Best Tomahawk?

Status
Not open for further replies.
A tac hawk has a spike, which can be used piercing, but it won't hammer, and you have to pay attention on the back stroke, just the same as hammering with the butt of a knife.
Most "tactical hawks" are spiked, but I know at least CRKT makes their's in both a spiked and hammer pol version (see below)

The CRKT would probably be the best of the bunch for putting holes in sheet metal and the like due to the edge geometry (the m48 spike looks as if it would dull quickly with a 4-way grind), but the m48 is the only one with a sharpened beard, which is pretty useful for large game.
Actually, it you look closely the CRKT has both a sharpened beard and a sharpened top edge, too. If I had an actual need for a "tactical hawk" I would look seriously at the CRKT Kangee or Chogan .

crkt_2720.jpg

So as not to sound like a total CRKT fanboy, I'll say that for a general purpose outdoor tool, I would pick a Cold Steel Trail Hawk (which is currently hanging from my daypack, actually). It's relatively light, inexpensive and durable. Its not my first choice for major wood processing, but for occasional light chopping and splitting it works fine once you put a good edge on it.
 
A large chopping knife in tropical regions, yes. In Europe, once the fields were cleared, they used sickles and scythes. Not long straight blades - those were considered at best short swords and reserved for nobility.

I don't think we are disagreeing on the fact that agricultural workers use blades, more the interpretation of their working shape. Since Europe was much more a feudal or fief culture with an elite heirarchy, the design of their edged tools was quickly governed by their status in life. Peons working the land didn't carry long blade for crops, if anything, the temperate climate meant they had much less need for them than those working in more tropical climes. The difference is that in temperate zones, you have vegetation that must withstand the extremes of subfreezing temperatures in winter, or comparatively harsh dry summers. The plants that survive and thrive on that are much more woody and fibrous. You wind up have more heavy stems, stick, and trees, not plants that much constantly be cut back regularly to prevent their invasion.

Hawks, hatchets, and axes are more prevalent in temperate zones, long blades - machetes, parangs, bolos, kukris common in tropical areas. That is why the American Indian adopted the hawk to a larger degree than a 30" long blade. It was a temperate clime export to a temperate clime indigeneous people. The Europeans didn't ship over swords, they considered them war blades. They sent axes, hawks, and trade knives up to 8" - 10"

You don't find depictions of farm workers in Europe or American Indians with long machete like blades. Those are tropical use blades largely restricted to central America, Africa, SE Asia or the Pacific Rim. They have become highly popular in modern American culture, but it's only been recently as we attempt to push back against our largely urbanized existence. What really happened in America's more primitive time is accurately documented in writings and pictures - the tomahawk is much more prevalent.
Hi Tirod,

The "corn knife" has been around roughly forever and still available if you have a need for one enough to look. I use one to cut willow saplings off the Iroquois river when I need to re-cane the antique kitchen chairs.

Corn Knife
 
I've got a SOG tactical tomahawk (black) and a Cold Steel Norse hawk. I prefer the Norse hawk.

The 'Viet Nam' hawks with the spikes like the SOG don't suit my needs for a nice hand axe. The Norse hawk blade is nice and wide. Just my $0.02
 

The SOG and Cold Steel definitely are popular, the Kangee is fairly new and definitely more expensive. The UC is an inexpensive offshore product, the usual caution there is advised - you get what you pay for.

However, the OP hasn't responded to the question of how it will be used. If I got the thread off track, my bad. Knowing the specific intent of use is important, tho. One difficulty I have is reading too much into a question that is phrased, "What's the best?" It implies we all accept the exact same standards to measure the tool by. In reality, there are numerous contradictory standards and no one tool can do it all. Compromises have to be introduced, there is no winner take all.

The angle of the edge, the weight of the tool, the handle length, method of securing the head to the handle, what other feature might be on the other side and it's emphasis, what kind of grip, it's texture, and even it's circumference all make differences that add up, tilting the usefulness of each product toward one side or the other. It's entirely why we have different tools - saying "which hammer is the best?" means comparing a framing hammer vs cabinet makers vs ball peen vs hand sledge. They all hammer, none does much good outside it's specific intent.

Without knowing the specific tasks the tool is being used for, we can't say which might be better for the job. I think that is one thing most of us can agree on - there is rarely a tool that is "best," but there are tools that are better for doing certain things, and if the OP is being sincere, then those tasks need to be specified in detail.
 
OfficersWife,

That's very interesting. I found this when I searched.

That is what this started out life as:
attachment.php



It is my 7 year olds and he didn't want the grip perfectly finished. He is funny about stuff sometimes.
Note how he engraved an eye for accuracy and teeth for sharpness. :D



Locally tobacco cutters are about a 50/50 split between big honkin' knives of various types with a strong preference for a squared tip and the task specific long handled tobacco knife.
1452Bt.AuSt.79.jpg
 

Attachments

  • DSC07238.jpg
    DSC07238.jpg
    186.6 KB · Views: 273
On a related note, I've got a couple of those TSC eastern pattern sickles. Sold has "Hand sickle" IIRC.
Thoroughly decent tools.

With 18" machete for scale:
attachment.php


1/8" thick SK-5.
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • DSC07241.jpg
    DSC07241.jpg
    113.7 KB · Views: 267
  • DSC07239.jpg
    DSC07239.jpg
    200.3 KB · Views: 268
Tomahawk.

I have about eight or so tomahawks. The only one with a hammer poll is the Trail Hawk, nice for woods cruising. The others are all used for throwing and are smaller and lighter. The largest of that bunch is a Cold Steel Frontier Hawk. It is a good thrower though I found the handle a bit too long and cut it back to 20 inches....may bob it a bit more yet. It is the heaviest of the bunch, most of which come from Track of the Wolf and are specifically for throwing.
I did remove the little set screw from the Frontier hawk and refitted the handle. Having a screw kinda defeats the purpose of the "cone/friction fit" common in throwing hawks. You want the handle to pop out if it hits badly.
Curious about the earlier Estwing comments....does Estwing make a tomahawk?
Pete
 
Okay, tomahawk originally meant war club. It had become synonymous with "hatchet" by the American Revolution.

John
 
In any case, it is a worth with interesting etymology.

tomahawk (n.)
1610s, tamahaac, from Algonquian (probably Powhatan) tamahack "what is used in cutting," from tamaham "he cuts." Cognate with Mohegan tummahegan, Delaware tamoihecan, Micmac tumeegun.
http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=tomahawk&searchmode=none

From an Algonquian (most likely Powhatan) word. Compare Malecite-Passamaquoddy tomhikon (“ax”), Abenaki temahigan, demahigan (“ax”).
Noun
http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tomahawk


Edit: and a quick article from JSTOR on the origin of the term and its usage:

http://www.jstor.org/stable/659577
 
I don't feel like re-doing my own research, done for the review of Troy's hawk.

But here's my footnote: Conlin Taylor, Native American Weapons, (London: University of Oklahoma Press, 2001), 16-30.

John
 
'hawk talk

Well, here's mine. it's lasted this long, that's all I can really say but it did help us chop our way out of a micro downburst that struck our campsite in FL, once upon a time. It is nice to have one when the need arises, that's for sure...
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    118.6 KB · Views: 62
Here is mine. Not into the "tacticool" thing. It is a shrew hawk, a bit smaller than most but very light and handy. Very sharp and the hammer poll is handy to have around camp and in the woods. I have added a paracord wrap to the bottom 1/3 of the handle for better grip and comfort, no pics of that though.

Specs and info here.
http://shrewbows.com/shrewhawk/

IMG_5295.jpg

IMG_5294.jpg

IMG_5293.jpg
 
Okay, tomahawk originally meant war club. It had become synonymous with "hatchet" by the American Revolution.

Didn't a lot of styles of war "club" have stone blades on them?
 
Yes. After enough hatchets became available, the old war clubs became increasingly rare.
 
I don't have much use for a hawk with a spike on it, in fact I've never found much use for one at all. If I was to get one it wouldn't have a spike on the end to gouge a hole in my skull. I won't be fighting with one, thats for sure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top