Top Battle Sidearm

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bobby, calm down. You are taking this personally. We know you think that a Glock is better than every other pistol chosen by anyone else here. Okay. You have made your point. You also observe that others do not agree that yours is better than theirs.

What do you do for a living? I am a forester, and my Witness has been through every bad thing that it can and has worked just fine. I have never fired it in self defense. But I have been shot at, I have had guns pointed at me. When I go into the woods, it is because of my job. I do that for a living and dare to say I have been in worse places than most here, save for those who have been in the artic or in Vietnam. I have been places where the maps fail, swamps in the US where even the USGS did not completely map. So, my Witness obviously passes your test.

The 1911 has been in vastly more situations, more environments, from ice to desert, from jungle swamps to open pastures, than your Glock. That is a fact and you cannot deny that, regardless of how you condemn it. You do not have to like the 1911, but if you cannot see that it remains a viable design, despite its age, then you are certainly not looking at things logically.

Ditto for the Hi Power. Yet your Glock will likely perform just fine. You opened yourself up when you talked about how great it is to the detriment of older designs, and then stepped one notch higher by then blasting those who take care of their pistols. And if cops are to be our gauge, then the .38 Special obviously made a better combat round than the 9mm, as cops carried and depended more on that round than the 9mm.

Relax. We all know what you carry, that you trust it, and that you believe it to be the best. That's okay. Now, it's your turn to realize the same about the SIG, the 1911, the BHP, the CZ-75 etc.

Ash
 
Bobby Lee,

I have no problem with you bashing every handgun or weapon designer other than Glock. Do you really have to drag Sgt. York into the mess? Let the patriotic hero rest, would ya?

BTW-I think Sgt. York would woop both you and me put together even if he was armed with a stupid old 1911.
 
If you would bother to read a few of my posts you would clearly see that I have not bashed or said anything bad about a Sig, Beretta, H&K,CZ,BHP, or any other good quality pistol. I am not a Glock ONLY person.

All I have said about the 1911 is more or less that SOME are not reliable out of the box.

I really don't care what anyone carries.

My whole point here is that unless you have carried your pistol in a harsh enviroment you have no idea how it will work and just because a million 1911's have seen combat for 80 years or longer does not mean YOURS will be reliable in such conditions unless you have tested it first.

Some people tend to pick their carry gun because it "looks" cool or because some actor used one in a movie and they assume it is has to be the best weapon but in reality they have no idea if it will still work if they get out of their indoor range and into the real world.
 
Do you really have to drag Sgt. York into the mess? Let the patriotic hero rest, would ya?

Very few people have as much respect for Mr York as I do.

I go to the Alvin York muzzleloader shoot almost every year. I have met his family and they are fine people.

Alvin is famous not just for his war time adventures but for his skill with a muzzleloader.

That does not mean that I would like to go to war with his .40 caliber long rifle.

If you want a good read about York go here.

http://acacia.pair.com/Acacia.Vignettes/The.Diary.of.Alvin.York.html
 
I'll take a Glock thankyou much,

Simplicity of design, can be stripped for repair in the blink of an eye, has very little metal to keep oiled or attract grit, the polymer frames don't rust or attract dust, very simple manual of arms; pull from holster, aim at B/G, pull trigger :) ! Like in the movie,"BlackHawk Down","This is my safety",*wiggles index finger* ;)!
 
My answer to the orginal question is a GLOCK as well. I would personally pick the model 17 but the 19 would do as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top