If made in USA is a requirement, you're limited to a Marlin 1894 or a Winchester 94, if you can find one. Between the two, I'd recommend the Marlin, since it was designed for pistol length cartridges and should be less prone to jamming.
If you change your mind and can accept an import, the Rossi copies of the Winchester 1892 are nice. Very slick action and reliable. The Rossis imported by EMF and Navy Arms have somewhat nicer finishes than those imported by LSI, and also lack the st00pid bolt-mounted safety found on the LSIs.
I have an EMF/Rossi 1892 Short Rifle in .357. I.e., it has a 20" octagonal barrel and rifle style wood. It's an absolute hoot to shoot and quite accurate out to 50 yards, the furthest I've shot it so far.