What are you going to be using the firearm for?? because that matters to some people and they are going to ask. the only advise i can give is that I have never ever ever ever heard anything bad about the S&W 1006, 4506, 4006 etc. those series or models are well built guns that are seriously good at what they do. with that being said, I cannot bring myself to change platforms from 1911's. mainly the thumb safety, it is ingrained in my head to draw and push safety down. If I could change the safety I would own a bunch of them. Dont make a decision based on what I think, wait for people who have experience with both firearms because I have never even handled an EAA.