I had a P944 .40S&W, was a good handleing pistol; if felt great, good ergonomics, good pointing, very reliable, it held a horrible group, about 14" at 25yrds... but it shot about 8" to the right for me at 7yrds, I just couldn't fit it right in my hand to be able to hit accurately. I bought it for $400 with 3 mags and sold it for $400 after 400 rounds. This was about 2 years ago. I'm a pretty experianced pistol shooter, the darn thing drove me crazy. Never had a single FTE/FTF issue with that Ruger though.
First time Pistol buyer: see if there is a local range around that rent's pistols, I was almost said and done that I wanted a Glock (pre-XD time period), till I put a 1911 in my hand, I'd never even considered a 1911 till renting one, I think I've tried every .45acp that the local range carries.
Pistols can be fitted, buy moral of my post goes, just because it feels good doesn't mean it will comply to your hand naturally.
BTW: if you get a 1911, might as well pick out your second and third one, even before you've shot the first... the have a way of reproduceing