Why choose a 9mm in a 1911 platform?

[Thirties]

I own two .45cal 1911-A1s and I am very very happy with them. I also own a CZ85 in 9mm which I also love, and I used to own a BHP Practical in 9mm which I always regret selling.

So, my question, without starting a 1911 love/hate conversation, is this:

Unless you were interested in a set of 1911 pistols in different calibers for competition, sport, or collecting, why would one buy a 9mm luger auto pistol in a 1911 platform?

I may be mistaken, but aren't there many modern 9mm pistols more reliable, holding more ammo, and more concealable, than those built on a 1911 platform?

Am I thinking this through correctly or am I missing something or ill informed?

 

[La Pistoletta]

Maybe some people like the ergonomics and don't want to re-learn their grip.

 

[Thirties]

That's what I thought . . . good enough reason to be sure. Aside from that, are there any other reasons?

 

[kamagong]

The 1911 trigger is a wonder in and of itself. Nothing compares.

 

[crushbup]

It's nice and slim. Perhaps one loves that feel, but only owns other 9mm guns and reloads for it. .45 is rather expensive now.

 

[J Lambs]

My wife likes the look and feel of the Kimber Stainless Ultra Carry, so I just bought one in 9mm. Maybe I can coax her into going shooting with me. I was afraid that the .45 would be a little too snappy.

 

[Pilot]

1. Trigger

2. Low felt recoil

3. If you like the ergos of a 1911

 

[slzy]

way things are going,ammo prices.

 

[NGIB]

Mag capacity and rails and other gizmos can't replace the functionality and shootability of the 1911 platform. If they weren't priced absurdly, I'd own a 9mm 1911 myself...

 

[steelyblue]

I personally own a 45acp, 22lr, and a 9mm 1911. I just like the way they shoot. They are so easy to shoot well with, it's almost like cheating! I can't group as well with any other platform.

 

[p89cajun]

My main thought when looking at 9mm 1911's was ammo cost. I love the 1911 but .45 is getting expensive.

 

[mnw42]

I have a .38 Super Commander, and I'm just a barrel change away from a cheap plinking 9mm.

The next best thing is a Browning HP.

 

[wally]

Ammo cost is my only reason for wanting one. Too bad they are hard to find for less than $700+ makes little sense to get an expensive gun to shoot cheap ammo. So until someone like Taurus or RIA sees the opportunity awaiting with a value priced 1911 in 9mm I make do with my Star BM.

I agree the sliding trigger is what really makes the 1911 special.

--wally.

 

[CountGlockula]

$$$$$$$$

 

[Lobotomy Boy]

If you pay $100-$200 more for a 9mm 1911 vs. a .45 1911, you can easily make up that price difference in short order if you shoot a lot. If you shoot 200 rounds per week, which I often do, that's roughly $60 for a .45 and $30 for the 9mm. You'll save the price difference between a .45 and a 9mm in 4-8 weeks, and if you continue to shoot at that rate, you'll have paid for the gun in the money saved on ammo over 10 months.

 

[Ghost Tracker]

I, just last week, saw a Springfield 1911 9mm in a Pawn Shop for ~$400. It was a little rough, but certainly worth a look. Next time I go by, if it's still there...it's coming home with me. Apparently the popularity of the 9mm 1911 is on the rise. Wilson Combat just introduced a new 1911 mag in that caliber. (There's yet ANOTHER excuse to by one!)

 

[NC-Mike]

I like steel-framed, hammer-fired, single actions pistols.

If I want a 9mm, a 1911 in that caliber is a natural choice.

I don't like the new plastic, DAO offerings that are out these days.

 

[Black Majik]

Pilot hit the nail on the head. Ergonomics, 1911 trigger, and all steel to reduce recoil. I'll offer one more, it's 9mm, so it's easier to afford than .45 ACP.

 

[Green Lantern]

Glad I found this thread before committing some hardcore necromancy on one circa 2006!

Now, I REALLY want a 1911...(eventually)

But I own a Glock 19, and thus have some 9mm ammo on hand. I figure if possible it's best to TRY and stick to as few calibers as possible for ease of "stocking up" on ammo.

Another plus for the 9mm is the price, as others have mentioned...

Hmm, that 06 thread in question was on the Taurus 9mm 1911 - I didn't see it on their site, is it still going to be released?

 

[Eightball]

Not to hijack the thread, but this caught my eye:

There is no right to have access to the weapons of war in the streets of America.
John Kerry, 3/2/2004

Response? There is now

Anyhow, I would agree with most of the other posters as to liking the 1911 platform, and wanting a 9mm for any given reason, as the answer to the OP's question. It just makes sense!

 

[bluetopper]

I'm waiting now on my Dan Wesson 9mm 1911 to arrive I have ordered. It is supposed to be a work of art.
They are just making 30 of them this year.
My main reason for getting one is I like to shoot smaller groups then my buddies at 25yds. and I just like high quality, beautiful, accurate firearms. I have other dependable sidearms I don't mind getting scratched up for carry.
Plus, not everybody has a nice 9mm 1911.

I've been through and outgrown the hi-cap polymer stage in my life. I felt no "pride of ownership" with them. The new wore off quick.

 

[kentucky_smith]

I was in the process of looking at parts to build one on a frame I've got, can't seem to justify the cost, so I bought another BHP.

 

[schmeky]

Here's a really nice on Gunbroker

http://www.gunsonthenet.com/Auction/ViewItem.asp?Item=103269417