Poll: 7+1 of .45 ACP vs. 10+1 of .40 S&W

[matsaleh]

I'm choosing between two options in the same gun: 7+1 of .45 vs 10+1 of .40. I'm leaning toward the .40, but I'd like to know what you all think.

I'm purposely leaving out the make/model to focus on the caliber/capacity question. This gun is to be my primary carry piece.

Thanks!

 

[Spot77]

I'd take the extra rounds in .40

I have a .380 that takes 7+1, but sometimes I second guess whether that's enough rounds or not. Strictly for home defense of course, I like the caliber, but I feel much better with my CZ loaded with 11 rounds of .40.

 

[Soap]

I'd be indifferent between a 1911 in 10mm or .45ACP. But choosing between .45 (which means 1911) and 10 rounds of .40 (which means a double stack), the choice for me is clear. .45 all the way.

 

[Spot77]

Why does 10 rounds of .40 mean double stack?

 

[FPrice]

I voted for the .45ACP but I think that you would be okay with either.

 

[George Hill]

Why can't you have 10+1 of .45 too?
Or what about 20+1 of 9MM?

 

[9x19]

I'd go for 10+1 of .45Glock... but it wouldn't replace my 20+1 9mm Glock 34 in the nightstand!!!

 

[matsaleh]

The choices are between two caliber offerings of the *same* gun. The .45 is offered in 7+1, the .40 in 10+1. I like the gun for its features, CCW ability, trigger, ergonimics, etc. Now I'm trying to evaluate the two caliber options, so I do not have the "luxury" of speculating about 10+1 (or more) of .45.

Thanks again!

 

[Spot77]

I think you'll find that most people prefer the .45 over the .40, so if the actual caliber is what's important to you, you probably have your answer as to which is more popular (I hate these kind of debates; they happen every week on every forum).

Which one do YOU shoot better? Can you notice a difference in the two?

Statistics and fps facts aside, I can't tell a big difference in shooting the two. Depends a lot on the gun too.

So with all of that to consider, do YOU feel comfortable with 8 rounds, or 11 rounds?

 

[Ian11]

If the handguns carries between 7-10 rounds, capacity really isn't much of a factor. I have respect for all handgun calibers 9mm and up for defense use. What's more important is how it shoots in my hands.

Try a .40 and .45 of similar makes. There's no clear cut winner except the one you can shoot better (even if you go against the majority).

 

[4v50 Gary]

I voted for the 45. Just use to it.

 

[Jeeper]

My answer is:

Which ever one that you will shoot more and become more accurate with.

 

[txgolfer45]

What Jeeper said!!!

Scott

 

[dude]

# or rounds is no way to make up for poor shot placement. As this is to be your primary carry piece you should invest the time and $$$ to see which one you shoot better. I never feel under guned w/8 +1 of 9mm from my p7 because the weapon works for me and I have full confidence in where my shots will go.

 

[txgolfer45]

I like the G23 in 10+1 for CCW. If I could afford a preban, then I would get even more!!!

Scott

 

[nemesis]

I carry mine and can't stand fat guns. I'll take fewer rounds and a skinny gun anyday. I've got another mag ready to go.

 

[10-Ring]

If I can walk around w/ my false sense of security when I carry my 7 shot Jetfire and feel secure w/ my 5 shot, j-frame revolver, I'm going w/ the caliber I am more proficient with...45 acp

 

[Boats]

Low pressure "push" recoil or high pressure "snap" recoil?

I'll take the low pressure push. I don't like the .40S&W subjectively.

 

[Preacherman]

10+1 of .40 S&W for me. This round hits virtually as hard as the .45 ACP (most tests put it at 90%-95% of the larger round, depending on the ammo used), and the extra ammo capacity is a very-nice-to-have feature.

 

[New_comer]

Eenie... meenie... mynie... moe....


Either of the two is good to go!











But 10+1 sounds reassuring!!!

 

[Tacblack]

I went with the 40 cal.

I was looking at a LE position and they offer SIG's in 2 guns the 45 and 40. I had to wonder 8+1 P220 or 12+1 P2340. Being LE I would have to go with 12+1.

This happens to be very close to post , thought I would add it. I would have to shot both and see if I sucked with one of them, cause if you cant hit the target:banghead:

 

[sm]

.45ACP -shot too many rounds over too many years.
I never cared for the .40.

 

[Glamdring]

Well I have to say I don't understand the question. You can have 10 rounds of 45 if that is a concern in a 1911. Or 7 rounds in a 40.

Will 3 rounds make any difference?

If your talking certain types of CC I might pick a 40 but would rather have a 9mm or J frame (for pocket or ankle carry).

 

[PowerSlave]

Make mine 45

 

[WonderNine]

Hmm....I'd prefer 15+1 or 17+1 or 9mm anyday.

But given the two choices I'll go with .45. And what's wrong with 10mm? The .40 would be dead last on my list for a defensive caliber 9mm and above.