Which black powder flask is the best and why do you like it?

[ClemBert]

I never bought a BP flask and opted to use the adjustable Thompson Center U-View measure as shown below. I simply set it to number of grains I need then use a 2.2cc scoop to fill it up before pouring into the revolver. And, no...that powder bin is not open when shooting.

Anyhow, I wanted to find out what your preferred BP flask is if you use one. What problems do you have with it or is it perfect. I read a lot of complaints about Pedersoli powder flasks...something about three tiny screws. I assume you have to remove three screw in order to fill it up?

 

[Tommygunn]

With regards to flasks, I don't think there really is a "perfect" flask. They do come in different sizes, then there are "Colt" and "Remington" flasks, and others. With regards to loading them funnels are available so you don't really need to tinker with tiny screws, if you so choose.

 

[Patocazador]

I have 2 types. The Colt-type flask is flat and fits nicely in my shooting pouch. The cylindrical ones are nice for bench reloading because they stand up on the bench and thus are quickly accessible.

 

[Fingers McGee]

A silver plated Florentine flask. It fits my character, is easy to use, and is heavy weight so it wont dent or crack if dropped. I've been using it for some where between 10 and 15 years. Colt or Remington style flasks are made of thin material soldered along the seam that will dent of crack if not careful. The tubular flasks are ok for bench shooters, but the traditional flasks fit in a possibles bag better IMNSHO.

https://www.trackofthewolf.com/Categories/PartDetail.aspx/69/1/FLASK-FLORE

 

[maint1517]

I have a traditions brass flask that came with my 1860.
its the only one ive owned so far. I've had no issues with it, but I have been thinking about getting one of the "teardrop" shaped brass flasks. They have one on ebay with a cannon and flags on it. Has anyone tried one of those?

 

[Armored farmer]

I have a traditions brass flask that came with my 1860.
its the only one ive owned so far. I've had no issues with it, but I have been thinking about getting one of the "teardrop" shaped brass flasks. They have one on ebay with a cannon and flags on it. Has anyone tried one of those?

That's what i use. A copper pistol flask.
It drops 29gr ff, and makes quick work of reloading my '58s.
I think it looks authentic enough.

 

[maint1517]

Thanks Armor Farmer. My mistake, it is copper and not brass. I'll probably grab one next week.

 

[PainlessWolf]

Good morning,
I use the Colt type flasks with my black powder revolvers. I have the standard copper one for use with the 1860 Army and the 'Marshall' .44 and it is set to throw a 30 grn charge . I use the copper Walker flask for the Walker and Whitney Dragoon and have it set for a 50 grn powder charge. For the LeMat, I use a fancier Parisian type flask that uses a 26 grn spout. I'll probably use the Army model one for the Starr.
regards!

 

[Mike OTDP]

I favor the tubular flasks. Easier to fill.

 

[TTv2]

I have a CVA Field Flask, which is basically just a round brass flask that's half the size of a regular one. I prefer to have something I can carry easily to something I can't and when I'm at the range, when it runs out, I just refill it with powder.

It only has one spout and it throws 21 grains of powder I believe. For my 1858 with Pyrodex, I'll put 42 grains in each chamber, in the .36 Navy's I'll just put 21 grains. The numbers work for me and my shooting and my steel framed guns, but if you're using a brass frame or a .31 caliber, probably not the best flask to use.

I do wish that more spouts were made to accommodate different amounts of powder. I can't say mine is the best, but I like it.

 

[44 Dave]

Have 2 of these, one plastic CVA screw off top, an assortment of spouts, and a set of Lee dippers. It depends on what gun, what bullet and where I am loading. When I want aslightly smaller spout insert a reducer from a plastic straw.

 

[J-Bar]

One like this. Easier to hold than a Colt style flask. Lots easier to fill, too.

https://www.trackofthewolf.com/Categories/PartDetail.aspx/69/1/FLASK-PS

 

[BullRunBear]

I've used most styles of flasks over the years but prefer the tubular or cylindical types. You can unscew the top or bottom from the body of the flask for easy filling. No need for a funnel or messing with those tiny screws. I have the set of spouts that screw into the top for different charges. If I need a bigger charge than the spouts, I just keep the lever open and pour the Goex into a measure.

I use a powder horn with my flintlocks, even at the range, just because it seems more appropriate.

Jeff

 

[T.J.]

I have three, one old Remington flask and two new cylinder flasks. The cylinder flasks can be emptied and filled much easier. I got additional spouts from EMF for one dollar each and they fit all three flasks. With the spouts that came with the flasks and the ones from EMF I can measure 30,29,21,17 and 15 grains of 3F GOEX black by weight. I will add a picture as soon as i can figure out how.
Terry

 

[WestKentucky]

I have three, one old Remington flask and two new cylinder flasks. The cylinder flasks can be emptied and filled much easier. I got additional spouts from EMF for one dollar each and they fit all three flasks. With the spouts that came with the flasks and the ones from EMF I can measure 30,29,21,17 and 15 grains of 3F GOEX black by weight. I will add a picture as soon as i can figure out how.
Terry

I have the two larger flasks shown in TJ’s post above this one. The cylindrical flask I have had for nearly 20 years. I use both for rifles, and I do it the old fashioned way. I trimmed my tube to match the charge weight I want, put a finger over the hole and push the lever over, flip it to fill the tube then release the lever and flip the tube up again. Dump into rifle and ram a projectile on top. I prefer the cylinder because it’s easier to grab and operate one handed, but with nice warm gloves on I prefer the fat flask as I can get a better grip, probably because of the textured image stamped on it. I have threatened knurling or roughing up the cylindrical flask.

 

[John L Venable]

I have colt replicas, a small one that throws 12 gr for my .31, the Standerd one for my .36's with various spouts, I bought the large Walker Flask but it's a PITA to adjust so I made it a wall hanger. for the walker and my rifled muskets I use the cylnder type brass jobs with misc spouts. It's really whatever your comfortable with. I also have a horn and antler measure for my "Pennsylvania rifle".

 

[drobs]

I want to say the below is made by CVA. Has a 30gr spout.

 

[Patocazador]

I have 4 of the cylindrical flasks that I have filled with 1F, 2F, 3F, and 4F powders with spouts that hold the proper charge for the individual guns. The 1F is used in my SxS 12 ga.

 

[Caliper_Mi]

Rifles get loaded using a measure similar to what the OP has. Pour from horn to measure, then charge rifle.

Revolvers I use the measuring flask with screw-on spouts of different sizes. Have a collection ranging from 20-50 grains. No, not quite as consistent as the measure but I trade that bit of consistency for speed and I'm still happy with the groups from the revolvers. I do plan to get on my game making combustible paper cartridges for the revolvers and in that case will use a modern powder measure.

 

[AlexanderA]

That's a nice cased set for your Remington revolver. The "stand of arms" flask is what's known as a "Colt" flask, while the "Remington" flask has a sporting dog within an oval. At least that's what the makers of reproduction flasks call them. There's also a "Colt" and a "Remington" bullet mold. I believe you have the "Remington" bullet mold. (The handles on the "Colt" mold are curved.)

 

[whughett]

I want to say the below is made by CVA. Has a 30gr spout.

View attachment 783307

I use this one too along with a full line of spouts from 10 to 60 grains. The screw on cap makes refilling easy.

 

[Ironhand54]

Another vote for the tubular flasks. Easier to use and hold.

I also like the TC clear measure.

IronHand

 

[swathdiver]

The Remington flasks are most comfortable in my hand. I use a screw in funnel to refill them, no need to pull those little set screws. It holds 5-1/2 ounces of powder, enough for about 68 shots of 35 grain charges or about 100 shots of 24 grain charges. More than plenty for a day of fun for me. It's also enough to reload both barrels on a doublegun at least 15 times.

My leather Hawksley with the flame proof valve is nice too for reloading the doublegun as in the times of old.

 

[Loyalist Dave]

I want to say the below is made by CVA. Has a 30gr spout.

View attachment 783307

That's the flask sold by CVA, but I think it's packaged and sold by other brands as well.

It's a good flask in that it's easy to fill, by twisting off the screw-on base. The spout is also removable as it screws on, and you can develop a pet load for one revolver or another, and cut the brass spout and finish it with a file to throw that pet load. For example, I like 18 grains of 3Fg and a couple of felt wads, under a .451 round ball in my Pietta, "Confederate Navy .44 revolvers". Highly accurate, all you need in CAS is to ring the steel, and doesn't beat up the brass frames.

Flasks are fine for revolvers, but I use a fixed measure, aka a "charger" for black powder rifles and smooth bores.

LD