a related 870 question
You just discovered the downside of accessorizing shotguns.
Everything you put on it adds weight and bulk.
Weight and bulk make the gun slower to swing, and this slows you down.
What makes the shotgun such an effective weapon is the speed at which you can get a load of shot on target.
What you have to do is a "real world" cost-benefit analysis for each accessory.
Is the reduction in speed counterbalanced by the accessory?
Nicely said, dfarriswheel. Thanks.
Wow, it's my lucky week. Yet another thread on THR that is directly related to an issue that I have. Read on...
So while you can counterbalance the extension and light by adding a Speed feed stock and/or a butt cuff, remember, this is going to make the gun heavier and bulkier, with a marked reduction in speed.
OK, here's my current quandry in deciding which 870P to buy. (Wow, life is tough, ain't it?
)
I realize that there are a billion answers to my question, and each one is right for a different person, but I'm gonna ask it anyway. The question is really at the end, but first...
...some relevant data for me: even though i do lift weights
I'm still a relatively small guy (tall, thin). I don't want a heavy front ended 870. I'd rather have speed & comfort level to get off accurate shots than a heavy gun with extra shots. (I'll take my chances with the fast & few since I'm not expecting any large marauding bands of road warriors to break into my studio ... just yet.)
My local gun shop has an 870P 4461: 18", bead, regular magazine, speedfeed I stock (the one with the extra shell holders). But as I've explained in at least one other thread, I don't want the SF I: shells stored in it reportedly get crimped over time; some report falling out; aesthetically, i don't like the look or feel of the SF I, and would rather add a butt cuff for extra shells).
(Plus, that 4461 has been on that shelf for nearly a month. Seems like no one else wants that stock either, yet at least one salesperson says, "aw, just take it. no difference. you don't have to use it, yada yada yada...")
But, i really want an 870P 4403: 18", bead, regular magazine, speedfeed II (AKA sport or solid stock set).
My gun shop, however, is having trouble so far locating a 4403. (They've got one more call to make on Friday.)
There are, however, 2 4407's available to them: 18", bead, +2 extension, speedfeed II, for about $50 more.
So, unless I get lucky on Friday and they find a 4403, then I've got two choices for now. (I guess I could wait a while for a 4403, but you know what that's like).
1) buy the 4407, remove the +2 extension if I don't like it & replace it with a +1 or just a cap, but why spend the extra $50 when it could be added later, and my cash is a bit tighter right now. (I think I just want to start with a regular magazine. I know, I know, every knowledgable person from Awerback on says, get the extension AND the light, but as a small guy, I want to start light (weight, that is), gain skills, then add stuff.)
Plus, as I've said elsewhere, if front heavy becomes an issue and I've gotta choose between extension & light, my sense right now is, I'd go with a light.
2) I could go with the 4461 the shop has now and just live with the Speedfeed I, or replace it with a solid stock set (but that makes me spend extra $ for a stock I don't want.
So,
here comes my question that could definitely tip my decision: does anyone know if there's a substantial (i.e., noticable) difference in weight between speedfeed I (hollowed out for shell storage) and II (solid)? My gut-level sense (no data) is that a +2 extension would be better balanced by a solid stock.
Given dfarriswheel's reasonable caveat about over doing the extra shells, and my reservations about the speedfeed stock, I think a more reasonable eventual system would be a solid stock, +2 extension with 1 extra shell, with the possibility of adding a buttcuff for those special future times when marauding road warrior populations increase.
That intuitively, again with no data or trial, seems like a better balance.
As always, thanks in advance for opinions to stimulate my thinking.
NemA~