Teenage criminal sues and gets £567,000.

Status
Not open for further replies.

jsalcedo

Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2002
Messages
3,683
A teenage criminal who received £567,000 in compensation after falling through a roof while trespassing boasted about his wealth yesterday, saying that he was looking forward to buying "a few houses and a flash car".



Carl Murphy, 18, got the payout last week, nine years after being injured in a 40ft fall at a warehouse in Bootle docks, near Liverpool, prompting angry protests from crime victims and politicians.

In his first public interview since receiving the award, Murphy - who has convictions for robbery, burglary and assault - said that he did not care about the response.

"I deserve this money and I don't care what anybody says about me," he said. "I'm going to buy a big house so I have a place to live with me mum when she gets out of jail. I might buy a few houses - I'll buy whatever I want." He added: "The papers just call me a yob and a thug because I've been done for robbery and assault but those were just silly stupid little things, like.

"I want to spend my money the way I want without people interfering and I want to have a prosperous future.

"I want to take my mates to Liverpool games and get a flash car. This money is mine now and I'll do what I want. I don't care about anyone or what they have to say about it."

Murphy received his compensation after suing the company that owned the warehouse. He claimed that if the perimeter fence had not been in disrepair he would not have been able to gain entry and suffer his injuries.

He is now partially blinded in his left eye and has 17 metal plates in his skull as a result of the fall. He also claims that the incident has caused him to suffer from behavioural problems. It annoys me that people think I don't deserve this money after all I've been through," he said. "I'm going to spend my money on whatever I want and everyone who called me 'Tin Head' can go get stuffed."

Residents of Bootle, where Murphy lives, said that they were too scared to speak publicly about the case but privately described him as the area "king yob".

One said: "He shaves his head so we can all see the scars. He likes to walk around and play the big man.

"I've seen him yelling abuse at the shopkeepers, telling them how he is going to buy the shop with his compensation money and throw them out.

"He is a villain around here. Everybody knows him but no one wants to confront him. He has a big family and they all stand up for each other."

In November last year, Murphy's mother Diane and her partner Kevin Parsons, both 36, were jailed for three years for dealing in crack cocaine and heroin from their council house in Bellini Close.

A police spokesman said: "Diane Murphy was using the home to distribute Class A drugs which was bringing a large criminal element into the suburb.

"Residents in the area are intimidated. Crime is happening on their doorstep. People like Diane Murphy and others who sell drugs disrupt the decent people who live there."

Police describe the area around Bellini Close as a "hotbed for anti-social behaviour, street-level crime and the distribution of Class A drugs". Several buildings are boarded up and vandalised - and gangs of teenagers wearing shell suits and trainers walk up and down the street shouting and drinking alcohol in the early daytime. Police make regular rounds.

Since Murphy's mother was jailed, he has lived with his grandmother, Barbara Murphy, who keeps a rottweiler in her home on nearby Church Grove.

She said: "He never finished school because the teachers couldn't control him. He was a nice boy before the accident but ever since the injuries he has been difficult to control. He needs this money. That is him for life now. What is he going to do without it?"

She said that Murphy does not work or attend school. Neighbours say that they see him drinking in the park with friends on most evenings or hanging around a local cafe.

The payout has been condemned by charities, which point out that victims of crime receive far less under the Government's criminal injuries compensation scheme.

The parents of James Bulger received just £7,500 following his murder, and the family of Damilola Taylor received £10,000 following his murder.

Clive Elliott, the director of the Victims of Crime Trust, said: "All rights to compensation should cease the moment a person breaks the law, in this case trespassing.

"Wrongdoers think they are beyond the law - and in this case they have shown they can become quite well off by breaking it."
 
Clive Elliott, the director of the Victims of Crime Trust, said: "All rights to compensation should cease the moment a person breaks the law, in this case trespassing.
My thinking exactly. What a total joke (of the unfunny kind) this sorta case appears to be - a farce - a smack in the eye for real crime victims.

Other thoughts and comments that tempt me are far from THR-safe!
 
He will be broke in a couple of years.

A couple of years? I say a couple of months ... £567,000 is only $1,088,895.02 (based on today's exchange rate) ... you're average idiot could burn through that kind of money in a matter of days.

This guy's going to have more "friends" then he knows what to do with and all of them will have a grubby hand out. You know he'll spend it pretty foolishly ... he'll get laid, drunk/stoned and throw parties so he can be "the big man" and the lowlife's he's surrounded by will burn through that pile of cash so fast it'll make his head spin.

Also considering the type of people he hangs out with, he's got a real high probability of being dead before he's broke.


This case is clearly a travesty of justice, but its nice to know he'll burn himself pretty good before all is said and done.
:evil:
 
I'm making a note to try and keep tabs on this pathetic POS. I hope to report back in about six months with a very entertaining account of his decent in flames. He "deserves" no less.
 
you're average idiot could burn through that kind of money in a matter of days.
So what? He'll just find another roof to fall through, and get another payday.
 
After reading stories like this and many others, I’m so glad we won the Revolutionary war. What is worng with people over there?
The same thing wrong over here. Plenty of judgements just as if not more absurd take place here too.
 
Lol the only way he'll keep his money is if he buys a brewery! He was into selling drugs, maybe he can transition:)

I have to say it's not great when business gets burned by stuff like this, but it's worse when it happens to ordinary people, and families. There was a guy nearby who got drunk one newyears and jumped off his hotel room balcony into the hottub. Yea, he's paraplegic but he sued the hotel and won. Apparantly it's the law! I wouldn't have had any idea.

I guess the thing is that ignorance of the law isn't an excuse, especially when you are constructing and managing a multi-million dollar building.
 
HighVelocity, it said drugs

A couple of years? I say a couple of months ... £567,000 is only $1,088,895.02 (based on today's exchange rate) ... you're average idiot could burn through that kind of money in a matter of days.

I knew a kid back in high school that got a half-million for getting hit and screwed up by a car. He was out of money in less than a year. At last check, he had $125,000 into a TrailBlazer :rolleyes:

I believe someone told me he is now at McDonalds.
 
It would be a lot more reassuring to think of him burning through a million bucks and ending up penniless if it were HIS million bucks rather than a million stolen from an innocent party.
 
It would be a lot more reassuring to think of him burning through a million bucks and ending up penniless if it were HIS million bucks rather than a million stolen from an innocent party.

We have to make do with what we have. :(
 
Forget broke-he'll be out one night, flashing his ill-gotten booty, and one of his fellow "yobs" will kill him for it.


Yob. I LIKE that word! :D
 
The message to all other criminal ner-do-well types is that Crime DOES Pay if you have the right lawyer.
 
Isn't it about time for Agricola to check in and say something along the lines of how we Yankee rednecks are completely misinterpreting things, and that if we knew all the facts instead of just the few from the news report we'd realize the settlement is actually a wonderful example of the ultimate fairness of the British system of justice? :rolleyes:
 
As many have said, this youth wont have the money for long - it will either go into his arm / up his nose, or some much bigger fish will have it off him. Either way, thanks to this and who his parents are, the child is probably a write-off for the rest of his life.

FWIW though, this Court case happened four years ago (and the accident happened when he was nine), he only gets the money now because he is turning 18.

There has been another case recently described:

http://news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=4253363
 
HankB,

i) well timed, Sir;

ii) these decisions happen all the time, in both our countries. I for one was amazed when people managed to sue McDonalds for making them fat, but at the end of the day when you have Court systems like ours, where lawyers are financially benefitting from cases that should be laughed out of the courtroom, you will get these decisions.
 
"Now I agree that this guy is lower than scum but since when is an insurance company "an innocent party"?"

Never forget that insurance companies are just money holders, great pools of common funds that were drawn from everyone with an account. A million dollars ends up being $5 from 200,000 people, *AND* if it's something that reoccurs, those 200,000 people end up having their premiums raised another $5 to cover when it happens again.
 
"I deserve this money and I don't care what anybody says about me," he said. "I'm going to buy a big house so I have a place to live with me mum when she gets out of jail.

This is the funniest line in the whole story. Writers for the Simpsons could not do any better.


-James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top