Sig Mosquito, Walther P22, or Beretta tomcat for son's 1st pistol

Status
Not open for further replies.

finz50

Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Messages
99
I'm looking for a gun that my 7 year old son can shoot at the range with me. He wants to go to the range and shoot with me and I'd like to encourage it if he wants to.

First off, he's VERY responsible when it comes to firearms. He's been shooting his BB gun since he was 4. He has to tell me the firearm safety rules verbatim before he can even touch any of my guns (or his BB gun) and helps me clear them to ensure they are not loaded, etc. He's always asking questions about how it works and how bullets work, etc. I try to answer them the best I can to a 7 year old (my 4 year old daughter know the Eddie Eagle rules cold too-LOL)... He only touches firearms while being supervised by me and I've only had to correct him twice in the last year. I think he's getting tired of his BB gun and is ready for something else, and I figure a .22 would be the logical choice. I asked him if he'd want a pistol or rifle and he said he'd rather have a pistol so he can go to the range with me.

I think I have it narrowed down to a Beretta Tomcat, Walther P22, and Sig Mosquito. (My dad has a Ruger Mark III, but the grip is too big for his hands). We went to the range with some guys from work and my buddy let my son shoot his Sig Mosquito. He actually handled it a lot better than I expected (~5 inch group from 7 yards for a first timer). He had to pull back the hammer to shoot it, but everything worked out good. Looked at the Walther P22 at Bass Pro the other night and he was able to rack it and lock back the slide by himself, and said "it was easy-LOL". It seemed to fit his hand good too with the smaller grip. I figured the Tomkat would be another option due to the tip-up chamber and the fact that he wouldn't have to rack it.

Anyone have kids that shoot any of these pistols? What inputs do you have? I know some people think he's too young to shoot a pistol, but I wouldn't buy one for him to shoot at the range if I didn't think he was ready. I'd appreciate any inputs!
__________________
 
Do not buy a Sig Mosquito. The most unreliable, malfunctioning, jamming, pistol I ever owned. I sold it as quickly as I bought it. You will hear this repeatedly from other owners. Ruger, Browning, Walthers, Sig Trailside or keep it simple and get a 22LR revolver.
 
I've owned all three and have been greatly disappointed with each and every one of them. Check out the Rimfire Central forum for details; the stories are never-ending. Try a Ruger Mark II or Mark III. Better yet, get him a Ruger Bearcat. It's a beautifully made single-action revolver that is about perfect for small-hands training and responsible firearms use.
 
i got my daughter (10 yrs old today) a walther p22 and yankee hill mite suppressor for her birthday.

she got them two days ago and already has almost 1000 rnds through them (almost two whole federal bulk packs from walmart)

it hasn't malfunctioned a SINGLE time (literally... i keep records of every round, every cleaning, every malfunction in all my center-fire rifles/pistols). of course, it was dripping with lube the whole time :)

i've been extremely impressed and the YHM can is outstanding.
 
to address your other question... i'm not saying 7 yrs is too young for a gun, but i think it is too young for a pistol. start him on a rifle. it will be MUCH safer for you and more enjoyable for him as hitting targets with a rifle is easy and fun. missing targets with a pistol is no fun. it's frustrating and makes for disinterest that could last into adulthood.
 
My daughter got her P22 when she was 10 and turns 13 in 3 weeks. She loves her and although it is ammo specific, it runs very good with it. Would not hesitate to buy another one.
 
Try a Ruger MkII instead of a III. I believe the grip will prove to be a better fit. I also agree that a .22 rifle would probably be a better starting weapon but I am not the decision maker.
 
I was at the range a couple days ago. A guy had brought his boys shooting various stuff...P22, small 22 bolt action, even his AK. They all had great discipline, never once did I witness sweeping or anything unsafe.

The P22 looked to be the best fit. Didn't seem to malfunction that much, maybe he was using MiniMags or something.

The Sig will probably be too big, as will the weight of the Ruger. I understand the NEW P22's have some bugs worked out and are fairly reliable.
 
Right now he's leaning towards wanting a semi-auto since it's "like dad's" (Glock 30). Sounds like he wants the P22 since "it's way easy to rack......waaayy easy".
 
finz50

I have been the exact same route with my son. We started with a Daisy air rifle, and when he started getting bored with that, we moved on to a .22 rifle. I let him try all the different brands, for the best fit and function for his size and age. He finally settled on a Remington 597, picking it over a Taurus pump action, because he told me he eventually wanted to have a scope on it. I think this was the right way to go as he learned about marksmanship, sight picture, and trigger control. He has become an excellent shot with that rifle, and so a few years later, we went shopping for a handgun for him. Again, I let him try them all on for size, and this time he chose the Walther P22. Fit his small sized hand very well, and the slide and all the controls were easy enough for him to operate. The two drawbacks with the P22 were its ammo sensitivity (runs best with CCI MiniMags), and the need to keep it clean after a couple of hundred rounds. The trigger isn't exactly the best, but for plinking it does just fine. The most recent gun I bought for him was a Taurus PT92. Naturally he was getting bored with .22s and wanted something with a little more power to it. I chose the Taurus because it offered him the choice of SA or DA, inexpensive magazines and accessories, and cheap 9mm. ammo. The gun has been great and he still has fun with all three whenever we go shooting together. To me it's been a great experience passing along this tradition to my son, and giving him the means to enjoy shooting safely and confidently for many years to come.
 
Last edited:
As a former Sig Mosquito owner I'd recommend you avoid this one--its not a "real" Sig.

A semi-auto wouldn't be my first choice for a young shooter. The single action Ruger Bearcat would be an especially good choice--good proportions for smaller hands, slower to unload and load encourages a deliberate and disciplined approach to shooting.
 
How about a S&W model 422 or 622 pistol?
They can be found in most gun shows for about $200.
They have decent trigger and light recoil spring so it is easy to rack the slide.
I have few and my wife and kids love them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top