More on packs & practice
4v50 Gary said:
I've nothing to add but suggest that if one is really serious, to do a week or two of backpacking. You'll get experience with your equipment, learn what is superfluous and what should remain in your bugout.
Great suggestion. Until you've actually been "out there" with it, using it day to day, you'll not have a good sense of how it's actually going to work. As I mentioned in my post, er essay (above), my tiered bob system has evolved over decades of wilderness travel with a backpack. I've been down so many equipment roads as to be laughable, paring away the items that didn't work or that I really didn't need. But it mostly works for me now. Of course, everyone will be different, so trying out yours to see if it works for you in the outback is invaluable. You can't do it in your den or garage. It's just not the same.
I also agree strongly with ctdonath:
Probably the best option is a full-blown proper framed backpack, relatively lightweight, having plenty of room for everything with easy access and good weight distribution.
Think volume, weight, access, and weight distribution.
This is especially relevant for smaller folks (I'm one: tall & thin, even if wirey). Consider the weight that you plan to carry carefully. All that gear may sound good up front - "gee, I'm really glad I'm packing this extra-large can of beef stew" - but once on foot, going up or down, in the dark, weight becomes a factor. Of course, if you've been in the military recently and had to carry a 90# pack (not me), this is less important.
And, having a pack that's designed to carry the weight you wish to carry is important, and learning how to load it to distribute the weight is equally important. Sometimes a minor, seemingly insignificant adjustment can make a HUGE difference, (sez one who regularly redistributes weight on the first two days of a five day trip).
Your pack should fit you like a glove. You should wear it, not carry it. If you don't know how to fit one, go to a backpacking store for instructions. Forget about walmart for this one.
There are some great backpacking "how to" books out there. The one that has been my guide since I started backpacking in 1972 is
The Complete Walker by Collin Fletcher. Extremely informative, written by the grandaddy of backpacking skills of the late 20th century, and funny as hell. (He writes of packing for his walking trip through the entire
length of the Grand Canyon, carrying a scale with him to the store to weigh underwear to get the lightest possible pair. Yes, again for smaller folks, ounces add up very quickly into pounds.)
Pay attention more to his general suggestions than specific equipment. Even the fourth edition, written in 2002, is now slightly out of date because equipment evolves so fast.
Personally, I'd still stay away from the cheapo canvas bags available from surplus stores, especially the ones without a hip-belt. In backpacking, you do NOT carry weight on your shoulders, but on the hips via the hipbelt. Hipbelt is critical. All the shoulder straps do is to stabilize the load.
I have three packs. One is my fanny pack by Mountainsmith that's nearly the biggest that you can buy. Full-sized
padded hip belt like you would find on a backpack. It is my constant companion when I'm not at home. I would no more leave home without it than without my keys. Even in the best of times, it's got water, an extra layer in the cooler times, rainjacket (in the rainy season), and a bit of food. It's going to get updated as a result of reading this thread.
My intermediate sized pack, that I call my day and a half pack (enough gear to do an overnight if necessary, even if not with full gear; e.g., no tent, but bivy sack, extra layers, 2 days food, water, first aid, etc) is an
Arcteryx Bora 50 . It has a built in pocket for a hydration system. (My hydration bladder is made by Kelty, but there are many that will fit it.) For a SHTF BOB, I'd want this one loaded and ready as a minimum. Very comfortable carry. I can regularly carry 25#'s with it for 8 mile day hikes and not even know it's on.
My full sized expedition pack, the one I'd want for those TEOTWAWKI times, is an older Gregory Atlas, no longer produced.
Here is a similar one. I can't recommend Gregory packs highly enough. Superb design, built to last (mine's been hundreds of very rough miles), very comfortable if you get one that fits you and learn how to adjust it. Note the gregory web site has a section devoted to pack fit.
Of course, gear like this ain't cheap. I elected to buy good wilderness gear instead of taking on a mortgage and raising kids. (I'm semi-nomadic, so it fits me.) If you've got a mortgage to pay and kids to feed, go for the best you can get. Remember, fit is everything, and bigger is not necessarily better.