• You are using the old Black Responsive theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Simple question on Desert Eagle.

Status
Not open for further replies.

el Godfather

Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2012
Messages
1,847
Dear THR:

I have a simple question: why Desert Eagle was made?

What was the logic behind it? What did Israel Military Industries had in mind while making this huge contraption?

Was it a novelty coffee table gun to begin with?

Thank you
 
Not sure, other than the unique gas return principle. Plus being a military contractor, I'm sure they counted on sales that never came..
 
IMHO it was built more as a curiosity than anything else but they are indeed a hoot to shoot. I've only had a chance to shoot the 44 mag version but it was a lot of fun. That said, I think the only real world application for these would be hunting, the 44 and 50 versions would take down most deer. Wouldn't be legal here in PA though.
 
Magnum Research designed it for American sport shooters, IMI was contracted to build it for them.
 
Dear THR:

I have a simple question: why Desert Eagle was made?

What was the logic behind it? What did Israel Military Industries had in mind while making this huge contraption?

Was it a novelty coffee table gun to begin with?

Thank you
Not sure......because AutoMag was no longer being made?
 
As I understand it production began prior to 1994 (AWB). I know a guy who has three and the last one he bought, he bought in 2001. He has them in .357, .44, and .50 AE. He bought the .357 magnum first back in the later 90s to go along with his .357 magnum revolvers, and then got the .44 magnum for the same reason, and then just got the .50 AE because he could.

As he explained it, it was still the age of magnums. Everyone still loved magnums and the ammo was relatively still inexpensive. And most folks still believed that magnums would go through body armor, not as a primary reason for buying them, but as a nice aside to buying them. They were unique and not a lot of people owned them, so it was also kind of a status symbol to own one. Also he enjoys big loud guns and finally went to ordering custom guns built on his Ruger Redhawks.

Desert Eagles are a gimmick, granted their fun as heck and I wouldn't turn one down if you gave it to me for free but when I can buy a Redhawk way cheaper and not have to be picky about factory ammo or worry about cast rounds for my reloads, the Redhawk wins my selection. I've tinkered with the idea of getting one but I just can't find the desire to make that ultimate plunge for one. Not when I feel like a S&W 625 would be a better purchase for the price point and ability to regularly shoot it far more easily. Plus I already own a SRH in .454, that round is more bad ass than .50 AE, and enough bad ass not bother with .460 Magnum.

f you could get the price down closer to $800 and the mags down to $30 you'd have something there. But for now they are way overpriced with far better selections on the market. Mayhaps not for mangum semi-autos, for but for guns by far.

Oh and I can buy a Springfield Range Officer for less than $900, get a conversion kit for $300 or so and still not have paid as much for a DE, and the mags are way cheaper. The ammo, eh, it's a reloader's round, but it will run reloads from what I have seen without too much trouble.
 
Oh and I can buy a Springfield Range Officer for less than $900, get a conversion kit for $300 or so and still not have paid as much for a DE, and the mags are way cheaper.

Yet you still couldn't shoot

50AE, 44mag, 41mag, 357mag & 440CB
 
No logic. The DE is simply a fun technical exercise but totally pointless from a practical standpoint.


Even bulkier and heavier (not to mention expensive) than revolvers of comparable power and the wheelguns have the upper hand in practicality (use of ammo at different power levels) and reliability without losing that much in terms of capacity.

Finally, the S&W X-Frame buried them for good in the "I want to have the baddest handgun" department.
 
The DE was intended for silhouette, bowling pins and hunting. It may be heavier than revolvers, but it is also has much less felt recoil. At 4 pounds, the DE is still much lighter to carry than an 8 pound rifle.
 
I love my DE and when it's out of amo it doubles as a blodgend ! fancy smooth rifling 6 point lock up bolt interchangeable barrels, looks cool, never misfired low recoil parkerised finish ,put in mud fire ,put in mud fire......I.E. I love my DE it's just sooo.. hungry!
CC
 
If we could legally use them for deer hunting in Illinois,(as of now, we cannot.), I would own a 10" .44 magnum Deagle
 
Last edited:
I think they exist because they can. Personally, not my cup of joe, but hey, I don't need to like it. Other people need to like it enough to buy it. I'm just glad I live in a country where the same courtesy is afforded to me for my favorite guns. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top