Wheelchair bound Brit arrested for self defense

Status
Not open for further replies.

jsalcedo

Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2002
Messages
3,683
I acted in self-defence says disabled robbery victim

A DISABLED man who used CS spray to fight off a robber is now facing the threat of legal action.

Wheelchair-bound Nicholas Ashworth, aged 22, sprayed his alleged attacker in the face with the CS spray.

He then climbed out of his wheelchair and limped across the road as the man screamed in pain. A passing police patrol spotted him in distress and stopped at the scene. Officers then arrested both men.

Today after being released on police bail pending further inquiries -- which could result in police prosecution -- Mr

Ashworth defended his use of the CS spray. He said he bought it to protect himself after being attacked in Bridgeman Street three weeks ago. On that occasion his attacker hit him in the face before pinning him back in his chair. The man then rifled through his pockets and stole £100.

Mr Ashworth, of Fletcher Street, Bolton -- who can walk just a short distance without his wheelchair -- said the incident left him feeling vulnerable.

Only days later he used it when a would-be robber confronted him as Mr Ashworth made his way to a nearby supermarket.

Mr Ashworth said the attacker held a knife at his throat and threatened to stab him. When he refused to hand over his money the man pushed him across the road and into bushes on the other side of the carriageway.

He said when he was threatened again he grabbed the CS canister and sprayed the man in the face.

He said: "I knew it was wrong and against the law but in my view I was acting in self defence. I thought the man was going to kill me.

"It is a sad state of affairs that disabled people like me have to carry such things like CS sprays for protection."

A police spokesman said that they were investigating the illegal use and possession of CS spray. He also revealed that a man was on police bail pending further inquiries into the attempted robbery of Mr Ashworth.
 
Agricola, how are you gonna explain this one? :rolleyes:
A police spokesman said that they were investigating the illegal use and possession of CS spray.
So an item most female college students in the US carry religiously is illegal to carry or use in England? :banghead:

Kharn
 
Concur: Agi, let's hit it!

This one I've just gotta read the excuse for.

By the way, where were the police prior to the assault???
 
Subjects depend on the King for life; citizens rely on themselves for life even against a tyrannical King. The founders of America whould have understood denying a person the means and ability to protrect his own life as the epitomy of tyranny.

We aren't like the British because WE WON the revolution, established liberty, and preserved it (so far) by a written constitution. I much rather be free than "civilized" in the fashion that British sheeple are.
 
Here's a link for the story: http://www.thisisbolton.co.uk/lancashire/bolton/news/BENTOPNEWS0.html

1. Right wing newspaper incorrectly reported the story.

2. He could have used HM's handicap shuttle and grocery delivery service, rather than wheeling though bad parts of town = the assaults are a result of his negligence.

3. He resisted the assault, contrary to home office directives.

4. He lost protection of the courts when he opened his front door that morning.
:p
 
Well what is a person in a wheelchair supposed to do? Jump up and go assault ninja on the assailant. Why don't they pat the guy on the back and prosecute the assailant.
 
Agricola:
If a wheel-chair bound person cannot use CS spray to defend themselves, what can he/she use to defend him/herself? A short list of examples would suffice.

Kharn
 
Don't you crazies get it?

Self defence with anything other than your bare hands and harsh language is uncivilised and WRONG!

I was being sarcastic...

The whole point is that you are allowed to 'defend yourself' just not 'defend yourself with any effectiveness or fore-thought'.

Agricola, do you like being a pawn?
 
I may be a crazy foreigner, but it seems to me that outlawing effective means of self-defense/defence is the same thing as outlawing self-defense itself.
 
when the wheelchair user gets done for assault, then the thread title is correct. until then, it isnt.

there is an element in this story that does suggest caution, namely that the alleged robber is on police bail and has not been charged. an attempted robbery, part of which has been witnessed by police, where the suspect has a knife and where he is detained in the act, does not result in that person getting police bail (which is only granted for more time to get evidence) - he/she is charged and sent to court (what happens then is up to them).
 
Rarely does a day pass when I fail to feel grateful to our forefathers for having rebelled against the English and founded a republic.

What a contemptible people the English have devolved into!
 
Self defence with anything other than your bare hands and harsh language is uncivilised and WRONG!
Bare hands will soon be added to the Forbidden Weapon List, if they aren't there already. As as for harsh language, remember there is no constitutional freedom of speech in Old Blimey.
 
Likely outcomes:

5. The alleged attacker, who prior had been to the Sweet Green Tavern, relied on the now popular "Paul Evans" defense: he was slightly inebriated and merely stumbled onto Mr. Ashworth whilst helping him cross the street. No intent to assault or rob...Ashworth must have been paranoid from his previous attack.

6. Prosecutors may grant clemency if Ashworth gives up his supplier network for the illegal CS gas (and shows ample remorse before the court).

7. Barristers now studying Ashworth's financial status, for possible compensation to courts and now injured "robber".

:p Sorry agri, this is too much to pass up!
 
Pepper spray is indeed illegal, as are pocket knives. When I was in England last summer a young man got six months in jail for having pepper spray.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top