ONE good all around pistol

Status
Not open for further replies.
David E said:
And this is the real answer, as others have noted.
Click to expand...

...as long as you don't mind not being able to legitimately conceal it, that is.

That may be your answer...that doesn't make it "the" answer or the "real" answer.
 
I like Warp's idea of a carbine conversion, too.
Click to expand...

I mentioned carbine conversions in Post #52, but I didn't post the cool pictures Warp did in Post #62....:rolleyes:
 
Warp said:
...as long as you don't mind not being able to legitimately conceal it, that is.

That may be your answer...that doesn't make it "the" answer or the "real" answer.
Click to expand...
I don't know why you have such a hard time concealing a 4" revolver. It isn't especially difficult.

Maybe a 3" Model 66 would've suited you better.

For the original stated parameters, it's near impossible to dismiss a 4" .357 out of hand.
 
Didn't I specifically state a semi automatic pistol? NOT a revolver.

While I agree that there is not One do all handgun for every situation or environment, I'd like to think that with all the options available and the experience as well as knowledge the member of this forum have, we could at least come close to it.
 
We know you didn't want a revolver, but you subverted the original guidelines yourself by allowing conversions, kits, add-ons, extra barrels and whatnot.

It became "what's the most versatile frame?". Which has been answered.
 
David E said:
We know you didn't want a revolver, but you subverted the original guidelines yourself by allowing conversions, kits, add-ons, extra barrels and whatnot.

It became "what's the most versatile frame?". Which has been answered.
Click to expand...

Of course, in typical fashion, there's more than one answer.

It depends on what aspects you favor most. Even with the highly versatile options out there, different choices are better at different aspects.

With the 4" .357 several have chosen you can load up or down pretty far...but you are stuck with that one caliber (even in slightly different cartridges). You can swap grips to somewhat alter shootability and concealability.

With something like a Glock 29, or some other choices, you can swap barrels and uppers very easily with commercially available parts and shoot several different cartridges and calibers and you can even grow it into a carbine instead of a handgun and, I would argue, that concealing 11 rounds of 10mm (in the stock, pretty darn concealable format) is superior to 6 rounds of .357. (and people do buy conversions, which is sometimes nothing more than a barrel and maybe magazines, all the time, it isn't like this is something only pulled out of the hat for 'what if...' discussions)


This is why it's so great to be able to come to your own conclusions and buy whatever you want for whatever reason you want. :)
 
The problem with allowing every possible configuration for a pistol that's allegedly supposed to be a "Do-It-All" handgun is that when, say, a Glock 29 is set up as a .22, it sucks for defense. When set up as a carbine, it sucks for concealed carry.

When I read the OP, it asked us to suggest one GUN, now it's one FRAME.

WHICH IS FINE, as it's still a worthy pursuit. But it seems to be an answer to a question not originally asked. At least, from how I read the OP
 
Since it must be a semi-auto, I would go with the s&w model 1006 in 10mm. Can be concealed easy enough,good for hunting at least up to deer size. All steel and not a Glock or a 1911.
 
I wonder how our answers compare to those in the other forum where he posted the same question earlier. Likewise, I wonder if he's found his answer yet.
 
David E said:
The problem with allowing every possible configuration for a pistol that's allegedly supposed to be a "Do-It-All" handgun is that when, say, a Glock 29 is set up as a .22, it sucks for defense. When set up as a carbine, it sucks for concealed carry.

When I read the OP, it asked us to suggest one GUN, now it's one FRAME.

WHICH IS FINE, as it's still a worthy pursuit. But it seems to be an answer to a question not originally asked. At least, from how I read the OP
Click to expand...

No, legally and technically it's still just one gun. The uppers and barrels are simply parts. :cool:

But I agree with your overall point here, which is why I previously stated it does kind of defeat the purpose when you allow all kinds of conversions and what-not. At least IMO. It's like asking for "one rifle" and people say an AR and then list 10 different uppers they'd put on the lower.
 
With the obvious concession that the weapon described in the op doesn't really exist, I'd say a S&W 69 with a 3 or 4 inch barrel is as close as you'll get.

If a semi is desired, I'd say a Dan Wesson of some 1911 flavor in 10mm.
 
Last edited:
Warp said:
No, legally and technically it's still just one gun. The uppers and barrels are simply parts. :cool:
Click to expand...

A basic fact that everyone here is well aware of. I don't know why you posted something so elementary. :rolleyes:

But I agree with your overall point here, which is why I previously stated it does kind of defeat the purpose when you allow all kinds of conversions and what-not. At least IMO. It's like asking for "one rifle" and people say an AR and then list 10 different uppers they'd put on the lower.
Click to expand...

At least we agree on something! Who'd a thunk it?

If the original question was "new federal law limits you to ONE Handgun and ONE rifle, what are they?" Then the 1911 or Glock would be a great choice for the reasons we listed, as would the AR-15. Two "guns," but they could accommodate many, many calibers.
 
Last edited:
ONE good all around pistol
Click to expand...

Colt Delta Elite 10mm.

Oh wait.......You added elephant, and I'm assuming you mean emergency self defense, not hunting, against elephants, rhinos, leopards, lions, cape buffalo and hippos.

In that case it's a Ruger Super Redhawk Alaskan in .454 Casull.
 
In that case it's a Ruger Super Redhawk Alaskan in .454 Casull.
Click to expand...

I have had the same thought, which is why I have one with a good holster that can be worn IWB/OWB, or as a chest rig.

In some states it would not be legal for handgun hunting due to the barrel length. If residing or planning to reside in one of those states you would want something else. Requirements range up to 6" so it probably isn't worth trying to please everyone.


Semi-autos just don't have the dynamic range.
 
This is why it's so great to be able to come to your own conclusions and buy whatever you want for whatever reason you want.
Click to expand...

That is Exactly one of the reasons I posted this question. Everybody has his/her opinion on what they think is best for "X". As well as myself being included. There are so many different ways to skin a cat, that I just really wanted to learn a few more tricks to the same end.

I wonder how our answers compare to those in the other forum where he posted the same question earlier. Likewise, I wonder if he's found his answer yet.
Click to expand...

Quite honestly, there are a lot more similarities than you might think. As well as quite a few "out of the box" thoughts. I will say this, on this forum I rarely if ever, saw a Sig, of any type mentioned. The Glocks were of course mentioned, referenced, recommended, etc. here, as well as there. But, more here than there.

As far as finding my answer goes, simply put, that'll never happen. There will Always be something bigger, badder, and better on the market that will make getting the job done easier. I would just like to know what all of them are before I make my decision(s).
 
...And in addition, yes, the elephant part was in a wholly survival mode means. NOT hunting them on purpose, directly. Strictly as a "last chance" food source.
 
Then consider the multi-caliber, multi-sized Sig 250, if you're comfortable foregoing the carbine conversion....
 
Sig p229 elite, by a hair over the sig p220. 7 extra rounds may come in handy sometime, since I can only have one pistol in this scenario.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

B
  • Locked
CCW vs competition pistol
Replies
12
Views
992
Mike .45
Mike .45
J
  • Locked
Selling a Pistol,what should I do
Replies
13
Views
777
logical
L
W
  • Locked
Building a pistol or which one is the best bang for the buck but...
Replies
14
Views
582
WinchesterAA
W
Hokkmike
All purpose rifle/pistol caliber hunting & self defense round nomination.
2 3
Replies
58
Views
2K
PapaG
P
N
  • Locked
Mercury Rising pistol
Replies
2
Views
796
SAWBONES
S
Back
Top