For anything bigger than me, that has the potential of digesting me, I like the idea of cast solids with wide meplates, pushed hard. I want bones breaking and two holes for every round. I consider the lightweight stuff mfg for personal defense, from people.
That 240 will not likely be recovered from anything you shoot at defensive distances. I cast and load my own, but I really like the Lyman 429421 over 20g of 2400 OR the Lee 310g gas checked RNFP over 21.5g of W296. More weight/velocity yeilds better penetration, but 240g isn't exactly a lightweight.
I'll make this one easy. A 45-70 round using a 400+gr Cast bullet traveling at very slow speeds compared to modern ammo will go completely through a Buffalo. Heavy and slow worked very well 138 years ago and still works well today.Balrog said:Does the slower velocity of the SWC load bother you?
Unlike when trying to stop a man where you have a fairly soft and easy to kill target large animals are tough. Many have very thick skin and big heavy bones. A heavy lead projectile with a wide meplat will expand less and carry most of it's energy deep into and animal even when striking bone. I'm sure there's a more eloquent explanation but I'm a simple man so that's the best I can do...I was wondering why SWC bullets are better for hunting large game.
Yes, that you're trying to make it something it's not.Just something about 1800 - 1900 fps that makes a statement.
I would certainly ask before I made that assumption.Personally, I think some hand loaders are affraid of the slow burning powders and the data that applies.
Because we found a better way. We also know that with cast bullets, absolute maximum velocity is not necessary.I don't know why fast powder - lead loaders are so temparmental about jacketed - slow burning powder- high velocity loaders?