually carried and used 1911's deactivating the grip safety was a common modification. IME the grip safety is more likely to prevent the gun from firing when you WANT it to fire, than prevent it from firing when you DO NOT WANT it to fire. I do like the 1911 style safety even when used on striker fired guns like the Sig M17 and some others.
 
Hindsight shows that Glock bought its way into police departments around the country, making killer deals to get their product on the hips of officers, knowing that this would impress people. I am not disparaging Glocks, which clearly did the job, but I am sure the IM Metal/XD marketers were doing the same thing, trying to buy their way into the market.
Ironically, Glock set the price artificially high for sales to civilians, upon advice of his savvy marketers, who knew that people equate price with quality. That and the bogus stories about how Glocks were undetectable really put Glock on the map.
 
In Y2K I was 12, and was probably reading those magazines you posted. I had a lil Glock and polymer prejudice even at that early age because I soaked up whatever I heard from old folks and they didn't like them, that and a game warden who was chatting my dad up one day railed against the worthless glock in the even more worthless 9mm.

I eventually got all that sorted out and own a few glocks and have owned many more. I was at a gun show one day and I probably looked at 50-60 tables full of handguns and then I reached one table that had "only" Glocks, something about them looked alright to me. Then, after I got one I started seeing all kinds of torture tests being done on them. One of them was called "A perfect 10" and it was an especially torturous glock torture test, he threw it out of an airplane and fired it. His HK didn't pass the first test this Glock 17 was subjected to.

I've been a Glock guy for over a decade now....since maybe 2006-2007ish
 
Thanks Miami _JBT for the interesting history of these two pistols. History aside, nothing has changed for me if deciding (and I'm keenly aware that I represent a minority view) between these two pistols: I would never carry a striker-fired pistol without at least one having a grip safety-and would much prefer carrying one with a more conventional manual safety.
 
I bought an XD-40 Service shortly after they where released in 2005. Liked it so much I bought an XD-40 Tactical for competition and XD-40 SubCompact for CCW. The XD-40 Tactical (right) in the picture below was my Limited-10 gun for the next decade and had had roughly 40,000 rds through it.

yFpWAJGl.jpg
 
My polymer journey began with s Springer XD45 Service, and I followed it up with an XD40 Service. Eminently satisfied, I got an XD40sc for EDC and worked with them for years, ultimately using an XDs 9mm for summer carry. However, when the pandemic hit, I decided to try building a Polymer80 Glock clone, and, impressed with its simplicity and reliability, bought a gen 3 Glock 19. It took a little practice to get used to the different grip angle of the Glock compared to 1911s and Springers but I found it a very good alternative. When eligible for my Blue Label, I went for a G43X and, given the 15-rd capacity that the Shield gen 2 mags offer, am now using it for summer carry over the XDs.

In my opinion and experience, both are superlative firearms, reliable, accurate, affordable, and easily mastered. I feel equally comfortable with either and comfortably bet my life on both brands.

Harry
 
One of my first pistols is an XD45 Compact. It is rock solid. I carried an XDS 9mm for years, also never missed a beat. I thought the build quality of both was excellent. These days I'm part of the small 10+ crowd. But I'd have no problem carrying either of my SA/HS pistols. Thanks for posting this history.
 
I owned a HS-2000 … when they first rolled out ..
Great pistol… I have owned several rebranded XD
Pistols … all functioned perfectly…. But .. I lean toward Glocks .. lower bore axis .. weighs less

I live 2 hours from Knoxville TN .. I purchased my new HS2000 for $265.00 OTD
 
Last edited:
It is a legit issue. Springfield Armory raised the price because they could.
I remember the LGS got in a dozen HS2000s from a distributor a few months after the Springfield release. People would come in to buy the advertised pistol because they were really getting the swing of this having a brand, maybe more so than now for M1A fans, etc.

Then, the LGS would say, we can sell you the same gun for 30% less if you want. Since a nice store, they kept the normal margins and passed the savings along. And... 80% would pay the Springfield price!

Took a couple weeks to get rid of them all. I was poor at the time so didn't snag one up.
 
I remember the AWB ban coming and bought a Browning High Power because I knew there would always be high cap military surplus mags from all over the world. Took me a long time to come around to Tupperware but eventually got to shoot several Glocks but just hated the fat grip and grip angle compared to svelte HPs. However I liked the Ruger SR9C and bought one and more recently an FN 509C Tactical which trumps other Tupperwares that I've tried.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top