Review: Ed Brown Special Forces - Added Gunsite Update

Status
Not open for further replies.

TexasRifleman

Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Feb 16, 2003
Messages
18,301
Location
Ft. Worth
This is the saga of a boring 1911. Boring because it's just a 1911. No bells, whistles, uber this or that, just a plain looking 1911. Boring because it doesn't give me any drama, just goes "bang" every time, no matter what I've fed it so far.

The story started back in January at the SHOT Show when I walked by the Ed Brown booth taking pictures for THR. Like so many booths there was something cool to look at and I'd usually snap a few and walk on. Except I didn't walk away this time. A short chat with the Brown folks about THR and why we were there led me to asking about their Centennial models. I looked at a couple of displays and they are impressive indeed. But sitting alone back in the corner of the display was this plain looking 1911. "What's that one" I asked?

Here's the pic I took back in January at SHOT. You can see I was focusing on shiny stuff! Didn't even put the boring SF model into the frame completely.

brown1.gif

"That is the Special Forces model". OK, there's some marketing cheeeeese for sure. I go to comment on that and I stop myself. His company, he can call them what he wants. But, it's a nice looking handgun so I asked to take a look. To make a long story short before I walked away from his booth I had made arrangements (with a dealer friend of mine at the show with me) to order one of these as soon as possible.

Fast forward to the first of August and I get a phone call from my FFL that the order is filled. After a nice lunch of sliders and filling out a 4473 at the table (sorry about the ketchup on the form) we walked to the parking lot where I was handed this plain blue case and I was on my merry way.

** Side note here. In fairness to Brown, my dealer friend didn't actually complete the order in January, he bought 5 pistols all at once and waited until he had orders for all 5. Brown requires 5 to be considered a "stocking dealer" or whatever they call it. I don't want to send the wrong idea on lead times. Brown promised 3 months and it was pretty much right on the money.

Some pictures, then more on the gun.

brown1-1.gif

I ordered this one with 4 Brown magazines, test fired in the gun. Believe it or not this is my first 1911 in .45, all my others have been in 10mm. Strange it took me this long. But, I had no .45 mags so I figured I'd start a collection :)

brown2-1.gif

Like I said, it's just a boring looking 1911. No drama. It's a trick, more on that later....

brown3.jpg

No FLGR, no funky springs, just a plain old plug? I thought this was an Ed Brown. Boring :)

brown4.gif

Brown calls this "Chainlink". It's boring looking too.....trust me, there's a happy ending to this lol.

brown6.gif

More Chainlink. Note the frame to slide alignment. No uneven gaps, no loose fit. Boring :)

brown7.gif

And put away nicely into my Tucker HF1. I love this holster, and hang onto it in hopes that someday I can open carry in Texas. In the meantime I wear it at the range and when I visit free states. That's another review, but it's an excellent holster. Not boring, very bling!

brown8.jpg

OK, so now to the boring review. I say boring because I'm used to blinging out my 1911's, and usually I do it with Ed Brown parts. So I was surprised he was making something so "plain".

But that's the beauty of this. I wanted an utterly reliable combat 1911. Not that my IPSC guns have been less than reliable, but I wanted one just for carry, and in .45. And that's exactly what I got. This thing is built like a tank. The finish is Browns Gen III coating, which is pretty much like tank armor as far as I can tell.

No full length guide rod, a religious argument really, but I've always used them (one pieces, not those 2 part monstrosities). But I figured it's 100 years later, maybe old JMB was right about the plug (turns out he was).

I didn't go for any of the stainless options either, just boring old steel in a dark finish. It's "just" a 1911.

So, I've taken it home, taken it completely apart, cleaned (didn't need it), lubed (didn't need that either, it was ready to go), and put it in the bag for a quick range trip.

Now it's been over 100 degrees for almost 2 months straight, so I have not had a long range session, just several short early morning shoots, and the boring old Ed Brown is still boring. Oh, as for the boring Chainlink, shooting in 100 degree weather requires a very good surface to maintain a solid grip with sweaty hands, the Chainlink is fantastic! Great grip but not painful like some more aggressive checkering styles I've tried.

It has fired about 1000 rounds now; Blazer, Georgia Arms Canned Heat, WWB, my reloads with both RN and SWC 230-gr bullets and it's so boring it hasn't failed to fire anything I've fed it. So boring it puts all the empties in a pile together. I have not decided on carry ammo yet, will be working on that later.

Here's a target, from about 15 yards out, just messing around. Boring, all right there together.... And the low/left isn't the gun's fault . Shocking I know....

brown9.gif


So. It's a boring 1911. And as far as I can tell so far, it's the finest 1911 I've ever owned or touched. It's built for real use, by a man who knows what he's doing. Oh he knows how to make nice shiny guns too, my friend at SHOT with me bought a Dave Champion model that's absolutely beautiful and the Centennial Models are spectacular!

This Special Forces model is so boring that I'm taking it to Gunsite for their 1911 Centennial class in late September, and I'm not even taking a backup gun. Will update this review after that class, I expect a week at Gunsite will really tell the tale on performance.

So there's not much to say here really. If you have an interest in a 1911 that fires every time, all the time, made with the best parts on Earth by (in my opinion) the best 1911 'smith on Earth, look into the Special Forces model.

Cheesy name, boring handgun, and I'd buy 10 more if I could afford them.

It's so boring I don't think I could take the excitement of a 1911 that fails to feed, fails to lock open, or sprays bullets all over the target.

It's probably the last 1911 model I will ever buy, unless I see something else at the Brown booth at the next SHOT Show :)
 
Last edited:
I have a lot of guns, and enjoy the variety. But, if I had to choose one gun, I have thought that the Brown Special Forces just like yours (only ambi, 'cause I'm a lefty) would be the one. Except, I'd just have to buy two. Yeah, a pair of them ought to do. If I could only have one gun, it would be a pair of Brown SF's. :D
 
I have a Brown also. It's a frickin' laser. Shoots so well, I find myself hardly shooting it. Every time, every time, I take it out it puts them in the same spot in a tiny group. Ok..back to the safe you go. ;)

Congrats.
 
I have an Executive Target pic as my screen saver, and I consider Brown to make the finest 1911's extant. My only complaint, and it would never keep me from owining one funds permitting, is with the 7 round mags. Surely Ed at some point will join the rest of the planet in agreeing that an 8 round mag that is 100% reliable is technically possible. My Wilson 8rounders have never bobbled once.
 
SharpsDressedMan said:
Any reason you don't just use the Wilson mags in the Brown pistol?

Ahh, the religious discussion :) I don't have a great answer really.

I bought these 4 mags just because they have the Brown logo, I don't plan on using them as my primary mags because honestly I'd rather have 8 rounders.

I have 8 McCormick PowerMags ordered from Midway that I'll use unless they for some reason don't work.

I have used Shooting Stars in my 10mm's and had good luck but don't want those for carry of course, so I'm already a happy CMC customer.

My reason for choosing the PowerMags is this article:

http://www.10-8performance.com/pages/1911-Magazines.html

I wish I'd have read this article before I ordered the gun and I'd have skipped the 7 rounders.

Hilton Yam Article said:
It is my feeling that the day of the 7 round magazine in a full sized Government Model has passed

And since this is my first 1911 in .45, and I didn't know what mags to use, I am going with this recommendation until I experience a reason to go another way.

If you'd have asked me a few weeks ago I'd have said Wilson I suspect. I know of Hilton Yam's reputation for this sort of thing and so I'll trust him for now.

I honestly don't have any preference or experience of my own to refer to.
 
aliasneo07 said:
How much did it run you?

Well I got it at dealer cost for a stocking dealer because my very good friend has his FFL. That's why I had to wait so long to get it, so my FFL could get enough orders to make it to the stocking dealer price. I'd rather not publish Browns dealer cost because I don't know if he makes that public or not. If you can find it on Google or whatever, that's what I paid. I want to make it clear that Brown was not involved in that, that was between my dealer and I.

List is $2295 but I don't really know where they sell at normally.
 
Thanks for the review. I've always liked the classic good looks of Ed Brown pistols and hope to get an Executive Elite one day.

This thing is built like a tank.

If you like that tank like feeling, check out Les Baer's pistols. I don't know what it is, but his guns make Browns feel downright svelte in comparison.
 
I've noticed that as well. I think EB melts or shapes the frame and slide a bit more.

LB's allways feel like they could use a little extra time getting melted or trimmed a bit. But that's what holster wear and eventual refinishing is for.
 
ps: Tucker holsters are fantastic. I wear one everyday and I recommend them.

The plain-jane 1911 though... meh. Too much attention to detail produces predictable results. Where's the fun in no surprises?
 
My CMC PowerMags arrived last evening so I took a quick early morning range trip with them. No problems new from the bag anyway.
 
AKElroy said:
My only complaint, and it would never keep me from owining one funds permitting, is with the 7 round mags. Surely Ed at some point will join the rest of the planet in agreeing that an 8 round mag that is 100% reliable is technically possible. My Wilson 8rounders have never bobbled once.

You can order 8-round mags from Ed Brown when you order a pistol. I did exactly that when I ordered a Special Forces Rail.

TexasRifleman, congrats on your Ed Brown. I bought a Special Forces Carry last year and added a Special Forces this year. I'm now waiting on a Special Forces Rail with quite a few custom options that should be here in early December. Like you, I've found them to be superbly made, extremely reliable and accurate 1911s that exceed all of my expectations. I really like the chainlink but opted to pay for 25lpi checkering on the Rail model that I ordered. I'll be using it in USPSA matches so wanted more aggressive checkering. Here are my two.

eb_sfc_vz_02.jpg


eb_sf_vz_01.jpg
 
Last edited:
TexasRifleman

Thank you for your thoroughly boring review of yet another thoroughly boring M1911 from Ed Brown.

While I don't own one of his fine pistols, I have used his M1911 parts for years and have been completely satisfied with their design, attention to detail, and their outstanding quality.

In other words, I have been thoroughly bored by their performance as well.
 
Last time special units used something like this it was made by Ithaca, Rand,..... Perhaps pathfinders of WWII? I think FN P-35 was preferred weapon even at that time.
 
Boring.

HA! That's my kind iof boring. A truly beautiful pistol and one I would really love to have. Some kids dream of lollipops and others of suger plums but I will be dreaming of that 45 for a long time
 
PabloJ said:
Last time special units used something like this it was made by Ithaca, Rand,..... Perhaps pathfinders of WWII? I think FN P-35 was preferred weapon even at that time.

Do a couple of JTACs with NSWC count as "special units"? If so, I personally know of two that carried similar in Iraq/Afghanistan.
 
Everyone loves the Kobra. Kobra this and Kobra that. Even Kimber tried to copy the snakeskin with that godawful Raptor (sorry if you happen to own one :eek:). Well, I've always said the SF was the best looking Brown in the lineup, and some may think it's boring, but I think it is just a "clean" looking 1911. If I had the money, I'd own one. I want the carry version so bad I can't stand it. Maybe I'm boring too. :scrutiny:

Great pistol, and great thread. Love me some Brown pics. :cool:

Jason
 
Jason_G said:
Even Kimber tried to copy the snakeskin with that godawful Raptor (sorry if you happen to own one ).

I own one ... and I like it, but I can understand why someone wouldn't. The "scales" aren't machined nicely like an Ed Brown but they're very effective in terms of gripping the frame or the slide.
 
I own one ... and I like it, but I can understand why someone wouldn't. The "scales" aren't machined nicely like an Ed Brown but they're very effective in terms of gripping the frame or the slide.

:eek: Hope I didn't offend, I just never cared for them aesthetically speaking. Different strokes for different folks I guess. I always liked the more "minimalistic" approach. Not a big fan of rollmarks, front cocking serrations, and a whole lot of other embellishments that some folks prefer, either.

Jason
 
Jason_G said:
Hope I didn't offend, I just never cared for them aesthetically speaking. Different strokes for different folks I guess. I always liked the more "minimalistic" approach. Not a big fan of rollmarks, front cocking serrations, and a whole lot of other embellishments that some folks prefer, either.

No offense taken. What someone else likes or dislikes is their business. It only becomes my business when someone makes it personal e.g. "you're a moron if you like x, y or z" or "you're an idiot if you don't want a, b or c". Your point about not liking front cocking serrations is interesting. Currently, I only have one 1911 with them and when it came time to place the order for an EB Light Rail, I went all out and requested front cocking serrations on the slide, plus a bunch of other upgrades. I wanted to turn the Light Rail into a hardcore "fighting" 1911 that I could use in matches, courses and classes. It's hard to run weak-hand drills without an ambi safety. It's hard to rack the slide on a belt or holster with standard Ed Brown sights. The front cocking serrations might help with press checking with a flashlight mounted ... and so on. Here's a list of the upgrades that I added because I see a need for them. Other people have different needs.

10-8 Performance rear sight, tritium front sight
25lpi front strap checkering
Ambi thumb safety
Front slide cocking serrations
Maxi-Well
Extended mag release
Checkering on underside of slide stop lever
8-round mag upgrade
VZ Double Diamond dirty olive grips (have those already)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top