best powder for 45acp?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Op, lol are you overwhelmed yet. Seems like maybe you could load 45 with common dirt and it would work fine.

Nope, coated bullets are not powder sensitive and imo do not matter in 45. You are not trying for max loads.

Pick you a powder that you have available and have fun.
 
I did shoot kegs of W231 with a 230 FMJ. My standard load was 5.5 grains which was just at 800 fps.

But, I decided to go with the old standby. The original 1910 rounds, the ones used in the development testing between the Savage and the M1910 (the pre thumb safety 1911)

picture from Sam Laker’s ColtAutos.com
1910_5.jpg

was a 230 FMJ with 5.0 grains Bullseye. and the desired velocity was 800 fps.

Examining old boxes, that was the way back then velocity

O6DXP9i.jpg


and for "Hardball" match ammunition, that was the velocity when the 1911 was the issue pistol.

YES8Hfu.jpg

izlNWG0.jpg

I am going to claim, that if your semi auto 45 ACP does not function with a 230 FMJ and 5.0 grains Bullseye powder, there is something wrong with the gun. And, this load is still a load that 1911 shooters use, or used, when they shot hardball matches. Titegroup is also an excellent powder in the 1911, a lot of Bullseye pistol shooters walked to Titegroup when Bullseye Pistol powder was unavailable. Powder charges are so close to be indistinguishable. What I like about these faster powders is, they give the slide a quick, hard kick, and then the pressure drops rapidly. I had one Colt 1911 frame peen out, due to poor fitting of the barrel lugs and slide stop. Only learned why the Colt opened so violently after reading this post

Old School Barrel Fit vs Modern Fit
https://www.bullseyeforum.net/t18500-old-school-barrel-fit-vs-modern-fit

However what I did learn, it is undesirable to accelerate the slide too fast. Of course it is undesirable to accelerate the slide too slowly. The load the 1911 was developed to use, accelerates the slide to the correct speed, and that means a gun that does not function with this load, there is something is wrong with the gun.

This is a load that was successfully used in two World Wars and a bunch of bush wars, and it is hard to make a realistic claim that there is a better.
 
Last edited:
I use mostly W231/HP-38 in the 45 ACP and most other handgun cartridges too. The classic load of W231 is 5.5gr under a 230gr bullet. That is very accurate for me. There are at least a dozen or more good powders for this fairly low pressure cartridge.

Use data at your own risk and always check data you see on the NET for yourself.
 
I've loaded .45ACP with HP-38, WST, N310, and Clays. I use the first two in semi-autos and the last two in revolvers. For Semi-autos, I like a 200gr SWC while for revolvers I lean toward a 230gr RN ( more reliable reloads)

Be aware that HP-38/WW231 is temperature sensitive and WST is reverse sensitive
 
So the powder with the most blast and flash for sd?????
My favorite!! You don't have to like it. Oh... you're under the impression that during a fight you'll be totally blinded by a flash. Maybe I already have a 700+ lumen tac light. Oh... but the flash will give my position away... is that another "what if"?
 
Last edited:
So many good suggestions above. I didn’t see Nitro 100 listed. It’s the most accurate 45 powder I ever used, but be careful as it doesn’t take much!
 
Clays. Why does everyone forget Clays? And Universal! Just about any fast to medium pistol powder for mid range .45 loads will work. Pick one and have fun! Good luck.
 
I haven't seen 800 x on the list. I used to find it on the shelf at the store all the time. For cheap. And would pick up a bottle of it quite often. Very good for 45, 9 mm and even light cast bullet .357 loads.
 
1A5796FB-5CDA-49B2-822A-020D94DD4E90.jpeg


HS-6 worked on this occasion. I need to do more testing but I’ll call 230gr Speer CPRN over 7.2gr HS-6 an accurate load in my gun. Slow and soft at 682fps.
 
I think the only pistol powder I haven't tried in .45ACP is FFFg. I half suspect a 35gr. load under a 230gr. lead bullet and over-powder wad would work - and with a good lubricant on the bullet wouldn't foul too badly. I'll have to try that someday but, in the meantime, Bullseye, Red Dot and W231 work fine.
 
i realize my question is broad and maybe no simple answer...

thanks to generous help from great guys on this board, i'm inching along towards reloading. there aren't any primers that i can find in my area, so i'll have to order some. i do see gun powder in most shops i go into, but i don't know anything about them.

all the ammo i've fired in 45 acp has been 230 grain. my goal starting out is to make a round that's as close to the armscore i've been using - nothing fancy or especially powerful, just a middle of the road dependable round.

so this was your goal, what powder would you use? also, the bullets i have are coated, does this make any difference in type of powder used?

and i wish a Merry Christmas to all!

I read through the thread and I didn't see anywhere where you mentioned how your planning to load? Auto powder measure, or scale and measuring each charge should play a major role in your decision. From a powder measure perspective, there is a huge disparity, and not all powders are equal. If you are going to use a scale, then all these suggestion you've gotten are fine, but if you are going to use a progressive with a volumetric powder measure, then I'd suggest adding that in "What is that best metering and performing 45 ACP powder using a Brand X Powder Measure". Just my .02. May only be worth .01 (Thanks Brandon) today, but there it is.
 
What ever is in stock.
Not sarcasm - truth.

I’ve used Unique, 231, HP38, Red Dot, Green Dot, Power Pistol, Titegroup, 700x, Bullseye, and so on. All can provide serviceable 45ACP reloads for most needs. I’m currently burning through my last five pounds of 700x on my 230gr blammo ammo (generic range fodder) as we speak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top