ChronoCube
Member
Does anyone know why Texas has Shall-issue for concealed carry, but open carry is illegal? At least that's my understanding of TX law.
From the standpoint of behavior in today's society, I think it would be a Bad Thing, just due to idiots acting like idiots. I guess it would be a reprise of why it was outlawed in the 1880s, as lanternlad1 said.
I, personally, am against open carry as I deem it to be tactically irresponsible for those masses of us CHL licensees who are not trained to carry in such a manner (ie-weapon retention tactics and the like). I believe the element of surprise is the best means of defense available to those of us who carry but don't have tactical training.
Texas has had laws against handgun carry (concealed AND open) since the late 1800s. It wasn't until the CHL law passed in 1995 that it became possible to carry outside your house except in certain, poorly defined circumstances. It's still impossible to carry a handgun openly in public unless you are involved in a sporting activity in which the handgun is a commonly used weapon. Personally, I wouldn't carry to and from those activities unless I were willing and able to deal with being arrested although it's likely one could get the charges dropped in court.Texas has had laws against open carry on the books since the 1800's
Don't apologize, there isn't a proposal yet.GEM said:I haven't read the proposed open carry law, so I apologize.
Prince Yamato said:These are basically what I call "redneck laws"; same thing as prohibiting bar carry. Back 60 years ago ( or more ) some Bubba got drunk or mad or both, pulled out his colt .45, and shot someone who slandered his 'paw or kinfolk. To "solve" said problem, politicians banned open carry.
I've also heard that it prevented free blacks from carrying weapons to protect themselves after the Civil War.
You can open or concealed carry when taking part in sporting activity, such as hunting, fishing, or shooting, or going to and from those activities without a license.
Erm, right now Texas does not HAVE an "open carry" law as such so it could hardly be about to be "reversed" (the term is repealed. perhaps your friend from Silicon Gulch didn't know the difference). Actually, unless things have changed recently, no one has actually SPONSORED a bill to change the laws concerning unlawfully carrying weapons so unless and until some legislator DOES SO, it will not happen until 2011 at the earliest. I, for one, am not holding my breath. I have contacted my legislators and will continue to do so in an attempt to persuade them to sponsor such a bill.C5Cruiser said:My friend is here (in California) visiting from Austin and said that the open carry law in Texas may be reversed and that it is now in legislation to do so.
Texas has had laws against open carry on the books since the 1800's. Its not an anti-gun thing, it's just the way it is. It was originally started to stop cowboys from coming into town, getting drunk, and shooting the place up.
From the standpoint of behavior in today's society, I think it would be a Bad Thing, just due to idiots acting like idiots. I guess it would be a reprise of why it was outlawed in the 1880s, as lanternlad1 said.
Nail...head...win.My guess is that the laws were selectively enforced (depending on the race of the 'offender') in the beginning but that became impossible later on.
If you honestly believe the "open carry with restrictions" (which isn't really open) is gonna keep OC'rs from 'being hassled", you need to pull your head out of the sand and take a big breath of reality.calaaverasslim said:I signed the petition and hope they repeal the OC carry law but with restrictions. One of the above opinions stated that idiots witll still be idiots and that sure is true. The majority of us probably wouldn't OC that much, but it sure would be nice not to have to worry about being hassled if we stopped in the store.