556 trimming question + need advice

Status
Not open for further replies.

JD Fla1

Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
99
Still a newb -
looking for feedback- please -
I had 600 nickel cases of .556 range brass, 90% FC marked, 10% LC marked, all have crimped pockets, gifted to me.
All cleaned up beautifully with my wet tumbler.
I'm trimming them down to 1.7495.with the Wilson lathe trimmer. and yes, nickle trims a little tougher than brass
75% of them all trimmed to either .7495 or .750
25% of the batch too are short for the trimmer, I guess the factory produced them short.
What could I do with the shorter stuff, they measure at .743 to .748 ?
I believe I can trim them to .743 and keep them all together and they'll be all fine, according to the "internet"
I would be putting a real small crimp to the cases, so keeping sizes segregated is the proper procedure, I assume.
I'm looking to keep these nickel cases for use in decent accuracy, not LRPrecision, I'm not advanced enough, and my pockets are not bottomless -
I use a mighty armory decapper and TNT Gold sizer, Redding competition seater, Lee FCD.
have 68-77 gr. hornady's, smk's, (maybe even try an eld bullet)
other - any consideration in cannelure bullets vs. plain
powder choices- varget, cfe223, blc2, A2230, A2520, and a few more-
figuring to start at mid loads, then work up .2 or .3 up - using Lee, Hornady manuals,and Hodgin's online for load info and coal. I have no chrono at this point -
shooting out of decent AR rifle barrels.
 
I'm trimming them down to 1.7495.with the Wilson lathe trimmer.
That's an impressive trimmer, achieving 5 ten-thousandths repeatedly. You're in a temperature controlled metrology laboratory right?

What could I do with the shorter stuff, they measure at .743 to .748? . . . shooting out of decent AR rifle barrels.
I'd suggest you go shoot. You're wasting time chasing variation that's meaningless for your application.

Once you're below 1 MOA, and pushing for 0.5 MOA, you might want to do a study to see if short vs long brass is detectable on target; I'll cheat and tell you that it is not detectable at that level.

Work on bullet quality and powder selection, and then go practice.
 
Can you let us know what rifle platform you are using? Also the load data, powder and bullet.
 
The shorter stuff is good to go, as long as there is enough neck to seat and crimp why even mess with it? I mean if you're going for bench rest competition brass then there is more to consider but otherwise who cares? Then again if you were doing that you'd know your chamber dimensions and be trimming to that and not SAAMI.

I use AA2230 with 50 grain VMAX (not cannelures) or 55 grain bulk with Cannelures and both are fine.
 
You can seperate them and crimp accordingly and that will work. Eventually the short ones will grow. I have over the years tried all my rifle ammo for accuracy both with and without crimps. My most accurate ammo is without a crimp. I only crimp ammo that is used in tubular magazines. If you do things correctly the neck tension will hold your bullet fine. I agree that a quality bullet will do 10X more for accuracy than neck length and/or crimping every time.
Years ago I was taught that as long as at least one caliber of bullet length was in contact with the side of the bullet you would get enough neck tension and were good to go.
 
With the Lee FCD you don't need to worry about the shorter ones and crimping. I trim all my .223 brass to 1.745ish and use a Lee FCD on all of my blaster ammo, works great. I don't usually crimp my "accuracy" ammo. Out of the powders/bullets you listed I've had good luck with 75/77's and AA2520, and great luck with AA2230 on the 50-62gr. Not much experience with 68/69gr, my rifles don't seem to care for them.
 
The shorter cases will be perfectly fine to use. Won't affect anything at all. The cartridge seats off on the neck of the chamber when fired.
I have the same trimmer and do get very good consistency in OAL
 
Like the others have said, don’t worry about it.

I used to be super picky about brass length, and still kinda am. I still trim all my rifle brass to “trim length” every time.
but if I chuck one up into my vintage Lyman universal trimmer and the cutter doesn’t touch the mouth, I’ll still give it a pass with the de-burr tool, then toss it into the trimmed pile, and never give them another worry about it.
 
That's an impressive trimmer, achieving 5 ten-thousandths repeatedly. You're in a temperature controlled metrology laboratory right?


I'd suggest you go shoot. You're wasting time chasing variation that's meaningless for your application.

Once you're below 1 MOA, and pushing for 0.5 MOA, you might want to do a study to see if short vs long brass is detectable on target; I'll cheat and tell you that it is not detectable at that level.

Work on bullet quality and powder selection, and then go practice.

I figured out how to turn that crank handle, and when to stop after about 300 cases, I keep it clean with a dab of oil, you can feel it when its done trimming. Believe me, I'm impressed with it also.
 
Can you let us know what rifle platform you are using? Also the load data, powder and bullet.

AR platform, .223 wilde barrels 16 and 18 " one of those B.A. Hanson premium ones. adj. gas block, Geisselle trigger, I have others also. 6x pst gen 2 scope, I will graduate sooner or later to a better barrel. It can shoot 1 m.o.a. at 100y. with factory IMI 77g. smk's
 
I guess I'm kind of trying to cheat a little bit by the asking of powder recco's - I forgot to mention S.W. precision rifle powder, Norma 203b, tac, 4198, 4064, and I'm trying to get some 3031.
I know, I'm all over the place with powder, but with primers being so hard to pick up, I'm buying powders when I see a lower than usual price.
I don't have much in the way of work ups yet, my range fodder is just using middle of the road load data, 55 gr. 62g. berry's and rmr's. figured I'd try em all out.

I take it, that as long as the bullet is down in, and close to being as deep as the neck is deep, I shouldn't worry a bit? I do a hard press check against the bench, they don't ever budge, and I beat like hell to remove a bullet from the case if I have to.
That was my main question -
 
as far as saami length, I don't know what my chamber is, and I'd be using these rounds in multiple AR's
what I use is the Sheridan slotted case gauge. I keep the depth I size to at the B ridge and below the top of the gauge, for not wanting to size it down too much. It chambers fine in my barrels.
 
A couple things I didn't see mentioned:

#1 if it bothers you, cut them down and convert to 300BLK

#2 have you tried priming any? They may have been gifted for a reason :) I've never seen LC nickel and haven't used much FC nickel, but have a crap ton of Speer nickel 5.56 - all from Gold Dot factory ammo. The primer pockets are excessively tight. Makes perfectly good ammo, just much harder to work with. Swaging doesn't help - these all went thru a 1050, then the super swage 600 - so not a crimp removal issue, just a very tight pocket. No idea about yours, but might want to check and get them out of the mix now if they're going to be problems their whole life.
 
forgot to mention S.W. precision rifle powder, Norma 203b, tac, 4198, 4064, and I'm trying to get some 3031.

Midsouth shooters supply has 8# jug imr 4031 earlier this afternoon, not sure if still in stock now or not. I've used cases as short as 1.735 without issue, didn't mean to trim that short but it happened.

Picked up some 62 HR hpbt bullets that I'm doing load development for, if I can ever get to the range, have 6 other sets of loads to shoot in 5.56/223 plus several in 7mm08, 303 Brit, 3006 and 243 win. Seems like it'll take a month of Sunday's to get it done
 
Good advice has been posted already. I have a bit of the OCD myself and can really geek out on minute details, but I've never chased a number 4 slots after the decimal. The important thing is that they are all the same length (within what is reasonably attainable) since you plan to crimp.

FWIW, I trim all of my .223 brass to 1.740 with no issue (because I use an RCBS X-die, and that's what the instructions said to do) but that is irrelevant because the sizing die that you or I use doesn't matter.
 
A couple things I didn't see mentioned:

#1 if it bothers you, cut them down and convert to 300BLK

#2 have you tried priming any? They may have been gifted for a reason :) I've never seen LC nickel and haven't used much FC nickel, but have a crap ton of Speer nickel 5.56 - all from Gold Dot factory ammo. The primer pockets are excessively tight. Makes perfectly good ammo, just much harder to work with. Swaging doesn't help - these all went thru a 1050, then the super swage 600 - so not a crimp removal issue, just a very tight pocket. No idea about yours, but might want to check and get them out of the mix now if they're going to be problems their whole life.

your right on the tight pockets, I've swaged them on press, then I still had to use the rcbs pocket swager bit and then the k&n uniformer bit to get the primer pocket go-no go gauge to verify.

I'll be priming them this weekend.
 
Last edited:
Thanks chamokaneman - I guess this confirms the shorter length is g.t.g.
and it probably does not have much bearing on the accuracy of the round, as long as the bullet is seated straight in the cartridge.

I got the cases from my bro-in-law who is an instructor at the range, along with 20k more in brass. It's one of the reasons I got into reloading, plus the waived fee at the range, which goes out to 500 yards.

Thanks everyone for all your input..
 
I take it, that as long as the bullet is down in, and close to being as deep as the neck is deep, I shouldn't worry a bit? I do a hard press check against the bench, they don't ever budge, and I beat like hell to remove a bullet from the case if I have to.
That was my main question -
Correct. I’m not sure how experienced you are as a reloader, but check max COL for each gun to make sure they will chamber and you’ll also know bullet jump. Then load a couple without primer and powder, make sure they fit the mag and let the gun chamber them, then measure them again to make sure the bullet didn’t set back. Neck tension is set with the sizer/expander, not the crimp step. Your initial list of powders will do you well. Good luck.
 
I never needed a crimp on 223/5.56 reloads with proper neck tension/bullet hold. Loading for M16, Mini14 & AR180. After bullet seating , the necks outside diameter needs to get larger by a minimum of .002" This gives about 35 lbs bullet hold. https://www.sierrabullets.com/reload-basics/reloading-for-semi-autos-and-service-rifles/

Trim brass back .010" when it gets longer then 1.760" Brass can be reloaded when as short as 1.730" (SAAMI)
 
here's a few pics of my messy bench and the nickel brass.
 

Attachments

  • messy bench 1.jpg
    messy bench 1.jpg
    252.3 KB · Views: 26
  • nickel brass1.jpg
    nickel brass1.jpg
    170.1 KB · Views: 23
  • nickel brass 2.jpg
    nickel brass 2.jpg
    101.1 KB · Views: 22
here's a few pics of my messy bench and the nickel brass.

Nice entry level set up! (Kidding of course!)

Try keeping a clean reloading bench when competing in several different venues! Now that I'm retired from competition due to arthritis my goal for 2022 is a clean/organized reloading room. I gave up on 2020 and 2021!

As far as case OAL you getting control of that. Crimping seems to be a bit of personal preference. I don't crimp!

Nickle plated brass seems to be brittle and fail much sooner than un-plated brass.

Smiles,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top