AlexanderA
Member
Carbines are "viable," but there are better choices today. And there is no cost advantage either, seeing what collectible Carbines are going for.
I almost feel like there is an opportunity there for Ruger to start making them. I bet they’d be more popular than the mini14/30
Yup - an excellent argument for a real rifle round. The M1 carbine is more expensive, less reliable, and less effective than the obvious alternatives. Maybe in some world that's "viable" but I'll pass.with the rising popularity of body armor, the .30 carbine along with most pcc's became obsolete, imo.
I bet they’d be more popular than the mini14/30
Well considering the Fulton match grade Carbines have a 3 MOA guarantee that might be an upgrade.If it had the lackluster accuracy of the mini 14/30?
Well considering the Fulton match grade Carbines have a 3 MOA guarantee that might be an upgrade.
Ultimak makes a rail for them that would allow a light and a red dot. That would bring them a bit more current.The only issue I'd have with using one for HD is a suitable white light mounting system, and finding the right ammo to reduce possible over penetration. I've seen what .30 FMJ can do to AR500 tgts (unfortunately) and I'm pretty sure even soft-point ammo is going to go through some dry-wall when compared to 5.56 in a suitable HD loading.
Other than that, they generally run well enough, and the cartridge is effective.
While the 327 Magnum has more power than 30 carbine, the 30 carbine is a rimless cartridge and the 327 is rimmed. The 327, like any rimmed cartridge, will introduce some feeding issues when fed from a magazine.
Be interesting if someone in the aftermarket could make a light mount that fits the bayonet mounts for carbines that have them.They are great guns. The only reservation I have is that it is harder to mount a light to one. I know it can be done with aftermarket stocks.
My dad was issued a carbine as part of a mortar crew in Korea. He had nothing good to say about them and I got the impression his opinion was based on firsthand experience.
M1 Carbine fires a 110 grain FMJ bullet at 1900FPS for an impact energy of 965 ft-lb
The 327 Federal Magnum launches a 115 grain Gold Dot at 1880FPS.
I see two advantages to a pistol caliber carbine (really the M1 Carbine is a stretch but a pistol caliber, sort of) in 327Federal Magnum has a better assortment of bullet weights and a manually operated carbine (lever or pump) for use in places that have a problem with "military grade weapons".
Now if the fine folks at Strum-Ruger would chamber a semi-auto carbine in 327Federal Magnum all the bases would get covered.
Just the ammo is likely worth 70-75¢ per round.what this is worth.