which one?

Neither would be my cup of tea, but being the curmudgeon I am the Beretta would get the nod. Great experiences with several of their handguns over the years, versus none with Charter.

I have neither. I'd go with the Charter, because I'm oldscool, because of what I've heard of their customer service, because they're American made and because the Nano is too glock-icky.

old fart

I had an older Charter Arms Undercover and was not overly impressed with it's overall fit and finish. Looked at a Beretta Nano and a Kahr CM9. Thought they were both well built guns and went with the CM9 because it had a nicer trigger and felt better in my hand than the Nano. Between the two choices I would go with the Beretta Nano.

I am familiar with SA, DA only and DA/SA, striker fire action would take some getting used to for me.

How many 9mm semi-autos do you have? The revolver interests me more because I have enough semi-autos for the moment.

I don’t own either of them. But l do own a different Beretta that I purchased used. When it malfunctioned, I contacted Beretta and was informed that they only warrant their guns for one year for the original (New) purchaser. After that you’re on your own. I don’t know about Charter.

I bought a Charter Arms Undercover - sadly it was during their worst days.
BUT - I sent it in for service in 2014 & they went waaayyyy beyond.
It's like a new gun (same serial so it's my old one).
I lost the cylinder release spring & plunger - they sent a new one.
Lost that one too! I called 'em & they were happy to have it returned (on my dime)
But they replaced not only the parts I needed, but they said the crane internals were rough.
So they replaced the entire crane assembly.
Returned it to me via FedEx on their dime.

Accuracy is dang good from a 2" barrel.

If the Charter is of recent vintage (and should be if it's a 9mm)
I'd go with that.
Yes I'm old school - but we learned to count, add, subtract, multiply & divide w/o a calculator.
We did it in our heads

Nano.

If they're both 9mm, I'd get the Beretta. I'm a believer in semi-auto cartridges in semi-auto's and revolver cartridges in revolvers.

While 9mm revolvers are sort of a "cult fad", generally speaking they're harder to sell if you want to. That's why manufacturers don't make many of them.

Neither. For the same money you can get a Bersa 9mm which is a good gun for the cost. Are you going to carry this gun as a concealed carry?

congrats but didnt you ask about this same charter vs nano back in june?
glad you got what ya wanted either way
gene

Personality.... neither. I'd save my money and get something better.

Deaf