Possible trade, want some thoughts

[IlikeSA]

I am considering a trade for a S&W Mt Gun in 45 Colt, a 625-6 to be exact. I am trading my 4 3/4 Blackhawk flat top in 45 Colt/ACP for what I bought it (600) for plus six hundred dollars. I have another flat top in the same caliber.

Thoughts on the trade?

 

[trackskippy]

You haven't done it yet?

 

[tubeshooter]

Since you already have another flat top in the same caliber, that sounds pretty good to me. That being said I am not up to the second on values of either gun.


But if I wanted to get a nice quality DA in .45C, that looks like a great opportunity.


[ETA: That convertible BH is worth somewhat more than $600 nowadays. I might see if the other party would take less cash, myself.]

 

[IlikeSA]

You haven't done it yet?

I didn't have the second cylinder or box with me, I just happened to see it in Cabela's gun library. I took in one of my two carry guns for trade. They're holding it til this weekend for me.

 

[IlikeSA]

Since you already have another flat top in the same caliber, that sounds pretty good to me. That being said I am not up to the second on values of either gun.


But if I wanted to get a nice quality DA in .45C, that looks like a great opportunity.


[ETA: That convertible BH is worth somewhat more than $600 nowadays. I might see if the other party would take less cash, myself.]

I agree that the BH is worth more now, but I don't think they'd hold the MG while I tried to sell it. I also think the MG will sell before the weekend if they didn't hold it. They've only had it in the case a few days. I've only seen two MG's in any caliber the last few years, and I've been keeping my eye out.

 

[dannyd]

Depends on how much you shoot; 45 ACP you can use large or small pistol primers; 45 Long Colt just large and sometimes hard to find.

 

[Pat Riot]

Your Blackhawk plus $600, right?

Boy, to me that’s like $1300 for the S&W. I would be torn because I would love one of those Mountain Guns in .45 Colt. Since I haven’t physically seen one in a loooong time I would probably go for it, but I would try to get the price down.

 

[IlikeSA]

Your Blackhawk plus $600, right?

Boy, to me that’s like $1300 for the S&W. I would be torn because I would love one of those Mountain Guns in .45 Colt. Since I haven’t physically seen one in a loooong time I would probably go for it, but I would try to get the price down.

That is with the price down some. They wouldn't go any lower since they just put it into the case. Like you, I haven't seen one in any caliber or even a 25 in a long time.

 

[tubeshooter]

I paid around that for a 25-5 in recent times. It's not a horrible price...

Dealing with a big box store vs. a private individual changes the calculus a bit.


If I already had another flat top - I think I would go ahead and do it! 'Twould be interesting to see what their sticker price ends up being on your old BH...

 

[NIGHTLORD40K]

Do it. You might have a long wait before seeing another Mountain gun. .45 Blackhawks are not exactly rare.
You could always send the MT to TK for moon clip machining if you really want a convertible.

 

[UncleEd]

My memory of the .45 Colt MG is that it transmits more recoil and
sting to the hand than a Ruger single action. But that's
typical. It is easier to fire a RSBH in .44 mag than in a Model 29.
At least that's my experience.

 

[Riomouse911]

I would do it, especially if I had a second of the gun I was trading away.

My only Mountain Gun is a 629-4 .44 Mag, sitting here with my standard 4 5/8” Blackhawk .45 Colt. (The etched “Mountain Gun” and “.44 Magnum” have faded off the barrel over the years .) The MG is a bit of a kicker with magnum loads, but with pleasant mid-magnum loads it isn’t bad.



Since it is an N frame I wouldn’t punish a .45 Colt MG with loads the Blackhawk can handle, but loads of decent power in .45 Colt are manageable in the MG without being awful to shoot.

A MG in .45 Colt and/or .41 Mag would be awesome additions to any revolver collection. Good luck getting that one.

Stay safe.

 

[Hikingman]

What is the condition of each? I was involved in buying/ selling vintage musical instruments for a long time. How much (or how little) revolvers have been used can greatly affect the numbers.

 

[Tallball]

If you really want the MG, yes.

Money-wise it seems like a so-so deal, but if you really want one and aren't going to see another one for years, go for it.

 

[red rick]

I wouldn’t make that deal .

 

[IlikeSA]

What is the condition of each? I was involved in buying/ selling vintage musical instruments for a long time. How much (or how little) revolvers have been used can greatly affect the numbers.

Both are in similar condition: finish is stainless with minimal scratches, lockup tight, no end shake, wonderful triggers. I do need to bring my measuring tools to measure the cylinder gap and throats, but will do that before I conclude the deal.

 

[Hikingman]

That is a difficult decision. I thought the -6 MG are all 45acp, not 45 Colt, I guess I'm mistaken. Considering you have a Flat-Top, if the you're comfortable with the cost, it might work well as an addition.

 

[chaim]

I have a S&W 625MG in .45LC and it is a terrific gun. I don't shoot it much, .45LC ammo is expensive, and reloading components can be hard to find (and I simply haven't started reloading yet* even though I do have all I need to get started). Still, when I do shoot it I love it, and it is a great looking gun.

I can't really say if you should trade or not, but you won't be sorry if you do pic up a .45LC S&W 625MG.


*EDIT:
I left out a word... I haven't started reloading for IT yet. I do reload .38 and .357mag and have for nearly 20 years.

 

[Frulk]

I like the Smith MT Gun Series. Especially in .45 Colt.

The deal seems to be somewhat in Cabelas favor in my estimation. Have you considered selling the Ruger to a private party? FLAT TOP .45 Colts aren’t necessarily growing on trees either.

 

[Obturation]

Smith for a ruger? Not me. May be there's something you're looking for beyond what you got but I doubt the 625 would be sitting there available if it was a sweetheart. Just my thinking.
I've been burned on s&w and left unsatisfied by their customer service. So, nope. I'd hold that blackhawk tight and let that mountain gun float on down the river.

 

[jstert]

not a trade for me, but i don’t reload 45lc. i have one ruger blackhawk 45lc/acp convertible. i rarely shoot 45lc out of it. if i had two, i would trade one for a ruger blackhawk 357/38/9mm convertible, which i already have. neither of my ruger convertibles will leave me before i leave this earth.

 

[horsemen61]

I’d get it!

 

[CajunBass]

Would a hobo eat a ham samich? You betcha! I had a 45 Colt mountain gun some years ago. One of the few guns I kick myself for selling, but I was experiencing a "personal economic downturn" at the time.

 

[DR505]

I would trade. I carry my .45 Colt MG far more often than I do my Ruger SA. They are really good firearms.

 

[CraigC]

Sounds good to me, if that's what you want. The Ruger is more easily replaced.

I can tell you that my 629MG is one of the last guns I'll ever part with.