12 Gauge or 20?
I will assume 12 Gauge for the purpose of this...
For the record, I, too, like the 1100. But I have an old one, a good one.
Here's something you don't hear from a bird hunter all that often: "Damn, after carrying this gun around all morning, I really wish it was heavier!" If you hunt flat country and don't walk around much, that isn't a big issue. Otherwise, I think it is.
So, I would put the 11-87 last and the Browning next to last, just based on their weight. Nothing wrong with them, as shotguns.
The price of the Benelli is a bit of a turn-off. If you need to be able to shoot 500 rounds in a morning, in the heat, and 500 more in the afternoon, it's good for that. I know at least one guy who paid over $1500 for one, an ugly black plastic Cordoba, because he goes way south and hunts doves, no magazine plug, hundreds of rounds per day, in Mexico. He says it was well worth it; the gun is flawless. I shot it, and liked it. Shoots like a dream, and it's light, as a bonus. Get the Comfortech, though!
The Urika 2 is a great gun. However, I would be tempted to get a 3901 instead, in walnut, believe it or not. Save money (compared to all the other guns listed) and get a great Beretta gas-operated semiauto. It is also light, and wood just feels better, to me, all else being equal, unless you want it for waterfowl also. It's not real fancy, so you won't have to feel bad if you use it.
I might also consider the Urika 2 in walnut. It is the lightest gun of all you listed, but only in walnut.
Another gun to look at is the 105CTi from Remington. Bottom-eject, almost no felt recoil at all, light, well-balanced. It is expensive, though, and I don't know how well it's been working for down-and-dirty real world hunting. I've shot one, and I loved it, though.
All of that said, in this and surrounding states we have a 3-round limit for birds. I'm liking my O/U lately, and I don't have to go around picking up hulls like with a semiauto. But it's a 20. There are only a few 12 Gauge O/U's I'd want to carry around a lot.
So, of those 4, I'd say Urika, Benelli, Remington, with the Browning as a ???
I don't have an opinion on the Browning Silver, since I haven't shot one or spent any time around those who were shooting one.
