Would you or wouldn't you? S&W 5906

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, if it is still available when I get back, I’ll buy it.

My post gave the available 5906 as an example of my list and my perpetual conundrum.

Bigger question is how do you go about collecting or deciding what guns to buy for a collection and when? I think if you have all the guns you need, after that, any more guns lean towards the category of collecting.

For me, I’ve created a prioritized list of guns that interest me and set a budget. I save for the next one on the list, and then, BAM, a gun lower on the buying priority shows up for a good deal before I have the money for priority gun number one. Then my gun money is back to zero, and I never get to gun number one on the list. I am in the category of having poor buying discipline. Maybe “poor” is the operative word.:) It never fails how the good deals on lower priorities show up when you have higher priorities.

I enjoy the process, and somewhat lament the missed opportunities in jest. It is what it is; I have what I need. Something else always comes along.

Your going about it the smart way. Have your list and wait for a nice deal to pop up. I dont really "need" anything but I have lots of wants. Biggest problem for me is I like low end stuff just as much as high end stuff. Never got the brand snob stuff. There are a whole lot of great innexpensive firearms out there these days. Its always nice to pick up something high end once in a while though if I find it really interesting.

Buying used is always nice. Its very rare that a firearm is shot out. The only new firearms I will buy are American manufacturers. I try to keep as much money as possible in country and in our manufacturing industry.

Something like a 5906 at a good price is an easy decision. Even if its a little scratched up you can just bead blast it back to look great as there is no finish. Cant really do that with the aluminum frame pistols unless you want to slap some paint on it...which is kinda Meh to me.

Go buy it, clean it up, and throw some new grips on it. I stippled a set of old worn grips on my carry 915 and didnt have any problems with warpage. Smith and Wesson DA/SA design was in the military trials (failed the salt test I think) so the design is sound. The steel frames are more durable. LE all over carried these before Glocks and its extremely rare to hear anything bad about them. Parts are out there if you look around. Mecgars are cheap and have better stronger springs than the factory OEM magazines. They are classic, American, well designed, and quality pistols with great history.
 
For me, I’ve created a prioritized list of guns that interest me and set a budget. I save for the next one on the list, and then, BAM, a gun lower on the buying priority shows up for a good deal before I have the money for priority gun number one. Then my gun money is back to zero, and I never get to gun number one on the list. I am in the category of having poor buying discipline. Maybe “poor” is the operative word.:) It never fails how the good deals on lower priorities show up when you have higher priorities.

Buying "out of order" when you find a good deal simply means you will eventually buy everything on your list, but for less than you had originally budgeted.
 
I'd pass on the 5906. They have their cult following, but in the end, the Beretta 92 does the same thing and is a nicer gun, all-around.

Additionally, I'd swap your #1 and 2 priorities. A 22LR pistol should always be top priority for a handgunner. 22LR rifles are great too, but being able to shoot cheaply should trump all else, IMO.

I DO like centerfire revolvers, (they're my favorites, these days) especially with light handloads. 22LR trumps them though.
 
I'd pass on the 5906. They have their cult following, but in the end, the Beretta 92 does the same thing and is a nicer gun, all-around.

Additionally, I'd swap your #1 and 2 priorities. A 22LR pistol should always be top priority for a handgunner. 22LR rifles are great too, but being able to shoot cheaply should trump all else, IMO.

I DO like centerfire revolvers, (they're my favorites, these days) especially with light handloads. 22LR trumps them though.

Get both!...eventually.... In fact... almost all the pistols in the military trials were pretty fantastic. Nice thing about those pistols is they all pretty much went on to have succesful careers and were made in large numbers. That means tons of parts out there if you shoot enough to ever need it. Im a parts junkie but for a 5906 maybe a spare set of springs, extractor, and possibly a fireing pin if someone is really worried. Im not aware of any major weakness in the design in 9mm. Factory OEM mags have gotten expensive for whatever reason (they use to be cheap) but standard Mecgars are better and still made.

5906s are not uncommon but people tend to hold onto them. I really like some of the more uncommon stuff but dont really shoot them much due to parts. Anyone got a source for Bernardelli P-One parts HaHa. With something like the 5906 you get the best of both worlds.. nice quality and you can shoot it as much as you want or can afford.

I also agree with Smaug on the 22lr pistol/rifle stuff. Shooting cheap is a priority. 22lr, like airguns, is also really easy to stockpile (you can only stockpile so much centerfire) and you can litterally get all the trigger/target time you want for little funds... which you can then save up for the centerfire firearm stuff. Airguns and 22lr are wallet savers as well as being great skill builders for yourself, the wife, kids, friends etc. etc.
 
Am sorry, but a M1 is your number 3?



Should be #1

Judging by the price tags, it's at a Scheels. I've never walked through one of their stores and thought, man that's over priced.

Yeah, Garrand is number 3 - I waffle there though. I know the supply of cheap CMP Garands is limited, and therefore time is limited as well. The Garand would probably be the best choice for a collection piece I don't have since I don't have any mil-surp rifles. All that points to moving it to #1. But I don't have any revolvers and I just see using those more. The Garand would likely be relegated to sitting in the safe and is more expensive to shoot if I decided to take it out of the safe.
 
Yeah, Garrand is number 3 - I waffle there though. I know the supply of cheap CMP Garands is limited, and therefore time is limited as well. The Garand would probably be the best choice for a collection piece I don't have since I don't have any mil-surp rifles. All that points to moving it to #1. But I don't have any revolvers and I just see using those more. The Garand would likely be relegated to sitting in the safe and is more expensive to shoot if I decided to take it out of the safe.
Ive got a New Old Stock straight-back grip module you can have if you buy the Smith. PM me.
 
I like 3rd generation smith's. The triggers can be cleaned up with a little work, parts are still very much available, and the magazine safety is easy to get rid of if you want to. There are makers of both leather and kydex holsters for them also.
You can also swap that grip with a straight back variant, which I happen to like better.
 
I keep my list of guns I want in my head and in no particular order. When I find one at a good price and have the cash for it I buy it. My want list has gotten shorter over the years.
FN-49
Egyptian Rasheed
XDm in .45acp.

I am working hard to resist buying a 10mm. I saw a good price on a S&W 1006 once but was able to pass it by.

I had a S&W 625 in 45LC on my list for quite a while. Then I came across a Dan Wesson 744 at a great price and it took care of my big bore handgun need.

I am sure there are a few others that don't immediately pop into my mind but I will know them when I see them.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, Garrand is number 3 - I waffle there though. I know the supply of cheap CMP Garands is limited, and therefore time is limited as well. The Garand would probably be the best choice for a collection piece I don't have since I don't have any mil-surp rifles. All that points to moving it to #1. But I don't have any revolvers and I just see using those more. The Garand would likely be relegated to sitting in the safe and is more expensive to shoot if I decided to take it out of the safe.

Some guns are just fun to shoot! The M1 Garand being one of them. After a few clips I find they don't get shot a lot though. Is there any place that you can shoot a few clips through one and then hand it back to the owner?
 
I've always loved the S&W 3rd Generation semi-autos. A scaled down 5904 (Model 915) has been my main squeeze since the mid 1990s. I like the 5906, which is the heaviest and probably most robust of the series, but for me it's just a bit too heavy. I've been keeping an eye out for a 5903. It's a lot lighter due to the alloy frame and that frame is pretty indestructible. I wouldn't worry about that being a point of failure.

I've got several original factory stainless S&W mags, one blued factory mag and several blued Mec-Gar mags in 15 and 17 rounds. They all function flawlessly. The 3rd generation Smiths aren't nearly outdated. IMO they're some of the best still to this day.

PS: It's very easy to remove the magazine disconnect. You can find the procedure on youtube. It's a simple matter of sliding off the rear sight and removing a small spring and plunger. I did it to mine along with a couple other minor mods that any kitchen table gunsmith can manage.

 
Last edited:
Some guns are just fun to shoot! The M1 Garand being one of them. After a few clips I find they don't get shot a lot though. Is there any place that you can shoot a few clips through one and then hand it back to the owner?


Yep! I don’t shoot my M1’s often. Maybe a hundred rounds a year. But it is the most satisfying weapon I have ever owned.
 
Snap that up in a New York minute.
Unfortunately it’s going to have to wait a few more minutes. Earliest I can get to the store is Monday. If it’s still there, I’m buying. If not, I’m still about half way to a 686 (or a Garand - I might have to update my priority list based on the idea of dwindling availability from the CMP).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top