Please recommend a 9mm pistol . thanks.

Status
Not open for further replies.

efeng9622

Member
Joined
May 14, 2005
Messages
460
Location
Maryland, USA
I am going to concern S & W M & P shield 9mm but actually I don’t like DOA gun because the trigger is too heavy , is it said that shield 9mm’s trigger is 12-15 lbs ? If someone can recommend a 9mm pistol with Single/double action, the price is not greater than $350 will be appreciated. Please tell me your opinion about shield 9mm.or it's trigger safety.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
The trigger on a shield is not 12lbs.
It might be half that. I recommend you try one. They are fine guns. I don't own one but have taught lots of people on them and have fired them quite a few times.

I don't think you are going to find a DA/SA for $350.

IDK but I think the closest would be something from CZ.
Like the Rami or a 75 compact (PCR). Also good guns.

Remember that the DA on a DA/SA is usually between 8-10 lbs of pull with the SA around 4-5 lbs.

ETA: Is this for concealed carry or just a general pistol?
I assumed concealed carry because you mentioned the Shield.
 
My shield was about 8 lbs but had a very pronounced wall that would jerk the front sight off target no matter how careful I was. Apex trigger sorted it.

Your price range you'll have to look at Turkish or Slavic pistols probably, many of which are excellent. Or something like a Makarov or Polish variant. Not 9mm though. Bersa might make a DA/SA 9mm variant for close to $350... check them out also.
 
Tanfoglio Witness P 9mm. It's an Italian CZ75B clone. It's DA/SA with a thumb safety. Decent DA trigger, Great SA trigger (4ish pounds), light weight (Polymer frame), controllable recoil, and comfortable grip. Easy to field strip (no tools) and clean You can probably get one new for under $300 easily. They also sell a 22 cal conversion kit for it as well.
 
shield 9mm is about 500 grams weight, is it too light " that would jerk the front sight off target "? if I buy it , I will concern concealed carry. how about S &W 915 9mm ?
 
Last edited:
shield 9mm is about 500 grams weight, is it too light " that would jerk the front sight off target "? if I buy it , I will concern concealed carry. how about S &W 915 9mm ?
Weight of the gun does not move the front sight.

The weight of the gun really only effects felt recoil.
If you hold still and press the trigger straight to the rear with the sights aligned, it will hit its target.

It could be a 454 Casull derringer. Hold still, press trigger, BOOM, hit.
 
I love CZs, but they wouldn't fit your price point if you are only looking for new. At $299, I recommend a Ruger LC9s.

If you have the opportunity, I encourage you to shoot the 3-5 guns that make your "final list" at a local range before buying- many/most indoor ranges with a gun shop attached to them will have rentals available for a reasonable price... IMO that cost is well worth the opportunity to try them out before you "pull the trigger" on your new purchase.
 
shield 9mm is about 500 grams weight, is it too light " that would jerk the front sight off target "? if I buy it , I will concern concealed carry. how about S &W 915 9mm ?
Shield is one of the larger carry 9s and is quite shootable particularly with the 8 round mag inserted. The trigger geometry wasn't favorable for me but others love it. Mine has a thumb safety but I never use it as it's almost impossible to flip on or off quickly.
 
Apparently Smith Shield triggers vary a lot. Reported at 10 pounds and mushy. Claimed to be 6.5 lbs. out of the factory. Factory triggers are irrelevant anyway. They all need work. Anyway, you need to decide on a budget then go try a bunch on for size. It has to fit your hand first.
"...price is not greater than $350..." Cabela's has 'em on sale at that right now. Doesn't matter if the thing doesn't fit you hand though. Too small might be fixable with a change of grips. Apex triggers supposedly give a 5 to 5.5 pound pull too.
 
Just a friendly reminder, that the S&W Shield is a single action only gun... The heavy trigger pull comes from the positive angle on the sear's engagement edge that is pushing the striker slightly to the back when disengaging. APEX sears have neutral angle on that edge, so the striker gets pushed less to the back thus resulting in better trigger pull, but it's not so shock resistant (read drop safe) as the stock sear.
 
I mean, the problem with your request is that its a very narrow field on account of the single action part. Look, if you don't like the Shield you don't like it, but reading what you said my impression is that you are worried about nothing. Also, the Shield is striker fired, not double action. You run a few rounds through it, you will quickly get used to the trigger. Don't fall for this persnickety trigger crap that we gun people love to bemoan. You can shoot anything well with a relatively small amount of practice. Of course a great trigger is nice and it helps, but a lot of the stuff you read on trigger issues is either people choosing to be trigger snobs or outright BS.
 
...but a lot of the stuff you read on trigger issues is either people choosing to be trigger snobs or outright BS...
This. My thoughts exactly. Trigger reach and overall fit of the gun are far more important. And that trigger pull WILL get lighter and smoother after several range trips.
 
Pity you budget is so low. If you could afford it I would go HK VP9 or Walther PPQ hands down
 
I am going to concern S & W M & P shield 9mm but actually I don’t like DOA gun because the trigger is too heavy , is it said that shield 9mm’s trigger is 12-15 lbs ? If someone can recommend a 9mm pistol with Single/double action, the price is not greater than $350 will be appreciated. Please tell me your opinion about shield 9mm.or it's trigger safety.

Thanks.

For pistol with hammer I would go with the Grand Power from Slovakia. Used ones in excellent condition cost $300 around here. I do not think you can beat that.
 
Whatever your budget allows.I CCW a S&W Shield 45acp and am currently testing a Century Arms Canik TP9 SF elite.Got 300 rounds through it and its fantastik.200 more without problems and it can join the CCW battery rotation.
 
I have a 9x19 Shield and like it. I did replace the trigger with an Apex Tactical unit. Besides improving the trigger, you can get rid of the two piece, articulating trigger and replace it with one with a safety blade in the middle of the trigger. A much better trigger safety device than the S&W trigger in my opinion.
 
I am going to concern S & W M & P shield 9mm but actually I don’t like DOA gun because the trigger is too heavy , is it said that shield 9mm’s trigger is 12-15 lbs ? If someone can recommend a 9mm pistol with Single/double action, the price is not greater than $350 will be appreciated. Please tell me your opinion about shield 9mm.or it's trigger safety.

I always think it's better starting with a purpose/problem and then looking for a solution. I don't really believe in "general purpose" guns anymore, so it would really be a bit of help to know what you want the firearm for in the first place.

That said, I just added a S&W M&P Shield 9mm to my collection about a month ago. I just finished putting about 250 rounds through it yesterday. With the rebate program (I think it just ended, but it's worth checking) it cost me under 300$, I believe. It's an excellent bigger-than-pocket-gun,-smaller-than-9mm-double-stack gun. I basically purchased it for concealed carry when I want something bigger than my LCP but thinner than my Ruger SR9C. And as that, it's great. Trigger is average, in the positive sense. No better or worse than you would come to expect in a cheap, small gun.

I think other manufacturers have done a better execution of the trigger safety, and until you wear off the sharp edge on it from use it's a bit annoying to get used to depending on how you press the trigger. But it isn't anything you'd notice during actual trigger time at the range. Unlike the LCP, it's a pleasant pistol to shoot. It's a bit jumpy but not unmanageable. Sight radius does affect accuracy, but nonetheless it's enjoyable. In other words, perfectly useable and good for a cheap, small gun.

Size wise it's great. It's small enough to pocket carry in larger cargo pants, and large enough to comfortably and securely carry it IWB in a Remora holster. It's very thin, which is why I bought it and I wasn't let down. Weight wise is what you'd expect, not really very decisive for me. I also liked that the slide is stainless which is great for reduced maintenance in rust-prone Florida.

Apparently Smith Shield triggers vary a lot

I was pending measuring it anyway after breaking in, so I might as well do it now. The trigger pull on my shield is: 7.5, 6.5, 7, 7.1, 6.6 (lb) for an average of 6.94 lb using a Wheeler Trigger Pull Scale. It's a bit hard to measure while tripping the trigger safety so I'd imagine that's the upper limit of what an actual finger would need to exert.

Hope the input was helpful. And if it wasn't clear by now, I'm perfectly happy with Shield 9mm. Only wish I had bought it sooner. But I would probably be saying the same thing had I bought an LC9 so take it however you will. Most any popular firearm within your budget from a reputable manufacturer will leave you satisfied these days if you don't have stringent expectations.
 
Last edited:
If you're willing to spend another $100 the gun you are looking for us the fairly new Springfield XDe. It's the first XD that is hammer fired and it sports a single stack magazine which makes carry more comfortable. It seems to be what you are looking for.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top