The PA ‘One-of-a-Kind’ Flintlock Deer Season Turns 50!

Lefty38-55

Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2023
Messages
321
Location
Northeast
PA ‘One-of-a-Kind’ Flintlock Deer Season Turns 50!
‘The greatest hunting sport there is’


Published: Dec. 19, 2023, 6:59 a.m.

Twenty years ago, Michael Vaka’s grandfather-in-law Glen Barlow showed up at his door with a gift for his grandson-in-law – a box containing a flintlock rifle he’d bought decades before for $50 at a local bar. The Thompson/Center Hawken, which had been stored in Barlow’s attic for many years, started Vaka on a magical journey to what has become his favorite hunting pursuit, and one that’s unique and steeped in history.

“My wife’s grandfather gave it to me and I was so excited that I went to the range and I tried shooting it and I could not get the damn thing to fire; I couldn’t get any ignition,” Vaka recalled. “Here, I was shooting Pyrodex (powder) instead of black powder. I mean you want to talk about being a newbie – I understood muzzleloading, but I didn’t understand black-powder hunting.”

When it comes to black-powder firearms, Pennsylvania and in fact, the Lehigh Valley, has a rich tradition, with the Moravians bringing their gunsmithing and gunstocking skills with them from Europe when they settled Bethlehem in the early 1740s. The state is also known as the home of the Pennsylvania Longrifle, with the first of those longrifles likely made in the Lancaster area sometime early in the 18th century. By the late 1770s, according to information from Jacobsburg Environmental Education Center, which is home to Jacobsburg National Historic District, William Henry II of the Henry Family of gunmakers from Lancaster had opened a small gunmaking shop in Christian Springs near Nazareth. Then, in the 1790s, he purchased land at Jacobsburg and built a gun manufactory, with a larger facility opened in the area in 1812. Today, visitors can learn about the history of the Pennsylvania Longrifle and gun manufacturing in the area by visiting the Jacobsburg Historical Society and its Pennsylvania Longrifle Museum.

Pennsylvania’s Flintlock Season
The Pennsylvania Game Commission (PGC) honors the tradition and history of the flintlock rifle in the state by holding what is believed to be the nation’s only flintlock-only deer-hunting season. While other states have muzzleloading and primitive weapons seasons, those seasons allow black-powder percussion rifles and/or modern inline rifles. Pennsylvania’s flintlock season has been held since 1974, which makes the 2023 event, set for Dec. 26-Jan. 15, the 50th year of the hunt.

According to PGC Director of Communications Travis Lau, the first flintlock hunt was held Dec. 26-28, 1974, on 37 State Game Lands, with 65 deer taken during the 3-day affair. “Eventually it was expanded to include more game lands, then made statewide in 1979,” Lau said. “Today, it remains a much-anticipated opportunity to enjoy the deer woods after Christmas, and it seems like every year some dandy bucks are taken in this season. I believe Pennsylvania is the only state that has a season dedicated to flintlocks, and in Pennsylvania, it’s the only deer season in which hunters can harvest an antlerless deer with their unused buck tag.”

Hunting with a flintlock in the flintlock season is a challenge in many ways, starting with the fact that sportsmen are using a weapon that has the opportunity to misfire, especially if the powder, flint or frizzen get damp or wet. Plus, it’s often cold and windy – weather conditions that certainly aren’t for everyone. Then there’s the fact that the major deer seasons have come and gone, so whitetail numbers are at or near their lowest point of the year.

The game commission estimates 77,000 hunters took part in the flintlock season in 2022-2023, harvesting an estimated 12,000 antlerless deer and only 1,230 antlered deer. Compare that to the overall deer harvest, where an estimated 650,000-plus hunters took 422,960 deer over the course of the entire hunting season, and you can see the odds aren’t necessarily stacked in the flintlock hunter’s favor.

A Passion for Flintlock Hunting
After his initial experience shooting his flintlock, Vaka called upon friend Rick Grgurich for guidance. The pair then spent time at the shooting range, with Grgurich going over the proper powders and setup for Vaka, including finding the right projectile for his particular gun. Fast-forward to today, and Vaka’s love for black-powder hunting burns strong. Every winter, he, his sons Ben and Cameron, and several friends gather to make deer drives on public hunting lands during the flintlock season, hoping to take a deer or two if the opportunity presents itself. Over the past 18 years, the Lowhill Township resident has been fortunate to harvest eight or nine deer, pretty remarkable when one considers the challenges of flintlock hunting.

“Our groups were originally like five or six people and now there are times when we get up to maybe a dozen guys,” Vaka said. “I think it’s the most beautiful time of the year, generally because of the snow and there’s no pressure. We’ll put on little pushes to each other and my sons are usually on the mountain with me, (plus) a lot of our friends. There are times we’ll see groups in excess of 20 or 30 deer because they’re in winter herds.”

When it comes to flintlock hunting, Vaka stresses the importance of practicing regularly to ensure you are familiar with the gun and have it in excellent working condition. “We spend a lot of time at the range, getting the guns to run right, getting good ignition, making sure you’re using the right flint, the right projectiles, the right powders,” he said. “Making sure you’re cleaning them between shots. It takes a lot of love and time.”

Vaka is so adamant about practicing with his flintlock that not only does he hit the range several times a year, he and his friends started a muzzleloading jamboree a few years ago to hone their marksmanship skills. During the daylong event held each June, the group competes in several skills challenges including shooting freehand at a target 50-yards away, taking aim at an egg suspended 10-yards away and shooting from a rest at a steel deer target 100-yards away. The winner of the competition then walks away with the coveted Wolverine Trophy. “We came up with this idea … because we felt like it just wasn’t enough,” Vaka said. “We felt like we needed to continue to challenge ourselves. It was an excuse really to just shoot more. And we love it so much — we spend more time with the guns and with each other.”

When it comes to actually being in the woods, Vaka says the biggest challenge for flintlock hunters is keeping everything dry so the gun fires properly. Unlike other black-powder or modern firearms, the flintlock relies on an ignition system that is completely exposed to the elements. Basically, the gun’s flint, frizzen (the metal plate the flint strikes when the trigger is pulled to create a spark) and black-powder pan sit on the outside of the barrel. That primer powder in the pan then ignites the powder inside the barrel via a touch hole on the side of the barrel.

“I would absolutely say you want to be prepared,” he said. “If there is any type of precipitation whatsoever, you have to have something to cover your frizzen and your lock.” He also notes that cleaning the gun regularly – both inside and out – is essential. That helps keep all of the parts in good working order, prevents rusting and wards off possible damage to the inside of the barrel.

“Every time you shoot it you should give it a really good cleaning,” he said. “And that takes time; it’s a commitment.”

Looking Ahead
While Christmas 2023 will be spent with family and friends, come Dec. 26, Vaka will once again be in the same environment he always finds himself on that day – making deer drives in the woods and hills of eastern Pennsylvania, his trusty flintlock at his side. For Vaka, it’s a tradition he tries to never miss.

“We always say that the day after Christmas is our favorite day of the year because it’s just like a reunion,” he said. “A lot of guys travel in from different areas to hunt in our group. I love all seasons, but if there was one (hunting) tag or one season I could only hunt, it would be flintlock, purely because of the challenge and camaraderie and the tradition. It’s not easy to get started. You kind of have to shift through the gears, but once you really understand it and you have confidence in your gun and your ability, it’s the greatest hunting sport there is.”

Source = ‘The greatest hunting sport there is’: Pa.’s one-of-a-kind flintlock deer season turns 50

PA.jpg
 
I've never gotten bitten by the muzzle loader bug, but if I were to do so something like this is the way I'd go. I have mixed feelings about having special seasons for specific firearms though.
 
They all do, sort of.
Just because Joe Schmuck is out with an inline with scope sight shooting plastic wrapped jacketed bullets with fake powder and shotgun primers is no reason you can't still be authentic.
And I still note the presence of plastic-and-stainless flintlocks in the picture. I had not known such things existed, and had to go look them up:

"The Traditions PA Pellet Ultralight Muzzleloading Rifle is based off the popular PA Pellet Flintlock but with a barrel made of a premium grade Chromoly steel, which is typically found on centerfire rifles. This material makes the barrel extremely strong, lightweight, & accurate The 1:28" twist allows for the firing of saboted bullets & modern muzzleloading projectiles. Additionally, the outside of the barrel has Premium CeraKote Finish which will help protect against rust, corrosion, and weather."

Egads. And I'll bet people scope them too.
 
Last edited:
Missouri had a Muzzleloading/Primitive season but within the last 10 years or so, the name was changed to Alternative Methods when modern handguns were added as allowed for the season.
So now if someone wants to hunt the season with their T/C contender, revolver, or semi-auto pistol, etc. they can, as long as it's centerfire and the magazine is 10rnds or less.
I have to admit that I'm occasionally curious about the Air Rifle provision.
Starts tomorrow (Dec 23-Jan 2) this year.

Deer:Firearms, Alternative Methods, Allowed

Methods

-Muzzleloading or cap-and-ball firearms, .40 caliber or larger and capable of firing only a single projectile at one discharge; in-lines and scopes are allowed.
-Multiple-barreled muzzleloading or cap-and-ball firearms and/or muzzleloading or cap-and-ball handguns, including revolvers, .40 caliber or larger, are allowed and may be carried in addition to a muzzleloading or cap-and-ball rifle.
-Centerfire pistols or revolvers using expanding-type bullets, such as lead or copper
-Air-powered firearms, .40 caliber or larger, charged only from an external high compression power source (external hand pump, air tank, or air compressor)
-Longbows, compound bows, and recurve bows of any draw wright; hand-held string-releasing devices, illuminated sights, scopes, and quickpoint sights are allowed.
-Crossbows
-Atlatls, which are defined as a rod or narrow board-like device used to launch, through a throwing motion of the arm, a dart 5 to 8 feet in length.
 
MeatEater (Netflix, Youtube) had an episode filmed in the PA flintlock season.

If you haven't seen that show, they go on a hunt, then cook what they kill. Well, they had several near misses, but didn't kill any deer so the end of the show was dedicated to slow motion photography showing flintlock ignition close up. Very cool. I never did the flintlock thing, but I love to hunt in the snow. We can bowhunt and firearms doe hunt all through January so that usually scratches my itch.
 
They all do, sort of.
Just because Joe Schmuck is out with an inline with scope sight shooting plastic wrapped jacketed bullets with fake powder and shotgun primers is no reason you can't still be authentic.
Truth, I often hunt (sometimes not lately) with some modern hunter friends, during modern-rifle season, just to go along, look for a nice bear or cougar, but I take my Jeager instead of of a modern gun. Also, when hunting bear or cougar out of muzzle loading seasons, I always take a my Jeager or Bess. (almost always, I did shoot a cougar with a .30-30 not too long ago) One time the game warden got quite a kick out of it, I saw him a couple of times a couple of years/seasons after, he'd get a big smile on his face and say: "hey! It's the Antique shooter"!!
 
I've never gotten bitten by the muzzle loader bug, but if I were to do so something like this is the way I'd go. I have mixed feelings about having special seasons for specific firearms though.
I've had the bug forever. But I agree. Flintlock only would be a bonus for me, but a flintlock is not ideal for someone just to use to take advantage of a season. They demand a lot of attention to detail. And, when you open a new season, it usually takes some days off the regular ones.

On the other hand, I do wish the ML seasons were more specific as to what is, and what is not a traditional firearm. As we know, the rules have been bent quite severely around the requirement: "loads from the muzzle".
 
I have a left handed Lyman Deer Stalker 50 cal, that I used in the Pa Muzzleloaders season, in Clarion and surrounding county areas.
Mostly in Cogley, Pa, (Kossuth Woods).
It was our most anticipated hunting season of all time. I actually got a doe with mine the first year I hunted. We noticed that once the temp got below 20 degrees, the colder it got the better the guns shot. The more reliable the ignition. I suppose the air is dryer the colder it gets.

Old pic but this is it. LYMAN 50 CAL .JPG
She shoots really well.
Primitive iron sights, flintlock only, black powder only, round ball only. The stock has a cheek rest on the other side of the stock.
It was the most fun I ever had hunting, period!

1703296649507.png

That's about all we ever got in a day. If we were lucky one of us would actually get one. We would miss them, and the telltale blue smoke clouds, and a deer walking away, was a dead giveaway that everyone missed the dang thing. Then we would all laugh at each other and then wonder how hard it was to feed your family with one of these, like our forefathers did.
I think every state should have a primitive muzzleloading season like Pa's.

In NC where I live now, we don't have muzzleloader season, half the guns used cartridge or breach loading, inlines, or any other contraption someone came up with that used black powder.
 
The more reliable the ignition. I suppose the air is dryer the colder it gets.
Never thought about that, but that could be true. I know that very cold air can be very dry air. But, a good flintlock, cleaned and loaded properly should be 100% reliable, or at least as reliable as a cartridge rifle. Or, possible more, as one would never get a factory "dud" cartridge out of the box. Can't look at a loaded cartridge and tell if there is priming compound in the cap. But one can flip the frizzen and check the prime, and look right down the touch hole and see if it's blocked or not. My Jeager has never failed to fire.

That old Deer Stalker is not a bad looking rifle.
 
Have you ever tried hunting with a flintlock when it was 35 to 40 degrees out and a lot of snow was melting and it was a misty day? We had miss fires in those conditions. So much moisture hanging in the air close to the ground. Probably something we were doing wrong.

Believe me, we weren't experts in the use of flintlocks. I think that's why it was so much fun.

We did discover that the ceramic lathe bit inserts that were 3/4" square by around 3/8" thick, when used as a flint, would reliably spark well in any condition and they didn't chip up like a flint will.
They cut our miss fires down to only the stupidest mistakes. I swear they will spark under water.

A cousin gave me one for in my flintlock probably 20 years ago and it went through many hunting seasons and still sparks as good today as it did when he gave it to me.

I'll probably never have to change it in my life.

It isn't something you would buy to use as a flint as they are very expensive, (I think $150.0 each) but when they get a small chip on them, they get pitched and a new one gets put the tool.
So my cousin had a very limited supply of these damaged lathe bits.

I would have to empty the safe to get a good pict of it. The Deerstalker is clear in the back. I have to re-upholster some chairs for Misses Tiger (Tight Wad), but I'll try to dig it out and take some pics of it if I get the chairs done in time. We are having Christmas dinner here so the chairs are first priority.
TT
 
Last edited:
And I still note the presence of plastic-and-stainless flintlocks in the picture. I had not known such things existed, and had to go look them up:

"The Traditions PA Pellet Ultralight Muzzleloading Rifle is based off the popular PA Pellet Flintlock but with a barrel made of a premium grade Chromoly steel, which is typically found on centerfire rifles. This material makes the barrel extremely strong, lightweight, & accurate The 1:28" twist allows for the firing of saboted bullets & modern muzzleloading projectiles. Additionally, the outside of the barrel has Premium CeraKote Finish which will help protect against rust, corrosion, and weather."

Egads. And I'll bet people scope them too.
No scopes, Peep sights and fiber optics are allowed. Un-used buck tag becomes any area/any sex tag so you can explore areas where you do not have a doe tag. You get an extra two weeks in the three 'special reg' WMU's around major cities with thousands of doe tags and little patches of public hunting; same areas get a head start for Archery so one can get a whole month more deer hunting if you do both.
 
Back
Top