The NEF and H&R Single Shots....

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dave McCracken

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
13,936
Location
MD.
The latter part of the 19th Century saw tremendous strides in firearms development. Breechloading arms met many needs and were developed to many price points from bare bones utility guns to fine art that shot.

For every high grade Parker, Fox and LC Smith made, a wagon load of economical single shots went out to wherever a good, reliable shotgun was needed.

While only one shot seems picayune to us of many repeaters, often one shot was enough to protect the chicken house, protect life or get dinner.

Some of these has names like Long Tom, White Powder Wonder, Long Range, etc. Sold for as little as a couple dollars new,often in conjunction with shells sold singly, they did a yeoman job for many of our ancestors.

Most have fallen by the wayside in the 150 years since the end of The Uncivil War. However, Harrington & Richardson, which had started making cheap revolvers, turned a break action single shot shotgun into their bread and butter gun for decades.

It was and is made in all gauges,and in 410,9mm rimfire,and other odd chamberings. The design was hell for stout, and it took real abuse or years of neglect to make one not work.

And somewhere along the line, the little H&R single became a multiple barreled shoulder arm. Rifle barrels made to fit the soft iron action turned out to batter the action excessively, so a stronger rifle action was developed with harder steel. Barrels have been offered from 22LR to 45-70 and the rifle action can be fitted with shotgun barrels to this day. The opposite may not be true.

These turn up in odd places. A friend saw and handled one in Kuwait recently.Others turned up in the news when Mexican rebels in Chiapas got organized in the 1990s.TV news featured peasants toting rusty H&Rs and opposing the government forces.

These also turn up in a lot of our personal memories. The first shotgun I used was a 16 gauge H&R given to my Father by his Grandfather around 1928. It fed the family during the Depression and functioned well until a relative neglected it in the 70s.

There was also a Huntsman muzzle loader, the first in line ML made in the US. It worked well but got traded off when I decided I liked side hammer MLs better.

An H&R rifle in 30-30 was a groundhog assassin with a 4X Leopold on top and served for deer.

And now Son has a 12 gauge NEF he learned to shoot with. It's now at a friend's for his kids to learn on.

BTW, New England Firearms took over the H&R line a couple decades back. They reworked the action from a top lever to a stronger and less expensive push button and have expanded the line of available gauges and calibers.

For a utility grade shotgun, the little single has a lot going for it besides price. Durable as a crowbar, it's rarely we hear of any that need a smith's attention.

The simple MOA means that it's a good trainer and the transfer bar action means it's reasonably drop safe. Its popularity has lots of aftermarket parts bobbing up from plastic stocks to scope mounts to heat shields.

NOTE: Anyone that can run a single fast enough to need a heat shield, please contact me....

As for downsides.,...

Triggers oft are heavier than the weapon itself. Son's NEF is 5 lbs, 9 oz and the trigger's 6 lbs. Working on these is not easy, the maker puts in the action pins with a very large hydraulic press.

Since these run quite light, kick with anything bigger than 28 gauge is hard. While Son's is chambered for 3" magnums, it's doubtful it will ever see any. Light loads for light guns.

And the 16 gauge that started all this for me killed in front and crippled in back. My very first gun related purchase was a slip on pad. The old 1 1/8 oz Western goose loads gave me nosebleeds sometimes.

The solo round is not as much of a drawback as one may think. In large part it encourages care in shooting. Also, many of us know how to shoot, hit the lever or button, let the barrel weight open the action and eject the shell while one slips another in. Practice early in life lasts a long time.

These are unbeatable when it comes to days where we carry much and shoot little.

They are perfect for Fall days when slipping through some hardwoods eyeing the canopy is our activity of choice.

They are good for loaning out, good for borrowing and good for those times when the small children in all of us get out to play.

And, they are the minimal shotgun. Nothing can be take away and still have a shotgun.

That's part of the charm....
 
H&R/NEF are great guns.

My first shotgun was a H&R 20 ga.

I currently have than one plus a H&R .223 and a NEF 20 ga slug gun. All shoot great and see much use. Quite possibly the best buys in firearms on the market.
 
You're welcome, Steve. The BB gets frequent queries about these and having something easy to find on them makes sense.

John, agreed. A lot of gun for the money...
 
Funny, really... while packing to move, I realized I only had one single-shot shotgun; a 16ga Stevens. I went out and picked up two NEFs and an old H&R, and will probably return today for the other I saw there.

$100, new, is too inexpensive to pass up for a good shotgun. To think, I'd never have bought any of them if it weren't for people on here saying how useful they are.

It's fortunate that people around here don't know about the amazing utility that can be squeezed from them - used, you can usually buy them for $75. This basically gets you what looks and functions like a new gun. :D
 
Let's be pessimistic,PTK, and say that the average NEF/H&R single shot shotgun gets too loose to safely shoot in 20K rounds.

I've no idea what the working life is, that's just a WEG.

Bought for $100, that puts per shot cost at a fraction of a cent.

Of course, some models run higher. The Ultra Slug Hunter is a whizbang for stand hunting in shotgun areas, and may set you back all of $200 plus scope.

Still one can field several singles for the cost of a decent US made repeater and set them up for different missions.

A turkey gun comes to mind. So do slug guns, truck guns, backpack guns, woods runners, snake guns, trap line guns, and even a trap gun, properly stocked and choked.

And more than a few are stored underground in PVC pipes JIC.
 
I picked up two more today. Two more on order, too. Dedicated 28ga, 410 ga, a few 12s, a rifled 12, and a 16 now.

What would I do without THR? :D
 
Ah the memories. An H&R .410 sits in one of my safes now. Hasn't been shot in a few years (blasphemy I know). That little shotgun given to a very excited 10 year old RR in 1984 by a doting grandfather has accounted for countless squirrels and rabbits for the family dinner table over the years.

I just might have to take that beauty out and shoot it soon :).
 
Phantom warrior and I share one of these H&R shotguns. Its a 12ga and the guy that sold it to me said that you could shoot slugs in it.

What he didn't tell me is that if you did the gun would try to squish your face.
 
Not all excess is wretched, PTK.

RR, yes you should. Just in memory if nothing else.

WA, if you has asked me I could have told ya.
 
I couldn’t agree more with this. I love evil black guns. From full auto MAC10s, to suppressed AR, to a real 40mm M203. But somehow I have a soft spot for these single break shotguns and rifles. I just recently picked up a .223 ultra hunter which I’m getting the barrel threaded for a suppressor, as well as an additional .357 mag barrel I’m having 3 lugged. I’ll post pictures when I’ve got them complete.

An H&R 20 gauge 18 inch barrel with a duct taped on fore end stock is what stays near my bedside at night along with a handful of shells. I sleep well! I would take a good used single shot 12 or 20ga for $60 over any handgun out there.

Dave: How do we know if we have one of the newer models of single shots that have the “reworked action” you described above? I have an old H&R 20ga which is at least 30 years old, as what I believe to be newer NEF 12 gauge.

Thanks, Dan
 
Go to the H & R site, www.hr1871.com and read the FAQ. The barrel accessory program (under customer support) is for the newer guns and they list what the appropriate prefixes are, along with all the other good info. I recently got my .410 back with 4 new barrels from 28 to 12 plus a Huntsman setup. I'm dying for some extra time to get out and pattern some of them.


gp911
 
Dave,

When I was working at one of Uncle Sam's schools for wayward boys years ago, my guys who were 'working down south' used to bring along pictures to go with their war stories. One set of pictures was of a string of porters, each carrying either a roped-up bundle of single shot shotguns or a case or two of buckshot. They were headed into the interior of Peru to arm Indian villages which were threatened by that uniquely Peruvian guerrilla group, Sendero Luminoso.

SL was a nasty bunch, and I saw ample photographic evidence. One picture that haunts the recesses of my mind was of a little Indio boy and his puppy, both bayonetted to death on the dirt floor of their hootch, with the blood smears of their death throes spread around them. Bayonet wounds on both displayed the distinctive cruciform of Chinese spike bayonets.

It was that sort of thing that was responsible for the caravan of porters my amigos were photographing. The idea behind it was the 'butter knife' or 'Mother Carbine' theory in operation- start with a single shot shotgun, use it to dispense with a SL guerrilero who had an AK or SKS, recover the G's weapon, and pass your single shot shotgun along to someone who was unarmed. Then rinse and repeat. It worked then and there, it can work here and now too if needed.

lpl/nc
 
The other cool family nostalgia thing about my little .410 is that as my grandfather got up in years, and the last few years he hunted before unfortunately having to give it up due to age and infirmity, he started using that .410 instead of one of his two 12 ga's. It just carried easier for him and was easier on his 70-something shoulders in recoil. I actually watched him roll a rabbit at near 70 yds. with that .410 across a Tennessee pasture a few years before he gave up hunting. No BS, it throws a tight pattern and he knew how to shoot!

I lost him to cancer in 2002, but what I know about guns and hunting I can attribute to his early influence and teaching. I've moved beyond what he tought me as he never really cared much for big game, but he got me going in the right direction and taught me RIGHT from an early age.

I think I will shoot that .410 soon :). I've also got his old Remington 31 in the safe too. That one I try to shoot a few rounds out of dove hunting every year. I can't shoot too many out of it though because it kills on both ends :). Light weight and back then what was a recoil pad?
 
Dave, great post but one correction if I may:

H&R redesigned the action before they went bankrupt and was then later resurrected as NEF and H&R-1871. I have two H&R Toppers made before they went bankrupt. Both have the pushbutton to open the action.

One is a 12 gauge made in the early 80s, when they were experiencing QC issues. The lug on the barrel into which the forearm screw goes sheared off under recoil one day. The forearm is now held on with duct tape. My father had one of these that the same thing happened to.

The second one is a Model 158 with two barrels, .22 Hornet and 20 gauge. I bought this one used a couple years ago.
 
DT, I think you have your answer.

GP. awaiting range report.

Lee, those Shining Path %^&*(s were bloody psychos. And a village full of peasants armed with SS shotguns and motivated by needing to protect their families has to be a force worth considering. I know in WWII the Phillipinos used a number of SS shotguns as well as the Palintid.

RR, thanks. We all have mentors and it's good to remember them.

Dave M,thanks, but I've heard it both ways. I do find the new action quite workable, but the lever style gave an indicator of wear.

The Huntsman and the old 16 were lever guns, the 30-30 and Son's 12 button guns.
 
Last edited:
I've always recommended the 20ga, 28ga, and .410 in these SSs

Rule of 96: Weight of Gun to Payload being the reason.

Now I had a old lever opening Savage Stevens in 12 bore.
The 30" full choke barrel was dented by an anvil near the muzzle.
Shortened to 20" with a bead reinstalled and I used it for assisting new shooters, and a "lessons" gun.

Sounds stupid, still I/we could use this gun to show folks how to operate lever opening shotguns, the difference in these and release levers like H&R Toppers/ NEFs, gun fit, correct basics and all that.

Primer only shells to add a little more to the lessons, adding noise.
Really super light target loads, often using popcorn kernels instead of lead pellets.

Everyone knew that gun would kick, and hurt, if heavy loads, or slugs were used.
They also knew they would have to contend with Me, and mine if they put a heavy shell in it, and especially if such a shell was stuck in there to get a laugh from anyone shooting it, especially a lady.

Consequences are severe if you do this with Me and My kind.

Sure I and some others shot slugs, buckshot and all, we were more seasoned and experienced. We also needed some Pattern Board Targets to use in assisting folks.

hehehe
You should see what a 1 1/4 oz load of #12 shot does at 15 steps to a sheet of Butcher Paper with a 30" circle.
"Stepping out the back door" distance and that circle was full of pellets. *grin*

Just how I and some others do things, lots of fun, educational and folks appreciate learning Pattern Boards.

That gun is in the possession of a family member I fired.
He was not "fired" at the time, and I thought he might get a kick out of using it to do repetitions each night to instill correct mounting to face.
*dumb me*.

Still in low light or no light, with a 00 buck load, or even a heavy load of #6, some interesting "flashes" coming from the muzzle end. *grin*

-

.410 is NOT a good choice for a kids first shotgun. Ineffective patterns.
Still, sometimes that is all a kid can do, or inherits.
Parent/ Mentor the young man or young lady and show them on a pattern board.

Kids do not want to be looked down on, and treated like kids.
Kids are not dumb, or stupid.

Do not just stick a "kids" gun in their hands and "lets go rabbit hunting (whatever).
They will see bigger kids, adults using 28, 20, and 12 ga, SXS, O/U, Pumps and Semis and feel small, in the way, and Frumpy.

Do not do this. Kids are our future, and WE are supposed to Pass Forward, and Preserve Freedoms.

-If a kid has been shown the pattern board, learns this .410, and understands, then the kids :
"I understand, I am just not big enough yet. So I know my pattern is not as good as bigger guns. I'll just have to shoot closer, and practice better Woodscraft skills, which is what I should be doing no matter the gun anyway"

-We adults, teenagers, whomever, will only use a single shot .410 too.
Kids see us and understand all about this, as we Parented/ Mentored the kids.

Rabbit hunting , especially in snow, with everyone using a single shot .410, has been a real great time!
We razz, tease, carry on and some great fun memories made.
Kids get bigger and still talk of these, Adults too.

"We look like those Civil War folks in that movie lined up, and there is only one wabbit that is supposed to come out of that stuff"

Kid was correct. Snow over a hedgerow, beagles in that snowbank just a carrying on, 12 folks, kids, teenagers , moms, dads, grandparents, all with a .410 single shot waiting for one wabbit to pop out.
We really must have looked stupid...
Wabbit pops out, near a Mom, kid, and teenager.
No shot for the rest of us.
"Get 'em!" kid hollers out.
Teenage sister misses, mom misses, kid misses.

"I'm just a kid learning mom, gimme a break. Sis was closer, what is her excuse?"
You just stand there, snow coming down and crack up.
Then the Beagles look at you with a "Listen, we did our thing, what is wrong with you folks?".

"Would someone puh-leeze hit a wabbit! Grandpa gave me a new knife and we need a wabbit so he can show me how to use it on a Wabbit".

Talk about pressure...*grin*

Hot chocolate, inside a shed, Grandpa with a grandkid and that Case knife getting used on a wabbit.
One cannot put a dollar value on that.

:)
 
28 gauge

28 gauge is more efficient than it is supposed to be.
Short shot strings are one big reason; more pellets arrive at the same.
This is why the 28 ga hits harder that it is supposed to.

Less Felt Recoil, and quite proven in taking all sorts of game, from Quail, Doves, other Upland Game, Small game such as Rabbit and Squirrels.

Highest Scores on a Skeet Tote Board, are with the 28 gauge.

Guns are easy to tote, especially when totin' more than shooting.
Even shooting a lot, and less totin', these are easier on a person, as they do not fatigue the person, in carrying, holding, and for sure shooting.

Expense of shells always comes up.
While it may be true Skeet Shooters are most known for using 28 ga, and reloading them as they do go through so many - Short Range Trap, 5 Stand, Sporting Clay shooters are not the only other folks reloading these either.

Lots and Lots of folks, discovered too many years ago , how this 28 gauge is a great gauge to have a Reloader For.
Just a MEC single stage is fine.

Quality time with family. From kids, wives, husbands grandparents, aunts, uncles, boyfriend, girlfriend, and Passing Forward.

Making Hulls - Making Shells- Making Hulls- Passing Forward, Making Memories -Repeat.

Single Shot 28 ga guns are great for first guns.
One can get slugs for these, and yes they work just great!
Ballistic Products is just one company that has components available.

Still, what do most folks on the property really contend with?
Stepping down the way to shoot some doves, rabbits, squirrels...
Big Water Moccasin down at the farm pond, where kids and all are/ will be fishing, handled just fine.

That Tri-Step thrower out back, some clays, and Grandparents having a quality time with grandkids.
Boyfriend, Girlfriend shooting these clays from a Thrower , and Cupid shooting arrows, and the folks up on the porch, or looking down the way...with that dumb goopy look they get.

There is that inviting "that boy" acting as you did at that age, interested in your daughter, coming back to the reloading room to instill some "understanding" about girls, and how they differ from "daughters" and all.

One could mention how that daughter learned to shoot a shotgun with a single shot 28 gauge, and she is as good as her momma, and daddy.
<slap his hand if he gets too close to the nice repeating 28 gauge guns, he ain't earned this yet>

"Honey, how sweet, we are going to shoot out back of the house, what a neat date" - daughter says.

That boy looks over his shoulder at daddy , momma on the porch, and mumbles something about "Short shot strings hit harder so I heard, just thought I'd listen to the fella that shared that with me".
;)
 
Dave,
Thank you so much for posting that. It totally made my day. I love my H&R M48 Topper that I bought in the spring for all of $70.
It has a mirror bore, and I refinished the wood. It's beautiful. I've included a pic from the middle of the refinishing process.
I love the way this thing handles, and even though I did not NEED it, it was just.... so lovely and beautiful in its simplicity. Sometimes I keep it propped against the door of my study because i feel like it almost belongs against a door for protection (even though I have many more "tactical" guns that would arguably serve the purpose better).

I'm really glad that you posted this. Thanks again.
 

Attachments

  • n9800647_30900936_9147.jpg
    n9800647_30900936_9147.jpg
    53.4 KB · Views: 185
20 gauge.

This Single Shot is just that good!

Shells are available at bait shops, gas stations and most everyone has a box of some kind of 20 gauge loadings, even if they do not own a 20 gauge.

Mine is a Youth Model, and kept handy. Factory recoil pad, fixed modified choke, and tosses some of the best patterns and slug groups.
Home use- slugs preferred load.
Mine has taken Deer, Geese, Ducks, Small game and Doves...15 bird limit here and it only took 12 shells to limit out.
Regulation Skeet, and if I do my part, it will run 25/25 as I have numerous times.

Popcorn loads and "ask" the Pigeons to leave a barn...
Rabid raccoon comes around, fell him.

Take a trip, and these Single Shots like road trips, hotel rooms and all too.

These like walking the property, with a dawg, and it does not care if shot or not, just taking in the sights and smells.

New shooters can learn correct basic fundamentals, and do repetitions each day with these.

Some things just "are" - this is one such "are".
 
This year I've been shooting my big brother's old 1970s vintage 20 gauge Topper 158 he had back in high school. I really do like my 12 gauge 870 express but so far I can hit clay targets pretty much as well with the Topper. The small size limbsaver slip-on pad was a perfect fit after removing the 30-year old factory pad that provided no cushion whatsoever. With standard target loads recoil is not an issue. My girlfriend much prefers it to the 870.

What about the newer Topper deluxe with vent rib and threaded choke tube? Are they as good as the old ones?
 
Ben, you're welcome. Singles make great project guns also.

Steve,IMO a 28 gauge single is close to perfect for a beginner's shotgun, and has lots of utility later on.

John, I've no input on the new fancy ones, but I see little downside.
 
Last edited:
Good write up Dave!!

I had two of the little H&R Topper's, can't remember the model numbers as they were different even though they both were .410. I sold one many years ago and gave the other to a son. He and his wife are bleeding heart, guns are ugly liberals! :barf: Anyway he sold it to his little brother, my youngest. Now this youngster, like me, is carrying if he's got his pants on. I have teased him about the little H&R. His words are," I'll never part with that little gun, Dad; you carried it afield for too many years. It's gonna rest in my vault now." Thanks for the stroll down memory lane. P.T.:)
 
Refreshing topic.My first shotgun was a Model 48 "Topper" in 16Gauge made by Harrington&Richardson.I've ALWAYS hunted mainly with a single barrel even while owning semi's and /or pumps.There's just something about them.
At present I own a single barrel 12,a rifled barreled 20 gauge and a wonderful wonderful 22" barrel NEF in 45/70 which is an absolute delight to shoot.
Here's a website where a lot of handi rifle types hang out.
http://www.go2gbo.com/
Stan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top