All great guns. If I had to rate them in an order I'd say Colt, Smith, then ruger. I've handled all three, but only shot the SRH. SRH would be fine and get any job done, but I think it is ugly as sin. The Colt is beautiful, but given the price, no thanks...... though I'd love to have one. All said, I'd probably buy the Smith. Nice balance of practicality, looks, and price.