Quality of Evidence in legal system

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nicodemus38

Member
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
583
in most trials, the crime labs are always able to take a bullet from a crime, and determine the caliber, and the bore diameter and the depth of grooves.

However when i wanted to slug the barrel on my rifle, i suggested to several gunsmiths if it would be ok to simply load a roundball up with a super light low velocity load and simply shoot it into a bucket of water lined with bubble wrap to prevent any barrel damage from misuse of rod while pushing a slug down teh barrel in the conventional slugging method.

the gunsmiths told me that even if i used asuper light squib load to push it out into water or an old feather pillow, that the round ball would have so much velocity that the measurements taken would be 100% inaccurate considering my barrels bore as the impact at even such low velocity would mash the bullet beyond usefulness.

So i would like some kind of legal aspect on that if a projectile moving under low velocity is unusable to take accurate measurments of your barrel, then how can the state crime labs even identify the caliber of a fired round, or to even match a fired bullet with a particular gun.


logica train... if velocity+impact of projectile= projectile that cant be used for slugging a barrel

if measurements wont equal barrel how can it be compared to a lead pellet pushed by rod through a barrel to slug it to create a comparison?

better yet, if impact at any velocity alters teh bullet, how can the lab say that shooting a different bullet into a different test medium (water tank or rubber media) be assumed to create the same deformation of the bullet?
 
The ballistic match isn't the bore...which is what you were looking for by having the barrel slugged...it is the markings on the bullet made by the rifling as the bullet passed down the barrel. That is why they match another bullet fired through the barrel and not to the barrel itself...plus it saves having to slice the barrel in half.

An even more important match are the marks on the expended casing...if recovered
 
As well as the fingerprints on those casings. You know that thumb print you planted on it when you pushed it into the mag!
 
As well as the fingerprints on those casings. You know that thumb print you planted on it when you pushed it into the mag!
I may be incorrect, but I believe that the heat generated from the round being fired dissipates the oil from fingerprints.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top