VCDL Board Member Foils Bank Robbery By Open Carry

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 3, 2006
Messages
572
From today's VCDL Alert:

The event that VCDL Board member Dennis O'Connor describes below happened in a SunTrust branch a couple of days ago.

SunTrust does not ban their law-abiding customers from legally carrying a firearm for self defense.

Had this been a Wachovia or a BB&T, both of which ban guns, the outcome would probably have been very different.

This event also underlines something that both Dennis and I believe - open carry, in and of itself, can be a strong deterrent to crime.
Yes, I know - the criminal COULD do a preemptive strike against someone he sees carrying openly. But in practice such an event is extremely rare. The outcome described below is the usual case.

In analyzing the encounter, the only thing I can flaw Dennis with is not being aware of the significance of what has happening around him.
But I have a law enforcement background and was trained to be on the lookout for certain behaviors and do so automatically.

The tellers at the bank, who are probably trained in how to handle a robbery, certainly knew what had just happened!

The other lesson is that crime almost always happens when you least expect it. In this case Dennis was busy getting some deposits taken care of and was focused on that task, something he has done for years routinely without a hitch. So when something unusual happened, his mind was a little slow switching gears.

Looking at it from a criminal's point of view, it was the perfect time for a holdup - the bank had just opened and there were few customers. (You can imagine that it would be much more difficult to rob a bank with, say, thirty people inside.)

In the end, this worked out as it usually does when a criminal finds himself face-to-face with an armed citizen - the criminal flees without a shot being fired.

In this more unusual case, Dennis's gun wasn't even touched or brandished!

Dennis's report:

On Tuesday the 26th of December I went down to the Sun Trust bank in Hopewell to complete some financial transactions. I got there just as they were opening and entered with a woman who had been waiting outside. There were three tellers in position to the left, one customer service associate at a desk to the right, and the manager was seated in his office to the rear right, so there were seven of us in the bank.

I have been banking there for years and know the tellers fairly well, who are quite used to me walking in with my holstered 1911 government model
.45 and two reserve magazines. As I was transacting business with my teller, a man came in through the front door on this warm December morning wearing a full ski mask, with only his eyes showing. He was wringing his hands and glanced furtively toward the office and then swept his eyes across the room, finally towards me and the tellers. At that, he turned and BOLTED back out the door!

The teller next to my position was the first to recognize the implications of what had just happened, and yelled for the manager who came rushing out from his office. He glanced toward me before sticking his head out the front door, looking both ways down the sidewalk, and pronouncing that the suspicious character had apparently left the area. The same teller then expressed her relief that I had been there, and mentioned that the next Sun Trust down on Route 10 (Iron Bridge Road) had just been robbed the week before.

I regret to say that I was pretty oblivious to anything but the business I was immediately conducting, and walked out thinking no more about it as a non-incident at the time. In fact, even later that evening I only mentioned it as a casual after-thought in a conversation with Philip. He urged me to write up this account of what had transpired, and I will leave it to him to dissect and analyze the facts, psychologies, probabilities and possible alternative outcomes.

FOLLOW UP

I went by the bank again today to make a deposit - same three tellers on duty. I asked them if the police were called over the ski-masked intruder.
They said no, but they had all discussed the incident yesterday afternoon and agreed that it was me standing there with a gun at Sharon's window (first one from the door) that spooked him into changing his plans, and they all thanked me again (although I didn't DO anything).
 
That...is FANTASTIC!! Wow. Wish I had more nerve to OC around Winchester.

We just had two home invasions in the same area within 2 weeks near my house. Things are heating up around here.
 
I'm a member of VCDL and think WTG! here too, but am doggone puzzled why the police were not called right then and there, and why someone (bank employee maybe?) didn't at least watch the guy for license plate info, etc.

C-
 
El T, don't underestimate all of us 300+ guys. :) Some of us ain't that fat.

Great story.
 
No one called the police? What a stupid thing NOT to do. No video tapes to look at, no possible MO to follow up on? Story smells like rotten fish.
 
That could explain why no one robbed any banks in my neighborhood a couple of days ago either. Open carry is illegal here so it's pretty clear evidence that open carry in Virginia protects the entire country.
 
No one called the police? What a stupid thing NOT to do. No video tapes to look at, no possible MO to follow up on? Story smells like rotten fish.
You know thats the only thing the skeptical part of me is scrutinizing too. Realistically would a bank manager who thinks they just about had an armed robbery not file a police report?
 
Malum ~

Larry Correia is the fellow you insulted with that :rolleyes: smiley.

I've met him. And he's not fat; in fact, he's the most evenly-proportioned large man I've ever met. I suspect that if I could stand on my own shoulders, I might be able to look him straight in the eye.

(Well, okay, maybe that was a slight exaggeration. But only a slight one!)

pax
 
3 crimes here:

1) attempted bank robbery

2) it was not reported to the police

3) as it was not reported to the police, it didn't get positive (or any) news coverage... and that's a damn shame if not a crime to the cause :p

that's my silly .02
 
TinyGnat, Appearing unarmed can make you out to be a potential target too.
Also can you find me a link to a case where a civilian open carrier was taken out first? A lot of people say that but no one has any proof of it happening.
 
Also can you find me a link to a case where a civilian open carrier was taken out first?
If you walk into a bank and there is somebody in there openly armed, doing business, wouldn't your question be: If one is armed, how many more may be?

I do believe that concealed would be a better choice.
 
Longwatch,
First let me say that I don't want to change the Open Carry Laws in VA. I like having the option of either Open Carry, or Concealed Carry. To answer your post about how Open Carry makes you a target, here's one I found with a quick Google search:

http://www.packing.org/community/how_to_carry/listview/16369/

Man robbed in the Centreville area

About 4:10 a.m. Sunday, July 30, officers were called to the area of Newton Patent Drive and Newton Tavern Drive. A 21-year-old Centreville-area man was robbed while walking on Newton Patent Drive. Two suspects approached the victim from behind, and placed a metal object up to the victim’s head. The suspects took the victim’s hand gun which he was openly carrying. The suspect’s then fled the area. The victim was not injured.

The suspects were described as black males wearing dark clothing.

Anyone with information about this incident or these suspects is asked to call Crime Solvers at 1-866-411-TIPS (8477) or the police non-emergency number at 703-691-2131.


It's easy to play armchair tactician, but in looking at these two scenarios,
they have a similar vein that Mr. Van Cleeve hints at: Lack of Situational Awareness. Had the victim mentioned above been more aware of his surroundings, he might still have his gun, but we don't know much of the circumstances (was he walking to get some air, was he just getting home, was he just waking up? why the hell was he out so late?) of why he was outside. I feel that the person involved in the Open Carry crime prevention was lucky as he seemed unaware of the criminal behind him (dressed in a ski mask to boot) while he was filling out paperwork. If the criminal had been more determined, or hardened, it's possible (again armchair tactician throwing an "if" pass here) that the person would have been a target and taken out first, especially since the criminal noticed the gun.
This is why I prefer Concealed Carry to Open Carry. Both require Situational Awareness, but the OC model requires even more vigilance which is difficult to maintain when one's attention is drawn elsewhere, like filling out paperwork. Open Carry also causes one to stand out as evidenced by the Criminal going "whoa!" and fleeing the premises. Concealed Carry allows one to blend in, and have a better chance at keeping the element of surprise.
My .02.
BTW, I am going to be at the VCDL booth tonight at the Nation's Gun Show in Centreville, VA. Come on by and say hello.
 
We just had two home invasions in the same area within 2 weeks near my house. Things are heating up around here.

I'm just wondering how open carry would be perceived in an area that has just recently had a home invasion or two. Certainly if the person doing the OC is well known in the neighborhood it shouldn't have any negative impact. But what about a good guy who isn't recognized by all? And what if he isn't the type who conforms to neighborhood standards of attire or body art or body color for that matter? Just wondering.
 
Tinygnat, I was aware of the Centreville case. All we can assume in that case is that OC did not deter those particular criminals, if the victim was in fact open carrying. We cannot assume that OC made him a target because we don't know what was in the minds of the criminals. It's plausible that he was robbed because he was the only one on the street. Did the criminals decide they wanted to steal his pistol or was he the just the first mark to come along at 4am or both? Who knows. Consider this, the robbery could have happened to a concealed carrier as well if he was practicing poor situational awareness, only a concealed carrier may not have lost his gun, if the criminals failed to search the victim thoroughly for loot. Basically I don't see how a CCW would have helped that victim who would allow a gun to be put at the back of his head.

Lets look at Dennis O'Connor's situation. Is there a similar scenario where the non LEO open carrier was taken out first? Of course we could go back and forth with scenarios and I would always say neither mode of carry is universally superior. A lot depends on the carrier and the situation and I believe it is up to everyone to decide for himself. However for me there are plenty of times when OC is superior to CC. I believe that open carry is a powerful deterent to crime, but how do you prove a crime didn't happen because of OC? Dennis's case is one of those. It is a rare case where we can prove a negative, where we can see a cause and effect between open carry and crime.

Now I'm not saying that open carry is a 100% effective deterent to crime. I believe about half or more of criminals would avoid an armed victim. Obviously in the Centerville case open carry didn't work for whatever reason. According to the Wright Rossi survey 56% of criminals would avoid an armed victim or one they believed was armed. I think the rest would take you if they thought they could get away with it (so don't let them think they can and present a hard target).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top