Open carry in Wisconsin??

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 7, 2003
Messages
1,073
I just read through packing.org's page and wanted to clarify something. Wisconsin prohibits concealed carry. No way, no how, don't even have an unloaded pistol stored within reach in the car.

But open carry IS legal? Packing.org mentioned you'll get noticed by the police if you open carry, but is it legal even so? Just trying to figure that out. Any Wisconsinite replies would be appreciated.
 
I sometimes hunt with a ruger super blackhawk. I carry it in a holster on my fanny pack belt. When I get to my car to get in for lunch I have to unload it and put it in the case and in the back before I get in the car.

It is illegal to have a loaded gun in or on a car in Wi.

I have never seen anyone open cary in town.

Winters
 
There's another thread in here somewhere about UW students with dummy guns being fined by the City of Madison.

From what I remember of that thread, open carry is legal in WI, and there's a state law that has preempted local ordinances to the contrary.

Local governments, like Madison, flout the obvious intent of the state law by arresting anyone openly carrying a firearm for "disturbing the peace."
 
Quite honestly, the only people I've seen practice open carry are workers inside gunshops and the occasional handgun hunter. Carrying openly in remote areas of Northern Wisconsin may not cause too many problems, but it would be a hassle as in Wisconsin a gun has to be fully encased and unloaded whenever carried on a motor vehicle and this includes boats, tractors, ATVs, and snowmobiles. In Southern Wisconsin you would have the cops all over you for carrying, the left wingers in Madison on the SW side fo the state are afraid of guns and the SE side of the state is chock full of blissninny sheeple. I live in SE Wisconsin in the most conservative county in the entire state and even our dufus Sheriff was an outspoken critic of CCW when it was up for debate last year. :fire:
 
I live in SE Wisconsin in the most conservative county in the entire state

Even the most conservative county in Wisconsin is liberal by any other standard. I was born in Milwaukee and also lived in Racine, after I left to join the service I never once considered moving back to Wisconsin. I don't even like visiting, what with having to dodge all the morons that have the "name" of their pickup truck displayed on the bug shield. Whenever anyone suggests that Nebraska is full of hicks, I recommend to them a little visit to Wisconsin to put things in perspective.
 
Yep. Open carry is, technically, legal in WI. On the other hand, I've lived in WI for the last 27 years, and I've never seen anyone who wasn't a LEO open carrying in town.

That being said, don't let the politics fool you - WI is a pretty gun-friendly state, culturally. Deer hunting is far too much a part of the local culture and economy for it to be otherwise. Pretty much no one will be fazed to discover you own guns (excepting the terminally leftist college types in the People's Democratic Republic of Madison). But then, Madison is in a different universe compared to the rest of the state. As Langenator said, they expressly skirt the law and, as policy, arrest anyone open carrying for disturbing the peace. Similarly, they use zoning regulations to prohibit the sale of handguns inside city limits, and discharging a firearm within city limts is strictly verboten (so no ranges).

IIRC, you can have an unloaded pistol (no chambered round, empty magazine if in the gun) in your car within reach, as long as it is not held to be concealed. On the passenger seat next to you has been ruled to be concealed in court, while on the dash in front of you is legally open. On the other hand, I don't think this is a good idea, since you're certain to be hassled by the cops if you get pulled over.

Really, it's a few key people from the PDRM and Milwaukee government that prevent proper respect for RKBA in WI. They manage to keep getting elected because they hide behind "don't need that to hunt," and our firearms culture is heavily weighted towards hunting rather than defense or sport. So the bigwigs can exert political pressure on people otherwise inclined towards RKBA, and they can cave in because it won't annoy their voters too much as long as they can still hunt.

As far as hicks, SIOP, our northwoods and our rural communities are no more "hick" than any other rural types in the country. Guys drive trucks with guns for hunting, as opposed to shooting appliances in the back yard. There's a lot more camo, and a lot fewer wife beaters. Granted, our urban areas are a lot less urban than NYC, LA, and Chicago...but I look at that as a good thing. And if you're a woman on the side of the road with a flat tire, odds are good that some polite guy will pull over to give you a hand. I'm sorry you don't like WI, and you're welcome to not - but I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't imply that my state is the armpit of the union.
 
Pretty much SOP for the police is to arrest anyone carring in the open for disorderly conduct. If your very lucky you will just have to pay a forfiture and *might* get your firearm back relatively soon. It amazes me how a lawful legal act can still be illegal. :confused:
 
I am seriously thinking about starting to open carry in my town. I know the police will be pissed, but I am planning on carrying a recent WI supreme court decision that talks about the legality of open carry. I will not carry one of my expensive guns in case it gets taken.

I feel like we really need to start excersising out constitutional rights. The one thing I am confused about is the WI law that regulates how close you can get to a school with a gun. As far as I can tell my best bet will be to stay at least 1000 feet away from any school.
 
I am seriously thinking about starting to open carry in my town
That idea has certainly crossed my mind, but two things have prevented me: first, I spent the vast majority of my time in Milwaukee or Madison, and that's where I would be most certain to be arrested, fined, and to have my gun confiscated.

Secondly, though...when it comes right down to it, I just don't have the stones. I'm unwilling to be the martyred test case. I'm ashamed to say it, but that's what it is. I try to make up for my cowardice with donations to pro-RKBA groups and the proverbial "strongly-worded letters" to my reps, but that's it.
 
Control don't feel bad. Fear is what is keeping me from doing the same thing. I am afraid of what the public atitude will be and if my face will get splashed in the paper. My town is not real big and someone walking down main street with a gun would surely be one of the lead stories in our weekly paper. If I ever work up the stones to do it I am planning on passing out fliers that talk about concealed carry and what my goal is by carrying openly. I would also notify the police chief to be aware that I will be strolling around town and expect them to be very supportive of me excersing my Constitutional rights.
 
Does anyone know what the policies are like in Eau Claire, specifically? That's where I'll be.


but I am planning on carrying a recent WI supreme court decision that talks about the legality of open carry.

Do you have a link to that decision?
 
Yes, it looks like we will be having an open carry march. WCCA volunteers have been talking about it for quite some time. Now that Adrian from SAFER has jump-started the issue again, it's just a question of timing.

The problem with testing the system by carrying openly is this: let's say it's Friday, you're carrying, and the police decide it's disorderly conduct or disturbing the peace. The DA's gone for the weekend. Are you going to sit in jail?

And what happens to your gun until your trial?
 
Quote:
On the passenger seat next to you has been ruled to be concealed in court, while on the dash in front of you is legally open.


Even my cat has more sense than that

Wisconsin has a long history of 'progressive' (that's what they like to call themselves in this state) politicians, don't expect any common sense to come out of this state. :(

Secondly, though...when it comes right down to it, I just don't have the stones. I'm unwilling to be the martyred test case. I'm ashamed to say it, but that's what it is. I try to make up for my cowardice with donations to pro-RKBA groups and the proverbial "strongly-worded letters" to my reps, but that's it.

I hear you.
 
The problem with testing the system by carrying openly is this: let's say it's Friday, you're carrying, and the police decide it's disorderly conduct or disturbing the peace. The DA's gone for the weekend. Are you going to sit in jail?
And what happens to your gun until your trial?

If its sitting in jail with a bunch of gunnies, it couldn't be any worse than a weekend at the in-laws :D
 
It looks like the date and time hasn't been established yet.

I know I will be there.
 
"Even the most conservative county in Wisconsin is liberal by any other standard. I was born in Milwaukee and also lived in Racine, after I left to join the service I never once considered moving back to Wisconsin. I don't even like visiting, what with having to dodge all the morons that have the "name" of their pickup truck displayed on the bug shield. Whenever anyone suggests that Nebraska is full of hicks, I recommend to them a little visit to Wisconsin to put things in perspective."

This is why when I met a girl from Tennessee, I chased her down and got her pregnant so we'd have to get married so I could move to TN and get a carry permit. :evil:

I grew up in New Berlin, and worked in downtown Waukesha and in Milwaukee. Spent lots of time working in crappy areas where people are content to be preyed upon by groups of teenagers who want to be real gangsters. I was in such a rush to get out of there as soon as possible. I don't know why people will live in states like that. Instead of wasting your time trying to change the political climate (nothing short of erasing Madison and Milwaukee would better that state) why not move to a decent area filled with nice religous normal people who aren't scared to death at the thought of guns?

Now I live in TN with my wife and two year old, with a gun on my hip and a smile on my face...
 
The problem with testing the system by carrying openly is this: let's say it's Friday, you're carrying, and the police decide it's disorderly conduct or disturbing the peace. The DA's gone for the weekend. Are you going to sit in jail?

And what happens to your gun until your trial?
Yes. If you are lucky they will get to you early Monday.
And they keep the gun until the case is settled most times. My friend had to wait around 3 years to finally get his back. It was a BS CCW/DC issue in his case but that happened in Fond du Lac (anti-gun) so YMMV.
 
Again, I'll be in Eau Claire. Does anyone know about the conditions there specifically? Does being from MN, w/ a MN permit, make any difference?

(Thanks for all the replies so far.)
 
Phantom Warrior, Eau Claire is pretty much a Democrat stronghold. The only reason that Senator Zien still represents that area is that, while he's a strong conservative, he also has the working man's credentials.

With nearly 1,000,000 miles on his '91 Harley, he gets the biker vote. As a decorated Viet Nam Marine veteran, he gets the Vet's votes. And, just as a all-around good guy, he gets the peoples' votes.

But it's still a Democrat area, and the cops and the city fathers kowtow to the wishes of our esteemed anti-gun governor.

Carry openly at your own risk.
 
But it's still a Democrat area, and the cops and the city fathers kowtow to the wishes of our esteemed anti-gun governor.

Carry openly at your own risk.

Thanks Monkeyleg. That's what I really needed to know.
 
For the "Defense Walk", how about a bunch of open carry guys marching in as many of the Independence Day Parades all through the state that they could get in?

Also a good time to hand out copies of the US Constitution as they go down the parade route. :evil:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top