Originally posted by:
TheGoldenSaber
If there's ever a SHTF situation that would be about the last gun I would grab.
This whole question depends a lot on what you mean by "SHTF situation".
If you're talking about a short term
Katrina type situation, I'd agree that a .22 probably wouldn't be very high on my list of things to grab.
If "SHTF" means a general collapse of society, a la
The Road Warrior, or even just a collapse of our currency and rehash of the Great Depression, a good .22 rifle and a few handfulls of hollowpoints would be just about the most valuable items that a person could possess, because it can KEEP YOU IN FOOD. I'll admit that squirrels and rabbits can be killed by an AR-15, but unless you enjoy eating red mist and bloody hair, it's not a very good way to obtain food.
Now before anyone jumps all over me about that statement, understand that I'm a handloader and I know that it's possible to load a .223, 30-06 or .460 Weatherby down and make it a reasonably capable small game harvesting tool. It just takes a lot more time, equipment and resources than thumbing five or ten rounds of .22 rimfire into your rifle.
I suppose that it would also be possible to plow a field with a 350 horsepower pickup truck, let's just say that it'd be a lot more difficult and the final results probably wouldn't be as satisfactory as using an old 40 horsepower John Deere.
I've spoken with quite a few old timers that lived through the hard times of the Great Depression and Dust Bowl, after a couple of very lean years, deer and feral hogs were almost extirpated from East Texas, even armadillos ("Hoover hogs") were pretty scarce. Squirrels, rabbits and small birds were about the only edible game that could be found with anything approaching regularity and the lowly .22 was all that stood between many families and starvation. On the rare occasions that a deer did present itself, a shot placed just below the ear hole would kill them every bit as dead as a 30-06 without making noise that would attract a Game Warden, or worse, hungry, armed and desperate people with children of their own to feed.