XD or Glock

[TimmyXD]

I have a Glock 27 and XD9. I like both guns and wouldnt say one is better or more accurate or anything. Your gun is only as accurate as the shooter. I do know that both guns handel completly different though point of aim grip, angle, etc. My glock is the subcompact and easily concealable the xd is the service model and still concealable but a little more tricky. For carry i probably switch about 50/50 between the two. Anyhow other then your own preference I would suggest to practice how you play and go with the glock for a carry gun also.

 

[PabloJ]

Isn't this choice between "violet" and "red" colored Kool-Aid? Oops, can't remember haven't drank any since 1981.

 

[gofastman]

Is the Glock available with a grip safety? There's your answer. LOL

Precisely! get a Glock.

 

[Strykervet]

The polygonal rifling is superior in velocity, and supposedly accuracy, to traditional rifling. I have a G17L that shoots phenomenal groups, and at closer ranges, just a ragged hole. A G29 that comes in close second. Both are more accurate than either Beretta I have owned. The 2 9mm's I have are mostly target pistols now, a 17 and a 17L. The .40 and 10mm just made the 9mm an obsolete carry round in my opinion. I think it is good for target work, war, and if for carry, reserved for the smallest of backup pistols.

I'd do what that other fellow said. Get the G27. Then get a nice IWB holster, like a Milt Sparks VMII and a stiff gunbelt. Now you have a conceal carry off duty piece that will use the G23 mags as backup mags. And you can get a different holster and use it as a backup pistol on duty --and hey! It uses your duty mags too!

I have this exact rig on right now, I love it. I also have several Glocks, and I have never seen a reason to get another plastic pistol. These things look simple and cheap, but they are a fine example of precise engineering. A lot of thinking went into that design.

The other Glock copies just don't cut it for me, but if I was to pick a differnt plastic pistol, it would have to be the HK USP. I've seen them in action, reliable and able to hit a sillhouette at 200m! But at the price they go for, I'd rather save a little more and get a nice 1911, or an older 10mm Smith and a bag of brass.

 

[easyg]

At one time I owned both an XD and a Glock.

I still own the Glock.

As much as I tried to like the XD I just didn't feel that it was as good as the Glock.

 

[Reasoned1]

I have several XD45s (purchased new and used) and have never had a failure--even with some of the worst ammo that would lock other guns up solid. Had a Glock 19, liked it very much, but also had enough stove-pipes to know that one wasn't perfect. You can't go wrong either way, so the real question is what feels better (especially when you're shooting it). Be aware that some good guns will work for some and not for others.

 

[1stmarine]

Springfield Armory vs. Brick and mortar?

Let me explain something simple... XD is a good gun I do not doubt that and anyone with one should be a very proud owner like all the little toys we have. But the glock is already well established with a reputation of the AK of the handguns. I just came back of my weekly IDPA training and we were talking just about that. Can anyone please jam one of these glocks, anyone? hello? This is getting boring here the same old glock that never jams and it is pretty accurate! Drop it in the mud, piss it clean and keep shooting.
Today I was shooting a full size glock in .357SIG in 2 different scenarios. Nothing gets better than that.

XD is an HS pistol renamed that is designed and made in Croatia. (did I spell it right?)
Glock desinged and made in Austria and assembled in the US to cover the huge demand of countless LEO agencies, security firms and legions of enthusiasts that keep a few jobs here and puts some food on some American home table.

Glock parts, accessories, options, special purpose solutions, whatever you can imagine.

But the most important thing of all is try them and see what feels better for you. The one that feels better that is the gun for you.
I am kind of boring, never look for anything new or exciting. Something that simply works.

Think!

 

[bubbacrabb]

I own both, both are good guns. Sense you're an LEO, I know the price you can get on them. You qualify for a good discount on both, but at the price the glock LE deal is, I find that hard to beat with 3 mags.

 

[CZ57]

I've had a number of Glocks. I own 0 now but I do have an XDm in .45 ACP. Not only would I rate it more accurate than a Glock 21, Which I have shot, I would gladly compare it to some pistols costing nearly twice the price as in the H&K .45. I like a polymer double-stack because the larger grip fits my large hands better and I use the #2 backstrap. With the #1 backstrap it is a very trim grip for a .45 ACP.

XD/XDm bashers seemed to be scared that the XD/XDm is going to steal their thunder. Try one before you decide and remember that this site is probably only second to Glock Forum when it comes to fanboys.

As far as higher velocity claims for polygonal bores, show me the proof and I'll show you the proof that the Match Grade barrel of the XDm is superior in accuracy.

 

[AZ Hawkeye]

I've had a number of Glocks. I own 0 now but I do have an XDm in .45 ACP. Not only would I rate it more accurate than a Glock 21, Which I have shot, I would gladly compare it to some pistols costing nearly twice the price as in the H&K .45. I like a polymer double-stack because the larger grip fits my large hands better and I use the #2 backstrap. With the #1 backstrap it is a very trim grip for a .45 ACP.

XD/XDm bashers seemed to be scared that the XD/XDm is going to steal their thunder. Try one before you decide and remember that this site is probably only second to Glock Forum when it comes to fanboys.

As far as higher velocity claims for polygonal bores, show me the proof and I'll show you the proof that the Match Grade barrel of the XDm is superior in accuracy.

There are actual reasons as to why an XD can be better for another than a Glock and vice versa. "Stealing 'our' thunder," isn't one of them. The M&P already stole the thunder the XD and XDm may have been gaining.

FWIW, on nearly all firearm forums that aren't brand/type specific, 1911's and Glocks are almost always the two most popular types of firearms.

P.S. I'd actually give an XDm a look if any federal agency even tried to test one. Not carry them as their duty pistol, simply tested them. Usually it's a SIG vs a Glock vs an M&P and maybe an HK. There must be some reason for this...

 

[MrSpiffy]

I've only handled one Glock, and disliked it as soon as I picked it up. It felt too plastic-y and lacked the texture I felt I needed to really grip it well. I shot the XD 9mm and loved it. It fit my hand very well, and felt great when I shot it. The grip was more textured, giving me the feeling that I had a better hold on the gun. The XDm that I ended up purchasing also comes with three different backstraps for different hand sizes.

But as everyone else has been saying, it all comes down to what you like. Handle both. Shoot both. See what you like. Only you can make that decision. Both are great guns, and very reliable. I've never had a failure of any kind with my XDm, yet. But even then, guns are like cars: every manufacturer makes a lemon or two from time to time. So, again, just shoot them both and pick whichever one you like best.

 

[CZ57]

There are actual reasons as to why an XD can be better for another than a Glock and vice versa.

1. Nobody equals Glock in the Ka-Boom department/poor chamber support.

2. Polygonal rifling only serves to prevent the use of cast lead loads.

3. Glocks do not have relieved ejection ports and empty cases being ejected are first met by the slide.

4. Be thankful that the XD is around, otherwise Gaston would be charging you $150 more for his tupperware.

 

[1stmarine]

I don't like the texture of the gen1 and 2 neither but this has changed a long time ago.
Fyi...
The glock rough texture but it is being discontinued for the civilian market.
What you call plastic is glass filled polymer that is several times stronger and lighter than steel. It is not to save money! LOL!

Gen3 rough texture vs Gen4 texture


Gen3 rough texture. The "glue" grip.

 

[1stmarine]

The rough texture in 9mm here above....
What is the real difference with the Gen4 texture? you have to hold one to know. It literally glues to your hand. Imagine a grip
that is made of skateboard tape but it is not tape. Something like that. Some folks find it a bit aggressive ... my point with defensive systems and also pistols is...

are not supposed to be pretty or comfortable but effective and comforting.

 

[RinkRat]

I too was looking at the XD, Glock, and the M&P's for a compact 9mm.

The XD & M&P felt slimier which is no secret. I didn't care for the XD's satiety grip, and the M&P comes with or without the safeties. The Glock is like holding a block and there are those who'd rather use a sharp stick but I like the feel of having a big-grip in my hand YMMV ...

Glocks have a plethora of after market products, they ARE very reliable, handle any ammo you care to use < you can roll cow turds into a ball - cram it into the chamber, and it would most-likely fire it > and I would feel confident that I can 99.9999999% be-sure it will go ka-boom upon trigger pull.

Say what y'all will but Blocks are user more then friendly, reliable, and there are more after market accessories then you could ever use. And they don't mind being mistreated, heck they might even prefer too be!!

I got the gen-3 g26 and I'm happy, it's a bit smaller then the XD & M&P and you can always use other higher capacity mags and make it bigger or add a mag extender too, I don't have a problem pocket carry in 90% of my shorts and in a-boot 48% of my pants, and if not in the pocket I have 3 IWB holsters that I can carry it 100% of the time with YMMV ... so pour yourself a cup a kool-aid and drink up you will not be disappointed ... once again YMMV maybe a lot.

 

[AZ Hawkeye]

1. Nobody equals Glock in the Ka-Boom department/poor chamber support.

2. Polygonal rifling only serves to prevent the use of cast lead loads.

3. Glocks do not have relieved ejection ports and empty cases being ejected are first met by the slide.

4. Be thankful that the XD is around, otherwise Gaston would be charging you $150 more for his tupperware.

1) In Gen's 1 and 2, sure. In Gen's 3 and 4, no, not at all.

2) Why would I want a cast lead load?

3) And...?

4) I didn't say XD/XDm models should go away, I'm simply stating that according to the opinions expressed by ALL federal agencies (there are a whole lot of them) who generally don't reflex purchase based on lowest cost as state and local agencies tend to do, that Glock, SIG, HK and S&W are all superior to Springfield.

That is all.

 

[1stmarine]

-Do not shoot lead. Warranty is over.. or get appropriate barrel for that.
-Gen1 and Gen2 with old wear out barrels? Get a lone wolf barrel $99 and done.
-Did some glocks have problems. WEll after 2.6 million sold I am pretty sure some did. - Did some AK-47 have some problems?... I am pretty sure someone somewhere,... hummm?

My friend Jimmy called me the other day to tell me HE FINALLY GOT A JAM in his glock and it was that he had put a 9mm round in the Glock 23 mag by mistake.
He never cleaned the gun for 3 years shooting weekly IDPA and keeps chugging.
He is a very busy man so he just wipes the pistol and that's it. He is going to leave it this one to see when it stops the first time as a curiosity item.
I tell him. you filthy pig. clean your stuff.
I will keep you posted. Who knows it might happen before we get into the nursing home. LOL!

 

[ranburr]

I have both. They both go boom. No issues with either platform after literally tens of thousands of rounds.

 

[miles1]

XD or Glock?Your gonna get the CZ fanboys awfull jealous there gun wasnt mentioned

Both are great guns.I went with Glock with No regrets.

 

[Mudinyeri]

1) ... I'm simply stating that according to the opinions expressed by ALL federal agencies ... who generally don't reflex purchase based on lowest cost ....

Federal agencies don't purchase based on lowest cost? Have you ever sold anything (or tired to) to the Federal Government? :banghead:

Why was it the Beretta was chosen over the SIG in the XM9 trials again?

Moderators, I don't know about you, but I'm really not seeing much value in this thread. It's the same old brand love/hate as virtually 100% of the similar threads before it.

 

[Sam1911]

it all comes down to what you like. Handle both. Shoot both. See what you like. Only you can make that decision. Both are great guns, and very reliable.

Good enough answer for now.