Newtosavage
Member
- Joined
- Nov 30, 2015
- Messages
- 2,918
On paper they are pretty close, but having taken deer with both I would personally rank the 30-30 a notch up on the ladder due to being able to handle heavier bullets and because the soft flat wide nose bullets in the 30-30 are more terminally effective than the numbers would leed you to believe. Both are perfectly adequate within their range when properly loaded.
So, I would have said the same thing a couple years ago. I've shot a LOT of critters with a 30-30 over the past 35 years. And I mean a lot. Over 500, thanks to an abundance of feral pigs around here. And you are absolutely right - the soft, flat wide nose 30-30 bullets do seem to kill with more efficiency than the numbers on paper would predict.
But having said that, now that I have several dozen critters downed with two different 7.62x39 bolt actions (Savage and Howa) and have hand loaded for the 7.62x39 for several years, I'm picking the 7.62x39 over the 30-30 anymore. It's more accurate, and has more range, and the terminal performance is so close to what I saw with my beloved 30-30 for so many years that it's really a toss-up. So given that it's a toss-up, I'll take the improved accuracy and extra 100 yards the 7.62x39 bolt action gives me. You know, because I can.