Rethinking sidearm carry while hunting

Status
Not open for further replies.
My Texas License to Carry entitles me to carry whatever I want while hunting or not. I can carry it openly or concealed. I do always have at LEAST two handguns on me. Sitting in my box blind, I have taken rabbit with an NAA mini revolver at about 50 feet. :D That little revolver is often the only thing appropriate I have on me when I need something like that.
 
Down here, in Florida, we get them all year round. They turn up in the darndest places, too. Heavy
rain gets them moving to higher ground, sunshine gets them trying to dry out and warm up, and you see
a surprising amount of Rattlers and Moccasins in roadways, and near buildings.
We definitely have reptiles in the Gunshine state, but you quit seeing them around Nov. here. Of course, this is only Fl in the legal sense. It's really more like LA- Lower Alabama.
 
Regarding the "2 legged threat", which I don't deny is real- outside of the possible random afghan feral dog (and those things are mean and dangerous) the MAJORITY of our military (at least the ones who actually leave the FOB and do missions) aren't even issued a handgun- and the 2 legged threat is exactly what they are after. Just a thought.
 
Regarding the "2 legged threat", which I don't deny is real- outside of the possible random afghan feral dog (and those things are mean and dangerous) the MAJORITY of our military (at least the ones who actually leave the FOB and do missions) aren't even issued a handgun- and the 2 legged threat is exactly what they are after. Just a thought.

I carry concealed. I can legally carry my M4 down main street, but I'd probably stick out like a sore thumb and I likely would have a hard time going in restaurants and such with it. :rolleyes:

As for carrying for self defense in the woods, why not? I carry my NAA .22s for self defense. I don't think the military issues THEM, either.
 
I carry concealed. I can legally carry my M4 down main street, but I'd probably stick out like a sore thumb and I likely would have a hard time going in restaurants and such with it. :rolleyes:

As for carrying for self defense in the woods, why not? I carry my NAA .22s for self defense.
I don't think the military issues THEM, either.
I'm not saying there is a thing WRONG with carrying a handgun when hunting with a long gun. As I said before, I just don't think its necessary for me, at least for most of the hunting I do here (hogs being the exception). I carry concealed in all other situations- a S&W shield on me, AND a Glock 19 w/ 2 spare mags lives in each of my vehicles. In fact, hunting with a long gun for critters other than hogs here (deer, dove, turkey) is about the only time I don't have at least 1 handgun on me and/or immediately accessible. When I hunted black bear in Maine, I carried a 45 as extra insurance. I feel a centerfire rifle or 12 gauge shotgun are sufficient for not only the critter being hunted, but also for 2 legged "surprises". Yes, I keep a couple 00 rounds in my pocket when hunting with a shotgun. A shotgun with pretty much anything in it is more than adequate for legless critters. Hunting somewhere that security of my vehicle and contents is "sketchy"? I'll put the pistol in my backpack, or do something else with it. I guess it's mostly me trying to cut down on unneeded weight as well as things that may make noise in the stand/blind. I'm going to start duck hunting this month with an experienced friend- may carry a pistol then, due to gatorsauruses. I'll have to ask him about that.
 
I'm not saying there is a thing WRONG with carrying a handgun when hunting with a long gun. As I said before, I just don't think its necessary for me, at least for most of the hunting I do here (hogs being the exception). I carry concealed in all other situations- a S&W shield on me, AND a Glock 19 w/ 2 spare mags lives in each of my vehicles. In fact, hunting with a long gun for critters other than hogs here (deer, dove, turkey) is about the only time I don't have at least 1 handgun on me and/or immediately accessible. When I hunted black bear in Maine, I carried a 45 as extra insurance. I feel a centerfire rifle or 12 gauge shotgun are sufficient for not only the critter being hunted, but also for 2 legged "surprises". Yes, I keep a couple 00 rounds in my pocket when hunting with a shotgun. A shotgun with pretty much anything in it is more than adequate for legless critters. Hunting somewhere that security of my vehicle and contents is "sketchy"? I'll put the pistol in my backpack, or do something else with it. I guess it's mostly me trying to cut down on unneeded weight as well as things that may make noise in the stand/blind. I'm going to start duck hunting this month with an experienced friend- may carry a pistol then, due to gatorsauruses. I'll have to ask him about that.

Well, be careful, ducks are addictive. :D I wish I could still do it. I could if I didn't have to walk so far through the muck. It's just too hard on me anymore. I might still book a goose hunt now and then, but I do like calling the ducks.
 
A drop leg holster is about as uncomfortable an option as you will find if you are going to be walking. The weight carries much easier on the hip or in a chest rig. A good low profile hip holster or a chest rig would be a much more comfortable option and would keep your pistol accessible.
 
In Colorado, it is only legal to carry a handgun that is legal for the game you are hunting. Colorado has a list of approved loads. I rarely hunt in Colorado

Sigh...

That's probably why you don't know your assessment is incorrect.

I hunt big game in Colorado every year, and have since 1989. The current requirement is that any handgun used in the actual hunting of game meet the barrel length/energy/bullet type requirements. Your first shots or later a coup de grace both fit this scenario.

Handguns carried for any other purpose can be of any caliber or type, and this has been validated by me personally in the field with DOW officers- they really don't care what you have on your hip if you have a legal long gun.
 
I might be tempted to throw a little Walther P22 or Glock 42 in my fanny pack when bowhunting.

It's legal if you have CC permit here.
 
i very seldom pack while hunting: Just don't see the need. Additionally, much of my hunting on federal property; get caught packing there and it's big fine and possibly jail time.
 
For clarification, I rarely hunt in Colorado for several reasons:
1. Of the DOW officers I have questioned, only 60% have given me the interpretation cited by .455 Hunter . The other have given me the interpretation I cited (and given me the impression they didn't want people to hunt at all).
2. On public land during bib game seasons, the hunter density is way to high for my taste.
3. I have a much better alternative available to me in West Texas. No elk and the deer are small, but the Mexican food is much better...
 
For clarification, I rarely hunt. Of the DOW officers I have questioned, only 60% have given me the interpretation cited by .455 Hunter . The other have given me the interpretation I cited (and given me the impression they didn't want people to hunt at all).
2. On public land during bib game seasons, the hunter density is way to high for my taste.
3. I have a much better alternative available to me in West Texas. No elk and the deer are small, but the Mexican food is much better...

1. Your style of interaction with the DOW officers must be different than mine. I have found them to be friendly and helpful in almost every scenario.

2. True- That's why the draw is the only way to go, not OTC.

3. That's your opinion, and makes for one less safety orange vest here in CO, so that's OK. By the way, there are elk in West Texas, but you have to know where to find them.
 
I don't get how im allowed to carry a loaded 18round handgun to and from the stand but not my loaded primary rifle to defend myself.
While I don't necessarily agree with it, there is some logic behind that reg. The idea is that the hunting weapon is only supposed to be loaded during legal hunting hours. Helps the GW be more confident that you weren't hunting illegally if the gun isn't loaded. When CCW permits became a thing in Ohio 15 years ago, it threw a monkey wrench into things and for a while, we couldn't carry concealed while hunting. That got changed but it's still with the caveat that your concealed carry weapon is not a hunting implement.
 
While I don't necessarily agree with it, there is some logic behind that reg. The idea is that the hunting weapon is only supposed to be loaded during legal hunting hours. Helps the GW be more confident that you weren't hunting illegally if the gun isn't loaded. When CCW permits became a thing in Ohio 15 years ago, it threw a monkey wrench into things and for a while, we couldn't carry concealed while hunting. That got changed but it's still with the caveat that your concealed carry weapon is not a hunting implement.
Stupid law right there. I would think the absence of gunshots, q-beam, and bloody critters would be sufficient evidence of not night hunting. I want to do everything that makes noise (like loading a gun) well BEFORE entering the woods.
 
A drop leg holster is about as uncomfortable an option as you will find if you are going to be walking. The weight carries much easier on the hip or in a chest rig. A good low profile hip holster or a chest rig would be a much more comfortable option and would keep your pistol accessible.
You haven't used a well configured drop leg then. I'll agree that the Lara Croft style isn't much good for anything other than accenting attractive legs, but a good single strap drop leg rig that's set up right works fine for long distance walking.
 
Stupid law right there. I would think the absence of gunshots, q-beam, and bloody critters would be sufficient evidence of not night hunting. I want to do everything that makes noise (like loading a gun) well BEFORE entering the woods.
As I said, I don't necessarily agree with it. And I can assure you that very few people are actually waiting to load up till shooting light.
 
If I were going to carry a handgun for a backup while hunting, it would be a Glock 20, 10MM with an aftermarket 6 inch KKM barrel.

Marginally powerful enough, and reasonably light. With Buffalo Bore 220 grain hard cast, it should serve me well enough.
 
You haven't used a well configured drop leg then. I'll agree that the Lara Croft style isn't much good for anything other than accenting attractive legs, but a good single strap drop leg rig that's set up right works fine for long distance walking.

I’d say Safariland makes a pretty decent holster and I carried a Beretta all over Iraq in it. I stand by my statement that a drop leg is less comfortable than anything else when you are doing a bunch of walking/moving into shooting positions/getting in and out of vehicles or tree stands. You are entitled to your opinion, but let’s not assume I’m forming my opinion based on an Uncle Mike’s holster.
 
I’d say Safariland makes a pretty decent holster and I carried a Beretta all over Iraq in it. I stand by my statement that a drop leg is less comfortable than anything else when you are doing a bunch of walking/moving into shooting positions/getting in and out of vehicles or tree stands. You are entitled to your opinion, but let’s not assume I’m forming my opinion based on an Uncle Mike’s holster.
I assumed you were forming your opinion based on experience with a double leg strap holster of some sort. The single strap Safariland's are worlds better, IMO. As you say, to each their own though.
 
I tried wearing a Blackhawk thigh holster hiking and also at work and its very uncomfortable. Bangs around, gets caught on everything and hurts my leg.

My next holster for woods CCW will be a kenie chest holster.
 
I’d say Safariland makes a pretty decent holster and I carried a Beretta all over Iraq in it. I stand by my statement that a drop leg is less comfortable than anything else when you are doing a bunch of walking/moving into shooting positions/getting in and out of vehicles or tree stands. You are entitled to your opinion, but let’s not assume I’m forming my opinion based on an Uncle Mike’s holster.
We had the same ones in 2001- and before. After we realized they weren't the right answer- not just for all the humping we did in the mountains (not unlike a lot of elk hunters) but also for riding in vehicles with the entire inventory of a REI and an army surplus store. You know what we did? We disassembled our safariland leg holsters from the S&M harnesses, threw away everything but the holster itself, then ordered and attached the belt drop assemblies, and turned these things into pretty much the same holster every cop in the US carries. because those guys spend some time walking around, and a whole bunch of time riding in cramped vehicles with a bunch of stuff too. That configuration is still in use with those guys today, except they are multicam and there is a different pistol in it than we used in 2001.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top