RevGeo
Member
I guess I don't understand why anyone would be concerned with what somebody else shoots. As long as someone's gun is legal for the game they are after it's their business, in my opinion.
I was raised by a gun nut - they called them 'cranks' back then - and I grew up shooting many, many different guns in many different chamberings because the old man was constantly buying, selling and trading guns with the other cranks he knew and shot with. I've shot and seen shot a lot of animals, large and small. I am no expert but my opinion is that any rifle chambering considered a 'big game' round shows pretty much the same results from a well placed bullet. Poor performance is the fault of the shooter, generally, not the rifle or round.
Hunting is a sport for the vast majority of us. If we were totally dependent on animals we killed we would probably be raising them as livestock or using deadfalls, tiger traps, booby traps, deer drives with our neighbors etc.
Nowadays I hunt big game with a 30-40AI built on a single shot 98 Mauser action that I inherited from my old man, the gun crank. Ballistically it's pretty much a 30-06 but I can load it down to 300 Sav or standard 30-40 speeds. I have to be careful with my shot placement (as do all single shot hunters) and have turned down shots at animals due to range limitations, poor shot angle and pure gut feelings that the shot would not be right. Anybody who hunts or has hunted with a muzzle loader knows what I'm talking about.
Since I am practicing my sport as I see fit I have little problem tuning down a shot and so I don't see a need for a .375H&H to drive a 270gr bullet into the vitals of an elk from any angle, personally.
BUT - If somebody else wants to hunt that way and wants to shoot whatever gun they choose then I'm all like 'Cool!' Same thing if some guy wants to sit in a tree like a bowhunter and pop his deer with a handgun at 20 feet.
Buy whatever the hell you want and have fun shooting it. This is supposed to be about fun. If practicality were that much a part of it I probably wouldn't do it. Cartridges and calibers don't make bad shots. The guy pulling the trigger does.
I was raised by a gun nut - they called them 'cranks' back then - and I grew up shooting many, many different guns in many different chamberings because the old man was constantly buying, selling and trading guns with the other cranks he knew and shot with. I've shot and seen shot a lot of animals, large and small. I am no expert but my opinion is that any rifle chambering considered a 'big game' round shows pretty much the same results from a well placed bullet. Poor performance is the fault of the shooter, generally, not the rifle or round.
Hunting is a sport for the vast majority of us. If we were totally dependent on animals we killed we would probably be raising them as livestock or using deadfalls, tiger traps, booby traps, deer drives with our neighbors etc.
Nowadays I hunt big game with a 30-40AI built on a single shot 98 Mauser action that I inherited from my old man, the gun crank. Ballistically it's pretty much a 30-06 but I can load it down to 300 Sav or standard 30-40 speeds. I have to be careful with my shot placement (as do all single shot hunters) and have turned down shots at animals due to range limitations, poor shot angle and pure gut feelings that the shot would not be right. Anybody who hunts or has hunted with a muzzle loader knows what I'm talking about.
Since I am practicing my sport as I see fit I have little problem tuning down a shot and so I don't see a need for a .375H&H to drive a 270gr bullet into the vitals of an elk from any angle, personally.
BUT - If somebody else wants to hunt that way and wants to shoot whatever gun they choose then I'm all like 'Cool!' Same thing if some guy wants to sit in a tree like a bowhunter and pop his deer with a handgun at 20 feet.
Buy whatever the hell you want and have fun shooting it. This is supposed to be about fun. If practicality were that much a part of it I probably wouldn't do it. Cartridges and calibers don't make bad shots. The guy pulling the trigger does.