A few weeks ago, I picked up two Pietta 1858s from Cabela's - a target model and the 5.5" barreled 'sheriff' model. At first I was planning on returning whichever I liked less, but after checking them out I decided I really liked both. Shot the target model last week and it was awesome, though I didn't bring along the shorty.
So anyway, one thing I noticed with the short one right away was that the hammer was significantly easier to pull back than the hammer on the target model. I thought I liked that at first, but now it just feels less solid and kindof 'klinky' to me.
Since then I've also found that the cylinder pin doesn't snap into place in the frame like the other 1858's does. Without the cylinder in place and the loading lever down, it just slides around freely. With the gun assembled, it still clicks around back and forth in the millimeter or two of space it has between the frame and the loading lever. A little annoying.
Last but not least - the trigger is a little creepy and doesn't seem to break as cleanly as the target model's does.
I think the easy hammer pull could be fixed by just tightening the main spring screw a tad, but I wouldn't be comfortable messing with the trigger and the cylinder pin. I'm not all that mechanically inclined and beyond basic cleaning/disassembly I've really no 'smithing experience at all. Would rather not pay for a tune-up.
Aside from these small problems, it's really nice. But these issues just make me feel a bit less enthused about it. Should I have them replace it and hope I get one in better shape, or would you just keep it and not let the minor flaws bother you?
Thanks in advance!
So anyway, one thing I noticed with the short one right away was that the hammer was significantly easier to pull back than the hammer on the target model. I thought I liked that at first, but now it just feels less solid and kindof 'klinky' to me.
Since then I've also found that the cylinder pin doesn't snap into place in the frame like the other 1858's does. Without the cylinder in place and the loading lever down, it just slides around freely. With the gun assembled, it still clicks around back and forth in the millimeter or two of space it has between the frame and the loading lever. A little annoying.
Last but not least - the trigger is a little creepy and doesn't seem to break as cleanly as the target model's does.
I think the easy hammer pull could be fixed by just tightening the main spring screw a tad, but I wouldn't be comfortable messing with the trigger and the cylinder pin. I'm not all that mechanically inclined and beyond basic cleaning/disassembly I've really no 'smithing experience at all. Would rather not pay for a tune-up.
Aside from these small problems, it's really nice. But these issues just make me feel a bit less enthused about it. Should I have them replace it and hope I get one in better shape, or would you just keep it and not let the minor flaws bother you?
Thanks in advance!