S&W629 8 3/8 vs 6 1/2

[Delta959]

Hey all,

I'm looking at getting a 44 for hunting here in South Dakota. I've decided on a Smith 629, but have a slight issue. I really don't like the full barrel lug on the longer barrels. My main gun shop can just order me a 6 1/2 without the lug (for a good price), and I thought that was perfect.

I then made the mistake of going to another store about 30 mins away, and they had a 629 Classic 8 3/8 NIB. I loved the extra length of that barrel, but with the full lug it was front heavy. They were asking about $50 more for it then ordering the 6 1/2. I'm sure I can talk them down, as they have that exact gun since '09, so price isn't really an issue.

So to my question. Is the 8 3/8 that much better? Will I really notice a difference when shooting? Will the barrel lug help? I'm pretty new to 44 mags, as I've only fired a 44 mag SBH, so don't know how the Smiths will compare.

I want to stay local, so getting one off the internet isn't an option I like.

Thanks,

Delta

 

[S.B.]

Depends on the -number after the model number in the crane cutout? My main worry would be if the cylinder turns backwards with each shot! Some of the older -numbers will with wear. Please, do some more research on this before you buy?
Steve

 

[Delta959]

They are both "-6"

 

[S.B.]

Then, no problems! /Any will have the encurance enhacements added.
Steve

 

[mdauben]

So to my question. Is the 8 3/8 that much better? Will I really notice a difference when shooting? Will the barrel lug help?

I actually like the full underlug, as I think it helps lessen recoild and muzzle rise when firing. As far as the two different barrel lengths, you will probably get a minor increase in velocity with the longer barrel, but personally I find the 6.5 inch barrel balances better for off-hand shooting. YMMV

 

[David E]

For a pure hunting gun, the 8 3/8ths" is presumably better, but the 6-6 1/2" is a better all around.

My 6" 29 and 8 3/8" 629 don't have under lugs, for which I am grateful. I carry them more than shoot them. And unless all your "hunting" will be from a motorized vehicle, you'll probably appreciate less weight, too.

 

[Delta959]

Most of my hunting involves hoofing it. My main areas are about a mile away from any road. This is actually why I'm getting into handgun hunting. more challenge, less gear.