Selling Sentimental Guns

Status
Not open for further replies.
When my Dad died my Mom, who hated guns, sold them for pennies on the dollar before mentioning this to myself or my brother. I would have truly loved to have the pistol that Dad kept in his underwear drawer my entire childhood life, a Browning Hi-Power. As for the guns I bought, the only one that has any emotional value to me is the one I bought the day after my home was burglarized in the early '80's and I needed something for home defense. I bought a beautiful S&W Model 19, nickel, 4-inch, 357 Magnum that for many years was my go-to gun for middle of the night concerns. It is retired from that role but this is one gun I would never want to part with.
 
My dads got my World War One trench fighter "war criminal" #1 bada__ great grandfathers Colt Woodsman he bought new in '36. I'll get it some day but I won't like the circumstances that will lead to it.

The rest of his guns I gave him. Only way to ensure you get the good stuff.
 
everyone is different but I dont put any sentimental value into material goods.

At any given moment I determine if something is useful or not.

The only "sentimental" things I keep are photos. Ill take a photo of things if I want to remember them.

Photos are digital so they take no space.
 
Tx....to a certain degree, I agree with you. If I had a $10,000 heirloom and needed to pay the bills, I would sell. However, when the sentimental value exceeds the monetary value I can't justify it. My grandfather's Wingmaster might fetch $400-$500, but I might spend that on two very good meals with my wife. Therefore....I can't justify it.
 
everyone is different but I dont put any sentimental value into material goods.

At any given moment I determine if something is useful or not.

The only "sentimental" things I keep are photos. Ill take a photo of things if I want to remember them.

Photos are digital so they take no space.
This is a good mentality to have as it avoids allowing money to be stuck in unused property, or clutter to enter your home. I do feel sentimental about some objects because they serve as a pneumonic devise that stirs up memories when I handle them.

I can go a little overboard on this. For instance, I don't want to sell the first handgun I ever bought, despite not having shot it for like a year and a half. That money would be better served going into another gun I do want to shoot, or reloading equipment. However, I'm sure it'll come out to play again one day, and it serves as a backup carry gun, so I just can't force myself to ditch it.

My father is an example of extreme sentimentality. He guilt trips my siblings and I into taking old junk because he clings to the past so heavily. He once insisted that I take a hammer that was so rusted up and old, that I was afraid it would break with any use, purely because it belonged to my grandfather.

His sentimentality is pathological IMO. He keeps a deck of old playing cards that is twice as thick as it should be because the cards are beat up and bent. They belonged to my mom, who died a few years ago. He won't use them because they are so beat up, but he won't get rid of them either. In a home full of objects that would remind him of my mom, I don't understand why he insists on keeping consumable objects that should be disposed of.

As guns are a durable good that can survive years of use, I can understand why people get really attached to them.
 
There are a few guns of my dad's that probably have sentimental value, at least to me. I have a couple of my own to which I am sentimentally attached. I'm not sure that my brother or dad ever get sentimentally attached to guns. At any rate, if I had any of dad's guns, I'd offer them to my brother before I sold them to a stranger.
 
Photos are digital so they take no space.

guessing your pretty young....




As for the OP, if your already contemplating it, they must not have that much sentimental value...
 
It would depend on the gun and whether or not he held any special feeling for it.

For example if my father purchased a gun and then a year later, god forbid, something happened to him, that gun would not really hold any special meaning to me. Simply because he owned it at some point wouldn't really make me keep it.

Now there are some that he has that definitely do have sentimental value.

There is the Springfield model 37 12-gauge pump that my mother bought him the first year they were married. She paid $60 for it at Western Auto and it would blow your mind the number of deer, squirrel, rabbit and dove that thing has killed. It means a lot to him and will mean a lot to me or my brother when he's gone.

So with his about half of them mean something and about half are just guns he's purchased on a whim that don't even mean much to him.

Of course there are also guns that he has gifted me through the years and those mean a lot to me and will never leave the family while I'm alive.
 
By the time I was born Dad had whittled down his collection to 3 guns, I started shooting and hunting with them by myself at 13 so they became my guns for all intent and purposes.

I still have the Winchester md50, Winchester md63 and Colt Match target(2nd series) still use them.

So OP if you have reservations about selling then find a way to use them, maybe trap or skeet a couple of times a year.
 
Firearms are not very popular in my family. I can count on one hand the number of firearm owners, including myself, and still have fingers left over. If my grandfather, another gun owner, passed away leaving me his few rifles I would never sell them. That is just how things run in my family however.

Here is an exercise you can do however. Put them in storage for a few months and forget you have them. If you open your safe and start to miss having those firearms there, it is not a good idea to sell them.
 
I inherited quite a few guns from my dad. I still have the ones with memories attached. Others I have sold or traded off. He loved wheeling and dealing and passed that trait down to me. :D
 
The proper thing to do would be to identify some other relative, or surviving friend of your father's, and pass them on to someone who might appreciate them more.
 
Owned almost all the snakes. Yep, everything but the Boa. Python, Viper, King Cobra, Anaconda, .....like a fool I sold them for half what they bring today....all were nickel and in 98% condition. :banghead: Yes, now, I buy high $ guns and keep them. I am a buyer and keeper now. Here is my last to come my way....


cdp.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top