Quail Hunt Follow-Up

Status
Not open for further replies.

TrapperReady

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2003
Messages
2,732
First of all, I want to offer up a big time apology, especially to re1973...

We ended up not shooting any quail.

After warming up with a few rounds of skeet, we had some lunch and waited for our field to open up. While at lunch, my friend talked with the kid who was going to plant our birds. As it turned out, the quail that he'd planted for a couple of morning hunts just weren't flying, they would just hunker down and sit really, really tight.

Knowing the nature of the dog we had, we realized that the dog would probably end up killing more quail than we would, so we went with the kid's recommendation and had him put out chukars instead.

When we went out to the field, we'd been walking maybe 10 minutes, and a large rooster pheasant flushed about 35 yards in front of us, going right to left. I was loaded with the 7/8oz of #7.5, and missed in front with the first barrel, but folded him with the second. The way that the bird cartwheeled down, I thought it would be DRT, but the dog retrieved one wounded, but very much alive bird.

The next 3 birds we flushed were all pheasants, and my friend had better shots and better ammo (using high velocity 1 1/4oz of 6s). He bagged all of them. We then got into a few chukars, all of which flushed at medium range, but were moving fast. With the light loads, I was getting feathers flying off, but was needing backup to actually get them to drop.

We worked our way back to the truck, got some water for the dog and dropped off our birds. I was not at all happy with my performance using these loads. I switched to a box of 1 1/8 oz #6s moving around 1450fps. We then went back into the field, and with the exception of one blatant miss, chukars and pheasants were dropping consistently and normally very much dead. The action was pretty heavy, and after another hour or so, the dog was getting tired.

Again, we returned to the truck to tend to the dog and drop off birds. By this time, I was running low on the #6s, so I decided to try the light loads for the first shot, with the heavier #6 as backup. On our last trip into the fields, we got into several birds we had missed on previous passes. Most were 30-40 yard shots (paced off) and the first shot would send feathers flying, while the second would put the bird down hard.

When we were done, we ended up with 12 chukars and 8 pheasants. Evidently, the folks who had the field before us had put out something like 20 pheasants, and only came back with 5 of them. I'm just glad we were able to help them out. ;)

So, at least when chukars and pheasant are likely game, I'm going to be using the hand-rolled 1 1/8oz fast-moving loads. The recoil isn't too bad, and they work very, very effectively. The 7/8oz loads work well on targets and I will try them on quail in the future, but I'm so far less than impressed with their effectiveness.

BTW, the pheasants went into my friend's freezer, but we ate the chukar for lunch on Sunday. They were breasted out, pounded to an even thickness and covered in pesto sauce. Lightly pan seared and served over pasta, it was quite tasty. Not exactly quail medallions with biscuits, but nice nonetheless.

Also, as a life-lesson for any pheasants out there. If a couple of hunters and a dog walk right past you... it's not the best idea to cackle loudly as you fly away behind them. :D

I figure this just gives me more time to find the right 28ga before my next quail opportunity.
 
Thanks for the post action debrief, TR.

Nest time, try 7/8 oz of 8s. The extra pellets fill the pattern nicely.

1 1/4 oz at 1450? Shoulder busters for real. But, firing at live game, you probably didn't feel much.
 
1 1/4oz? Nah.

Only 1 1/8 oz at 1450.

Actually, the first few times I lit them off, they seemed pretty impressive. However, as the day wore on, I hardly noticed them. I think the abundance of poultry in the air helped! ;)
 
That's the way it goes. Live game causes one to ignore kick, even stuff that hurts when shot at a static target.

1450 is pretty fast. Most of my current stuff runs 1150 to 1225.
 
No apologies needed; bird huntin' is bird huntin'...
Glad you had a good time.
I was afraid these birds wouldn't fly, btdt.

Never hunted pheasants, but I will someday.

On bigger birds and the few times I played the pigeon shoot game. I liked and used the 'super pigeon" load ( 3dr 1 1/18 oz running 1200 fps). Have also used the "old pigeon load" which IIRC was 3 3/4 dr of 1 1/4 oz of hard # 7.5. running 1330 fps. The later used most back in the day for teal, small ducks...etc., With a fixed choke gun (b/t a IC an Mod) ...lets just say I really liked teal.:D

I never really was radical ( other than testing on PB) on loads. Nowadays most stuff still loaded with 1 1/8 oz running 1150-1220 with hard shot. For a long long time I used the super light loads for competition, just changed shot sizes for game. I do use 7/8 and 1 oz loads, but I'm not in the league as most of you guys, I still need that "golden pellet". Just slow to change, and dunno patterned my guns...slow to change, no excuse...other than needing all the help I can get. 2 3/4 dr, 1 1/8 running 1150 , with hard 8s is my favorite all around load for skeet, 5 stand. S/C and small birds. I'm hopeless I guess. Funny thing is when I shoot the other 3 gauges I run 1200 fps, I don't have problem in the 12 ga running 1150...I did at one time run all 4 the same 1200 fps. I know I'm weird and hopeless.
I have fun tho'.

Glad you had a good time and got some birds.
 
A couple things...

On quail, my favorite meat shot is on one going straight away. I can snap shoot this one with great results. And 7/8 oz of 8s is more than enough,even on wild birds. Cylinder, Skeet and IC would be likely choices.

Pheasants, OTOH, have been swatted by Yr Humble Scrivener on similar shots and even though tumbled with lots of feathers drifting down, have outrun the dogs and may still be going for all I know.Wild Chinese Chickens have Kevlar back muscles and bones, it seems. On those, I prefer an angle shot and try to shoot the eye out. On wild birds, I'd prefer 1 1/4 oz of 6s or even 5s unless shots were running close. The least I'd use on wild ringnecks is a 1 1/8 oz trap load of 7 1/2s under most circumstances. Chokes would run up to Full, and a pocketful of choke tubes might be comforting.

Chukars, IMO, on preserves need less ooomph to drop than ringnecks. Wild ones in the Far West might call for tight chokes and 6s, but field loads of 8s and no more than Modified choke will work on pen raised stuff.

Teal, Bless them, have my number.Something inside me refuses to believe that something that small as waterfowl go can be moving that fast. I tend to miss teal WAY behind...

Along with dove, they serve as a reality check when I get to thinking I'm hot stuff with shotguns.Some friends report decent results with steel 6s, but I'd be more inclined to go with 4s in non tox.

Darn, I'd sure like to bag work today, throw on an old Filson vest with some loads in the pocket, whistle up a dog and head for a fencerow. But, duty calls...
 
BTW, we must of run into some new experimental chukar attack drone while out there. We had hit the end of a section of field, and were walking up a slight rise on a small access lane (where the folks who plant the birds can drive).

Anyway, the dog was working in the corn on our left and my friend was a double arms-length to my right. As I was scanning ahead, I saw this tiny missle approaching about chest high and flying NOE roughly 70 yards away. I double-checked the location of the dog and my buddy, clicked off the safety and took the shot, but by that time it had closed to about 10 yards and was still coming right at my chest.

My shot blew a bunch of feathers off its left side and it veered to the side, missing me and slamming into the edge of the corn rows, where the dogs promptly fetched it up. I swear that I had missed its head by about 3" with the wad.

One of the damndest things I've seen a bird do. We hadn't been anywhere near it when it had started flying. I almost wonder if it hadn't been shot at on another field and was simply escaping when it had the bad fortune to plow into us.
 
Trapper, your experience over the weekend mirrors the last couple of years of hunting for me.

I have reloaded shells for pheasants for the last 5 years or so. A combined total of WAY over 300 pheasants have fallen to my reloads in my presence (2 of my partners shoot my loads also). I shoot 20 gauge almost exclusively and my partners both shoot 12's.

IMO for pheasants #6 shot is MINIMUM for good clean GYDRT kills past 30 yards and inside of 45 yards. #5 shot is all I use these days and for good reason, they WORK. #5 shot launched at 1200fps will kill pheasants stone dead with 3 pellets in the body out to a stepped 50 yards. #6 shot works well most of the time but I have seen a good number of running crippled birds that were hit hard with 6's. Under very similar circumstances the #5 shot will kill the birds.

I have experimented heavily with Hodgdon Longshot in 12ga and had REALLY nice results. The 1 1/4 ounce max load with Remington wads in AA hulls is a real slayer. Patterns are superb for any speed and mind boggling for 1400+fps. Meat damage is DEFINATELY worse than lower speed loads but if you do your part and don't shoot too close it is a negligeable difference. Recoil is stout, no doubt about it, but when shooting birds it is not an issue.

Another fantastic load is a 1 1/8th ounce 12ga load at about 1300 using Winchester Super Field and Winchester components.

Pellet energy kills, you can create that energy with speed or pellet size or both but the fact remains that pellets with higher energy kill birds.
 
Sigh...
Sigh...
Besides drooling, I now have chest pains, and feel real birdymyself.
HSMITH I used a lot of #5 hard shot,back in the day, I like it.
Dave, I will hit/fell the Teal, even on 5 stand...the wabbit is the one I miss...put wings on a wabbit, I'd do better I'm sure...my shooting bud used to tease me "just pretend its a duck taking off and let get get to flight ( the hop)...my winged wabbit troubles starting going away and my scores up...
Got a funny story I'll post in hunting about quail/birds/ flight and dogs.
 
HSMITH - Thanks for your post. The load I've been most happy with recently has been a max load of Longshot in a AA Hull, pushing 1 1/8oz of #6s in a Windjammer (actually a CB-made clone) hull.

Since I'm just about out of them, I think I'll pick up a bag of #5 and try that instead. Someone here (very likely you) mentioned that they've had problems dropping #5 in a MEC 9000G. If it was you, what do you think about using an appropriately sized measure and just pouring them in on top of the wad at station #4?

I've used #5 shot in the past, but was getting decent results with #6, which is often easier to find in store-bought ammo. I think I may try one of the recipes using 1 1/4 oz and pushing around 1300, but with #5s instead of #6s.
 
Someone here (very likely you) mentioned that they've had problems dropping #5 in a MEC 9000G.

That likely was me, I have had problems and probably mentioned it here or on TFL at one time or another. #6 shot works fine in my 9000G but #5's are too big.


If it was you, what do you think about using an appropriately sized measure and just pouring them in on top of the wad at station #4?

Dumping them in at station 4 is exactly what I do. I took an old AA hull with a split and cut it off incrementally until I was throwing 550 grains, for my 1 1/4oz loads. I dipped it in the bowl of shot and leveled it off and weighed the "charge". I cut until I was +/- 20 grains on each dip. Then I did the same for 1 1/8th ounce.
 
TR, sounds like a Kamikaze Chukar. Good thing you hit it. Birds do some weird stuff.

H, darned if you don't make me want to dig out the 1 1/4 oz charge bar. Got a sample pack of Claybuster clones of the WAA114 wad around here, any suggestions on a load of 5s using them and some Unique salted away for a rainy day? Got a box or two of Nitro Golds saved for a special purpose load too. Thanks...

73, jumping teal were hard to figure out, but I'm catching on. Never saw a teal jump like that. Did shoot Woodies off small streams and ponds. They went up as if on an elevator.Will look for your epic...
 
I've got nuthin against reloading but for the past 3 years I've used the factory Fiocci- Golden Pheasant load. The nickel plated #5 shot at 1250 fps really swats em dead in the air and not alot of feather draw.
I'm leaving to hunt SW Iowa on Saturday. wild ringnecks and a few quail I hope!
 
HSMITH - If you hear a dull thudding sound, don't be alarmed, it's just me beating my head on a wall. Until I read your post, I'd been thinking of all kinds of different things I could get at the hardware store which could be customized into a shot measure.

Then you reminded me that I've got a few THOUSAND likely candidates sitting 3 feet from my reloader. :banghead:

Thanks for replying before I actually spent money on something.

BTW, I picked up a bag of #5 and plan to try the following recipe:

CAUTION: The following post includes loading data which is provided only for purpose of discussion. ALWAYS CHECK A RECIPE AGAINST A PUBLISHED SOURCE. Neither the writer, The High Road, nor the staff of THR assume any liability for any damage or injury resulting from use of this information.

Winchester AA Hulls
30.9 grains of Longshot
1 1/4 oz of #5 hard magnum shot
Remington 209P primers
Remington SP12 wads

According to the Hodgdon website, this should push around 1385fps and is not quite a maximum load.
 
Dave, I have not tried Unique but I have tried Universal which should be almost identical. I got decent loads with it but not the quality of patterns I got with Super Field (also nearly the same as Unique) and Longshot. If you need some wads to experiment with let me know, I have some F114's and some SP12's for sure, quite possibly some others also.

Kingcreek, that load works VERY well as would any load of good hard 5's. Hope you have an outstanding hunt, good luck!!!!

Trapper, I would laugh at the dull thumping sound, but let's just say I went through some trials finding something that would work and leave it at that...........:rolleyes:

The load you propose is just a smidge under what I have been shooting. I went between there and the max load last time I cranked some out. You are going to LOVE it. Unlike most ultrafast loads you don't need to choke it tightly. Mod will throw Mod patterns and Full will throw Full. Distribution with my loads has been outstanding.
 
"my friend talked with the kid who was going to plant our birds. As it turned out, the quail that he'd planted for a couple of morning hunts... "

Dang- I wish I could deer hunt this way. I'd have the kid that plants my deer put a nice 6 pt. at 150 yrds, a good 9 pt at 90 yards and a great 12 pointer at 45 yards!!:neener:
 
Kingcreek, that Fiocchi load is based on their live pigeon load, IIRC. Top components, including hard shot under that nickel.

Good luck on your trip, please post after action report here. Thanks.

H, thanks for the offer, but I'll just pick a bag of WAA12F114s and a bag of West Coast 5s. I was looking through the manual last night and noted the info on both Univ.Clays and Longshot. I might want to try to work up a super tight 2 3/4" load for turkeys that'll work well from Number 6's 40 POC barrel. Univ might get the nod, it has some application for 1 1/8 oz stuff and I don't NEED 1330 FPS.

I also may want to work up a long handicap load for trap with it. Any experience with Longshot in 1 1/8 oz loads?
 
Any experience with Longshot in 1 1/8 oz loads?

Yes, but nothing slower than 1400fps or so. At 1400 they made a nice game load but I did not try anything in regards to a trap load. Smallest shot used was #5. Minimum loads should heat up pattern centers, but I would beware with very low pressure rounds and cold weather coming, consistency with low pressure and cold wads is hard to get. You have a head start though, you are not going to be trying it in a backbored barrel so consistency will be a lot easier. Don't worry about recoil, Longshot has a very "pushy" recoil rather than getting popped like typical shotshell loads.

A couple years ago when I was going to be a good trap shooter I had a couple of really nice handicap type loads. Green Dot at about 1225, Universal at about 1250, and Super Field at about 1225 all worked really well with resonable fringes and hot centers. For a nice wintertime trap load Green Dot is always nice, and Universal should help distribute the pellets a little better.

Universal can be used ANYWHERE you have used Unique, it only meters better and burns cleaner. I use it in 9mm, 40, 45 acp, 45 Colt, 38 special +P, and 357 magnum.
 
Grayrock - If you want deer "hunting" like that, then check out some of the shows on OLN or the Outdoor Network. :rolleyes: The shooters are typically sitting around in a big box-on-stilts waiting for a deer to come get its daily feed from a timed rotary feeder about 75 yards away. They wait until they see the one they want, then "BLAMMO"!

When I talk about preserve birds, I try very hard to refer to it as shooting, not hunting. I think that distinction should be followed by some of the "hunting" shows as well. Otherwise, I may start calling it hunting when I go pick up steaks at the supermarket.
 
Followup for HSMITH - I just finished making a 1 1/4oz shot measure using your method.

I measured out 550 grains of #5 shot, and then poured it into an old AA hull. In a very bright room, I lined up my knife on the outside, even with the top of the shot. I then dumped the shot and carefully cut level with the mark. I was fortunate, and when I dipped and measured 20 or so times, everything was within +- 17 grains.

Then, I taped the measure to the end of a carpenter's pencil (with small strips of duct tape of course) and wrote the amount on the pencil with a Sharpie. I've found that dipping it into the shot, and then lightly bouncing it on the rim causes the excess pellets to fall away and gives very consistent results.

This evening, after the boys go to sleep I think I'll whip up a few boxes of the load I mentioned previously. If things work out, I may get to test them next Wednesday. If so, I'll let you know how they work.

Thanks again!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top