Wow so from pennies to crazy amounts per pound. I appreciate the replies. To those who asked, I just don't hunt because I never have. Like I said originally I would like to get into hunting. I'm currently laid off and trying to justify the purchase of a rifle to hunt deer with. Deer season opens here on 11/13 and if it makes sense I will buy one and fill the freezer. I have a great place to hunt at a relatives who lives in the Ozarks and always has deer on his land to the point of being pests in his garden. Just wanted to see if it made monetary sense.
This I can relate to! I was deprived as a child and was not taught to hunt or fish or even shoot. I started getting into hunting a couple of years ago with the express purpose of learning how to acquire meat in case of necessity. Employment or gov't scenarios that could lead us to that are numerous but will remain unmentioned so as not to sidetrack us (or get me in trouble
I have very much enjoyed the process of learning a bit about deer hunting. The first year I only went out a couple of times. Last year I went out a bunch but still did not get a deer. But I was learning and even saw several deer. This year I scored a small buck on my 4th trip into the woods. I will continue to hunt with some friends but it will be a different feel this year since I'll already have meat in the freezer. I guess my point is that there's a variable amount of effort involved and luck definitely factors into it.
If I were in your shoes I would first ask about the chance of success. The garden pest situation you described sounds very promising but I'd ask all sorts of questions to make sure.
Then I'd remind myself that folks dragged deer out of the woods long before there was camo or scent cover or 1000s of other "must haves" were even invented. Don't wear bright stuff and mind the wind. Deer are easily spooked but seem to have a short attention span.
Then I'd make the rounds of the local guns stores looking for a used but good condition .30-30 lever action rifle. Then I'd buy some ammo and shoot until I convinced myself I could hit a paper plate at the required distance (most likely 50-75 yards given what you described). If you've never shot a rifle that might cost some money. If you have then maybe only a partial box would be enough. Either way there's not much sense of shooting at an animal that might move if the wily paper plate is still eluding us.
And I'm not going to go into the ethical issues other than to say I think we owe it to the animal to make a good shot.
Ideally then I'd go get in place and be very still before the deer usual come to snack and then shoot the plumpest doe that comes in (assuming doe tags aren't overly expensive). And then I might wait around to see if they come back and shoot a second one.
Assuming butchering it yourself, not too much ammo, and $250-300 for a decent .30-30 you could easily come out ahead of store bought meat. But on the other hand there's always the risk of coming home empty-handed even after spending all the money. Luck, unfortunately, plays a big part. And when unemployed that luck factor is going to feel an awful lot like Dirty Harry's "do you feel lucky?"
Best of luck (on the deer and job hunting)!