How would you navigate this situation?... RE no firearms in bars

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 11, 2007
Messages
629
I attend a dance class and I carry concealed. The area around the building is bad! However, having mentioned this to several of the ladies who attend the class, I have not had one agree that it is even "not good". They have all said "it's a fine area", in essence. In about the first 6 months, I have personally experienced 3!! interactions/interviews that could have turned violent. These were while going out to eat after class with a friend or two. I have stopped going out in that area.

In my state, it is illegal for any non-LEO to carry a firearm into an area designated "over 21" by the liquor commission. I HATE this law :mad: Of course, I CAN legally go out to a restaurant and drink heavily while armed. No, I do not do that.

Lately, a group of the girls have started going out for a drink after class, walking 3 blocks to the bar. A couple of the guys go, and I am quite sure that none of the guys carry a gun. (I mean, it's dance class. Who would carry a gun, right? ...uh, besides me :)) The bar is a very nice, low-key blues bar with live music.

-I can't offer a ride to all the people. When I have heard them talk about driving, most of the girls just really want to walk instead of drive.
-I do not feel good about refusing to join them and just leaving them to walk alone.
-I cannot continue my carrying and walk down to the bar with them - not inside, per the law.

I could walk down to the bar with them, then hang around outside the bar alone until they are done, and then walk back with them. That would be very weird. In the end, the truth is that I carry for myself and not specifically for anybody else's protection. Just to be clear, I mean that I do not carry with the intent to protect anyone besides myself - I'm NOT stating that I would not be there for someone in a clear need of my help.

What would you do??
 
1) Why is the area considered bad? What were your 3 interactions/interviews that could have turned violent?

I mean, just because you think it is bad, doesn't mean it isn't bad.

2) Are you saying you want to be chivalrous and escort these ladies because you don't feel the area is safe enough to be walking?
 
... What would you do??

Begin by getting real with myself.

You say you are not carrying to protect others, only yourself. However it sure sounds to me like you are playing bodyguard to all those poor, ignorant, helpless ladies in that really bad part of town, where you have personally had serious altercations.

hmmmm Have you ever thought of seeking out a job with the Secret Service ?
 
If you've attempted to persuade these people that their actions are unwise and they do not agree with you then they have the right to CHOOSE to do something you consider unwise.

I'd say you've fulfilled your moral obligations (and I'm a great believer in the moral obligations that decent people owe each other as a part of a civilized society). You can only say, "Good-bye, hope to see you again next time," and leave them to the consequences of their own, reasoned decision. If it turns out badly for them its on their own heads.

As unhappy as you may be about any ill-consequences of their decision, you are not responsible for the choices other adults make. You've tried to warn them and offered your assistance. You've been turned down. Its out of your hands.
 
1. Say you're hungry, and suggest a restaurant instead. See who take you up on it.

2. Claim claustrophobia, allergy to cigarette smoke (that last doesn't work if you smoke), and stay outside. See who joins you. If no one--wrong crowd, guy.

3. Leave the gun home and take a knife, OC--whatever IS allowed.

4. Mention you left your jacket/phone/wallet/etc. in the car, lock your gun in the car (if that's legal) and rejoin them.

5. Write you state senator and mention that the law as it now stand puts an undue burden on young guys looking for a little...fun--serious cramp in your social scene!

PS: You're carrying in a dance class and they don't KNOW that? Not very fun dances, are they? :neener:
 
Believe it or not, the golden rule still applies

You say you are not carrying to protect others, only yourself. However it sure sounds to me like you are playing bodyguard to all those poor, ignorant, helpless ladies in that really bad part of town, where you have personally had serious altercations.

hmmmm Have you ever thought of seeking out a job with the Secret Service ?

Once in a while people still do nice things for nice people. It's decent of you to be concerned and keeping up the subtle 'this isn't the best part of town' routine may help, particularly if you're with them at the next "interview".

It isn't "legal" for folks to carry guns in National Parks but I've heard from about a dozen THRs that they "do it anyway". I'm not saying it's right or wrong. It's commendable that OP is at least concerned IMO.
 
1) Why is the area considered bad? What were your 3 interactions/interviews that could have turned violent?

I mean, just because you think it is bad, doesn't mean it isn't bad.

2) Are you saying you want to be chivalrous and escort these ladies because you don't feel the area is safe enough to be walking?
1- There are a lot of homeless and beggars. There are a few main streets that are very poorly lit. It is an area of OPEN drug use and sales. There have been some notable attacks in the past, in that area. ...in addition to my experiences.
-The most significant of the interviews is detailed HERE.
-I was also walking with a girl, behind a guy - we were kinda keeping our distance and he slowed his walk. When we caught up and walked around him, he started following and making remarks to the effect of "slicing heads off" or something like that. She was talking to me, but I was trying to pay attention to him.
-Another guy was just being an idiot and started yelling and making a scene because my friend and I walked around a light post rather than on the same side.
2- No, I am not saying that I want to be chivalrous and escort the ladies. I am saying that IF I were going with them, I would feel somewhat responsible for their safety. Since I am not going with them, I am concerned that something bad could happen very easily in that area.

You say you are not carrying to protect others, only yourself. However it sure sounds to me like you are playing bodyguard to all those poor, ignorant, helpless ladies in that really bad part of town, where you have personally had serious altercations.

hmmmm Have you ever thought of seeking out a job with the Secret Service ?
Thanks, but c'mon. I am only voicing my concern, not saying that I feel a duty to be there for them. (and see the end of this post for additional info)

As unhappy as you may be about any ill-consequences of their decision, you are not responsible for the choices other adults make. You've tried to warn them and offered your assistance. You've been turned down. Its out of your hands.
Yep, probably the only answer there is.

PS: You're carrying in a dance class and they don't KNOW that? Not very fun dances, are they?
Thanks for the suggestions above.
There are some ways to conceal in the class. 1- IWB behind the hip - works for me, but I have had girls put their hands there and exclaim "what is that?". I ride a motorcycle, so told them it's an MP3 player for music when I ride. 2- Undershirt-carry, like the Deep Concealment Should Holster, under a button-front shirt.
Pocket carry might work, if the gun was as small as my cell phone. Also, SOB would work as well as IWB, but I don't like it as much. Smart Carry would be a bad idea :)

Just take it anyway.
The deepest concealment method that I have, which would allow me to carry ANYWHERE, is not very good for concealing in the dance. That would be ankle carry, and there are dance steps where she is rubbing her feet around my ankles. I suppose I could return to the car and switch holsters.

Here is some important information regarding this situation. I left this out to get opinions without this tidbit...
They BEG me to come out with them, and I do like to join them. No, I am not a big drinker. I do not want to walk in that bad area, but I will drive and meet them there. (SEE? Evidence that I really do not consider myself a bodyguard :neener:) So, they are walking and in a dangerous area, and I am safe in my car. Now I'm not such a good-guy any more :eek: Know what I mean? Anyone need to change their answer now? :)
 
Last edited:
So, they are walking and in a dangerous area, and I am safe in my car.

If that's the case, why aren't you all driving to the bar together?

As a Washington State resident, I understand your dillema. I have occasionally found myself in that situation. The alternatives are:

Don't go to the bar.

Go, but leave your firearm locked in the car (and out of your control).

Go armed and break the law (which, of course, nobody on THR would advocate).
 
Last edited:
If that's the case, why aren't you all driving to the bar together?

As a Washington State resident, I understand your dillema. I have occasionally found myself in that situation. The alternatives are:

Don't go to the bar.

Go and leave your firearm locked in the car (and out of your control).

Go armed and break the law (which, of course, nobody on THR would advocate).
The girls just want to walk. I don't know, maybe they are trying to save the planet by saving gas?

Each time they go out, I insist that I won't be going. A couple times, they have begged me and broken me down. When I have gone, I have locked the gun in the car.

Riding a motorcycle with acquaintances who don't know that I carry, and ending up at a "bar" for lunch, makes this a very regular law that I encounter. It's just not secure to lock a gun in the tiny trunk of my motorcycle.

rainbowbob, in your opinion, is there any chance this law could ever be changed? I have thought about it and I just don't see it happening. I can imagine the lawmakers thinking to themselves - "You want us to encourage people to carry guns into bars?!?! There is NO reason for that!".
 
I would just forgo the gun and carry a knife, or maybe a surefire E2e or something. Bright, compact flashlight. Not as good as a gun, but it will blind people for a moment.
 
rainbowbob, in your opinion, is there any chance this law could ever be changed? I have thought about it and I just don't see it happening.

I don't see it happeneing for the reasons you iterate. There would have to be a compelling reason for law-makers to stick their necks out. Not likely in my lifetime. I can't complain too much because this state actually has better laws than so many others. It's still BS, though that if we want to go out with our friends we have to disarm.
 
Your commitment to obey gun laws is commendable. I had the same dilemma.

Either you are not able to carry everywhere you go, or you must alter your lifestyle to accomodate your carry needs.

I decided to not stop going to those places that were "over 21", but since I am not carrying in those places, my best defense is to avoid conflict and to run like hell at the first sign of trouble.

In my area the problems in bars etc are not with innocent bystanders. So, as best I can I avoid the situation where I would have to defend myself with a firearm.
 
Here is some important information regarding this situation. I left this out to get opinions without this tidbit...
They BEG me to come out with them, and I do like to join them. No, I am not a big drinker. I do not want to walk in that bad area, but I will drive and meet them there.

John Farnam said it best: "Don't go stupid places and don't hang out with stupid people." Even if they beg you. You've done what you should, warned them that they are walking through a bad neighborhood. It's up to you how much you're willing to risk to be in the company of stupid people, only you can judge that. As for me, I just don't go to bars. I've pretty much quit drinking, too. I save a lot of money and a lot of headaches that way. ;)
 
I would just forgo the gun and carry a knife, or maybe a surefire E2e or something. Bright, compact flashlight. Not as good as a gun, but it will blind people for a moment.
Thanks. I have that pretty well covered. I usually carry two knives (1 is illegal because it is a 2" fixed-blade :rolleyes:) and two flashlights. One light is low output and one is very high output - about 150 torch lumens.

I decided to not stop going to those places that were "over 21", but since I am not carrying in those places, my best defense is to avoid conflict and to run like hell at the first sign of trouble.
Certainly good advice, whether carrying or not! However, it is very tough to run away when you are in the company of a girl. She still won't forgive me for running away from the mugger last time :evil:

I used to also carry pepper spray (OC). That stopped in the summer because the stuff I like to carry (Fox) is a little too bulky to pocket carry with all my other things.
 
If you are dancing WITH the gun and your partner doesn't know about it something terrible could happen. What is wrong with you? She even touched your gun?? BE RESPONSIBLE. What if you have an AD because the gun drops? :fire::fire::fire:

VVVVVVVV Either way, how would you like for YOUR dance partner to be wearing a gun on them without telling you? It's just a matter of common courtesy I think. If you will be coming into close contact with someone else, do not wear your firearm or let them know. Am I wrong?
 
What is wrong with you? She even touched your gun?? BE RESPONSIBLE. What if you have an AD because the gun drops?

Whoa...calm down! A properly holstered weapon with a covered trigger guard will not AD simply by being brushed up against. Nor will it fly out of the holster. Or AD when dropped (with MOST modern firearms).
 
Is the penalty for carrying in the bar and being caught worse than losing your life, if you MUST go to the bar?

Laws should be obeyed. But some people (namely, my CHP instructor) advocate weighing the consequences of carrying in "prohibited" areas against what you have to lose if you don't carry there.
 
My CCW disappears in my pocket, I can even place my wallet in front of it. The bar I hang at has a restaurant many times full of cops, I sit at the bar section even though I only drink tea, my friend drinks alcohol. In my state, my gun should be in my car but since I am not boozing it up and no one can tell, I figure to do what's best and not wait for a Luby's to happen to me.
 
One point I didn't see mentioned was that it is a group that goes out to the bar or restaurant. It seems like based on your info that it is at least 5-6 that go out. While this does not guarantee anything, I would assume the odds of a mugging etc. go down with increasing group size. Safety in numbers as they say.
 
If you are dancing WITH the gun and your partner doesn't know about it something terrible could happen. What is wrong with you? She even touched your gun?? BE RESPONSIBLE. What if you have an AD because the gun drops?
The gun remains in a secure holster, with the trigger guard covered. There is no way for the gun to go off while in the holster. For the gun to fall out of the holster, someone would need to turn me upside down and shake me. I would make the claim that I AM responsible, regarding my carrying of a gun.

Oh, I also exaggerated when I may have said "some girls have touched...". I am very good friends with the instructor. She is the only one who has touched it, when she put her hand on my back, right above the butt of the gun.

VVVVVVVV Either way, how would you like for YOUR dance partner to be wearing a gun on them without telling you? It's just a matter of common courtesy I think. If you will be coming into close contact with someone else, do not wear your firearm or let them know. Am I wrong?
In my opinion, yes, I think you are wrong. If my dance partner was wearing a gun without telling me? Honestly, I would be very pleasantly surprised. She would be someone I would admire for having the forethought and maturity to take responsibility for her own safety!

...I figure to do what's best and not wait for a Luby's to happen to me.
I agree. I simply have to weigh the possibility of being made. That becomes very unlikely if I use a different holster.

Thanks all!
 
If the gun is concealed what's the problem? What is the penalty for carrying in a bar? We don't have anything like that here in CO, but if you're caught carrying concealed without a CCW the first offense is a misdemeanor, 2nd on up though is felony territory. Just have to weigh the consequences & slip on the big boy pants either way you decide.
 
If you think you can pull off being completely honest with them, do it. If they're worth hanging out with, they'll respect you for it.

If not, the best thing I could come up with is to tell them you have to run somewhere real quick (gas station for a drink, a friend's house to drop off the 'item' he/she left at your house) and will meet them there in a bit.

This is if you are willing to disarm and go into the bar to join them.

This is also assuming that you're as good of a liar as I. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top